Ian Williams might be just as good. What school does Karty play for? If you haven’t seen Williams, then you don’t know just how good he is. He’s got deep range as well. No sense and being bitter about someone’s opinion
I have seen both. Williams is excellent... no doubt. That being said, Karty has the best leg I have seen in my lifetime. The ball makes a completely different sound coming off his foot. I was with a well known football observer here in NC that saw the opening kickoff & literally said “oh my god, that sounded like a cannon.” I kinda laughed when I told him he missed it because it only about 7 or 8 yards into the endzone. He then hit one thru the uprights about 10 minutes later. It’s an NFL leg on a high school kid.
I’m not bitter. I’m stating a fact. I am confident enough to state it as such. I have video of him hitting from 45 with no step and from both 65 & 70 at the NUC this past January. I have shared those videos with a couple posters on here... CatholicCougs14 and Nepsy7.
You can say it is opinion and depends on who is doing the ratings. Fine, fair enough. He was ranked #1 as a Jr and the 247composite has him #1 going into this year.