Kentucky's Quarterback Situation

Play some D

Junior
Nov 14, 2008
1,183
342
0
Patrick Towles don't play defense. Our record might still be the same. Although I think we would have prolly beat Southern Miss. With that said, I most certainly think this offense, with Gran & Towles would be much better than we have seen so far.
 

Tomsong

Redshirt
Oct 2, 2016
29
16
0
You put a true stud QB on this roster and this team is off to the races... No doubt about it! Go CATS!
 

TBCat

Heisman
Mar 30, 2007
14,317
10,331
0
I don't see Barker being a factor the rest of this year considering the injury and surgery. If we need a second option at QB I think they have to look at Hoak. In fact it's probably just a matter of time before Johnson isn't able to go, I would start giving Hoak garbage time ASAP in preparation for that. We can't really worry about redshirts right now, we have more help on the way.
Totally agree. I don't see Barker recovering from back problems during the season. This sounds like an off season type of thing. Also Johnson isn't built for the punishment he will be taking. He might not go down for the entire season but I can easily see him being out for some series. Also even if he doesn't go down you want to rest him as much as possible. Even if there are no injuries that sideline him he will get dinged up enough to severely reduce his effectiveness.
 
Last edited:

docholiday51

Heisman
Oct 19, 2001
22,011
26,718
0
Totally agree. I don't see Barker recovering from back problems during the season. This sounds like an off season type of thing. Also Johnson is built for the punishment he will be taking. He might not go down for the entire season but I can easily see him being out for some series. Also even if he doesn't go down you want to rest him as much as possible. Even if there are no injuries that sideline him he will get dinged up enough to severely reduce his effectiveness.
Hopefully it doesn't happen but if Johnson goes down (even for a couple of series in either of the next 2 games then you have to think Hoak is the next guy up,depending on the situation later in the year that might change.

I haven't heard it discussed lately but I thought I heard the coaches say a while back the Hoak was getting the #2 reps in practice.
 

Beatle Bum

Heisman
Sep 1, 2002
39,902
60,276
113
Hartline didn't start out as a very good QB.

Harline may be a good comparator for Johnson. I think SJ will get better. He seems to have a solid ethic and stays relatively calm. Maybe too calm, at times. When he is able to see more of his progressions, I think he will be better. We recruit DL and OL Jucos at times, the former much more than the latter, and we do not expect much of them the first part of their first year, even when they get here in spring. I think we need to be patient with Stephen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: UKCatNnc

katfanuno

All-Conference
Apr 15, 2008
1,636
1,037
113
I think Johnson will be fine, as long as he can get his progressions down. I prefer him to towles or barker, johson doesn't appear to have happy feet
 

Deeeefense

Heisman
Staff member
Aug 22, 2001
44,073
51,037
113
I would like to see Johnson keep the ball on the read option (when the end contains) 3 or 4 times a game minimum. That will do a lot to help our running backs. I also think he is most dangerous when he is rolling out with run/pass options. I know they didn't want to do much of that against Bama but I think he should on the remaining teams on our schedule. He can be very effective if used properly.
 
Last edited:

shutzhund

All-Conference
Nov 19, 2005
29,202
2,619
0
I don't see Barker being a factor the rest of this year considering the injury and surgery. If we need a second option at QB I think they have to look at Hoak. In fact it's probably just a matter of time before Johnson isn't able to go, I would start giving Hoak garbage time ASAP in preparation for that. We can't really worry about redshirts right now, we have more help on the way.


I sort of agree but that will be throwing the lamb to the wolves. The qb situation has and is chaotic.
 
Oct 1, 2001
5,199
1,898
0
Both QB's just aren't very good. Johnson could be the starter if he was even serviceable at throwing the ball but he isn't. Against good defenses, they will take advantage and force containment on the outside and dare him to beat them with his arm. Which he won't do.

Barker. He's a huge question mark. Underdeveloped bc of the talent or the lack of talent he faced in high school. Throw in a back injury and he may never become the QB so many thought he would be in high school. Sad thing is, UK hasn't had a good QB since Mike Hartline. Until we do, the offense will have its up and downs.

For a school like UK to succeed in the SEC, it's vital to have a QB that can put points on the board by stretching the field. Just going to face too many good offenses and solid run defenses throughout the year.
Perhaps you would enlighten us as to this lad might be and how he will lead us to the promised land. I'll hang up and listen.
 

JasonRDunn

All-Conference
Jan 27, 2008
1,761
2,322
113
Sad thing is, UK hasn't had a good QB since Mike Hartline. Until we do, the offense will have its up and downs..

Hartline didn't start out as a very good QB.

Some great thoughts in this thread. I think the reality is that neither QB has a lot of experience and probably are not so incredibly talented that they can come in and be great from day one, regardless of how they performed in the Spring game. There were many folks on this board (at various times) that felt that both Andre Woodson and Mike Hartline were not SEC-quality QBs.

I think that both Johnson and Barker will get better with time. Will they be all-SEC, I am not sure. Will they help us win some games, I think that they can and probably will. But they (and we) need more time to figure out whether they are a long-termish solution.

On Johnson, I think he played more like an early Andre Woodson, as Andre had a bad habit of hanging on to the ball too long -- and was stripped several times for fumbles. I like how Johnson does appear calm in the pocket -- maybe too calm -- holding on to the ball too long.

Most likely, we will get to see both QBs more this year and can probably make a more informed decision on QB potential when that happens.
 

UKCatNnc

All-Conference
Sep 30, 2005
6,163
1,736
0
The jury is still out on Johnson but I think under the circumstances he has done a decent job. I just worry about his ability to make it through the year without injury.
Johnson was sandwiched pretty hard on that last 3rd down. This may have had a lot to do with the FG call on that last 4th down. Go Cats!!
 

Kats23

All-American
Nov 21, 2007
8,683
5,913
63
Perhaps you would enlighten us as to this lad might be and how he will lead us to the promised land. I'll hang up and listen.

I don't understand what you're asking for really. If you're asking me to name names his name was Mac Jones and he's not committed here no more
 

megablue

Heisman
Oct 2, 2012
13,439
12,973
113
Last edited:

willievic

All-American
Aug 28, 2005
6,167
7,111
0
UK's failure to recruit a QB for two years and a bad OC hire have crippled the offense. The offensive coaches we have now are very good but we don't have the talent we need.

ZCats, who was the bad OC hire. Brown went to Troy and is successful and Dawson is at USM, and they beat us. Gran is at UK, and our offense hasn't been that great. Seven points against Florida, and 6 against Alabama. One TD in two games won't cut it.

OLD STOLL FIELD GUY!
 
  • Like
Reactions: PowerofPelphrey

willievic

All-American
Aug 28, 2005
6,167
7,111
0
Jawon Pass is being red-shirted at Louisville, having chosen U of L over Alabama and Ohio State, among others. That's damn impressive, no matter who you root for, especially with Lamar Jackson only a sophomore. I sure wish Pass was at Kentucky.

Louisville Committed (7/16/15)

Offers List:
Alabama, Auburn. Clemson, Florida, Indiana, LSU, Miami (FL), Mississippi State, Missouri, North Carolina, North Carolina State, Notre Dame, Ohio State, Texas A&M, UCF, Virginia Tech

No UK offer! Not good enough for us?

OLD STOLL FIELD GUY!
 

Mr Schwump

Heisman
Nov 4, 2006
29,563
23,097
18
Jawon Pass is being red-shirted at Louisville, having chosen U of L over Alabama and Ohio State, among others. That's damn impressive, no matter who you root for, especially with Lamar Jackson only a sophomore. I sure wish Pass was at Kentucky.

Louisville Committed (7/16/15)

Offers List:
Alabama, Auburn. Clemson, Florida, Indiana, LSU, Miami (FL), Mississippi State, Missouri, North Carolina, North Carolina State, Notre Dame, Ohio State, Texas A&M, UCF, Virginia Tech

Then he's an idiot if he's as good as you all claim. If so he'd be starting for about half those teams as a true freshman.
 

megablue

Heisman
Oct 2, 2012
13,439
12,973
113
Then he's an idiot if he's as good as you all claim. If so he'd be starting for about half those teams as a true freshman.
The list of offers was taken directly from this website, under the recruiting tab for Louisville, so I assume it is legit. I remember seeing him in the East-West Army All-Star game and he was quite impressive, reminding me of a better-throwing version of Derrick Ramsey. Nonetheless, as I stated, it's quite impressive that he went to Louisville and was okay with red-shirting to wait his opportunity to fill the shoes of Lamar Jackson.

There's no question that he would be starting for us, for sure. Can't help but wonder if our record would've been any better, though, at this point...???

https://redragetailgate.com/2016/09/05/will-jawon-pass-redshirt-this-season/
 
Last edited:

Blue Decade

All-American
May 3, 2013
10,266
6,034
0
Barker started the season incredibly well. He was on fire the first half of SMU and then gave us a pretty good impersonation of Towles. He then subsequently broke his back over Bear Bryant's cursed knee. Metaphorically speaking.

Johnson stepped in and did a great job against NMSU but has since shown that he is really.... Really..... Okay? He offers an extra dimension but stays in collapsing pockets for too long and doesn't seem to know when to scramble. I think Hinshaw is working with him to correct these issues, but Johnson doesn't seem to have the vision or quick release that Barker did.

I have to wonder how much Barker's chronic back injury played into the equation of his worsened performance and if he could come back this season to spark an offensive rush. There were several throws in the Bama massacre that Johnson didn't make, didn't see, and didn't throw away that I think Barker would have. Barker can't scramble like Johnson, but he can be more decisive and get the ball out quicker. Maybe a healed back would help.

I'm not sold on Johnson. I think he does some good things, but I'll be incredibly interested to see Barker return and how teams (both ours and opponents) react. We're beginning to see defense turn things around and I think we go bowling if offense can do literally anything. We've seen the run game become a major factor, and that's something we didn't display as prominently when Drew was taking snaps.
Drew Barker has had 5 starts and, overall, has played surprisingly poorly. But Barker is only a sophomore. He has an NFL quarterback's body, and a good arm. Barker hasn't yet shown an ability to recognize coverages or put together a full game of solid play, but it's possible that he can still learn to do those things. The problem with Barker is the back injury. Once a young quarterback suffers a significant back injury, they are seldom the same again. Steve Johnson is a 2nd string quarterback from a juco. He is an emergency quarterback, who was probably never intended to be the starter. Johnson has started 2 SEC games, and he is 1-1. Johnson has poor fundamentals and almost no experience. He will improve with more playing opportunities, but he only weighs 180 pounds. Right now, Gunnar Hoak is the future. But if Kentucky signs Danny Clark and Jarren Williams, those 2 will change the future for the quarterback position.
 

redbudman

Sophomore
Apr 10, 2007
7,027
184
0
Didn't the kid from Ohio who had been committed to Ohio St. for 2 years there just visit us! ( can't think of his name) But Vince Marrow has stayed in touch and we are the favorites! I say
go ahead and play Hoak if he is good enough!
 
  • Like
Reactions: PowerofPelphrey

Blue Decade

All-American
May 3, 2013
10,266
6,034
0
Didn't the kid from Ohio who had been committed to Ohio St. for 2 years there just visit us! ( can't think of his name) But Vince Marrow has stayed in touch and we are the favorites! I say
go ahead and play Hoak if he is good enough!
Hoak is redshirting, and that's a good thing. You are thinking of Danny Clark.
 

BIGBLUEQ

Senior
Jun 22, 2003
1,321
549
0
I would like to see Johnson keep the ball on the read option (when the end contains) 3 or 4 times a game minimum. That will do a lot to help our running backs. I also think he is most dangerous when he is rolling out with run/pass options. I know they didn't want to do much of that against Bama but I think he should on the remaining teams on our schedule. He can be very effective if used properly.

I think you are correct, when he moves the pocket and rolls out he is pretty good throwing on the run
 
  • Like
Reactions: megablue

tuck66

Freshman
Sep 26, 2016
261
91
0
Luke Wright Looked really comfortable to me in the spring game. Didn't get many opportunities, but the 1 deep ball he threw was dead on the money (wasn't caught beacause of a good defensive play) ! He also probably knows this offense inside and out since he came to UK from Cinci. with Gran & Hinshaw. I look for him to get a shot at some point if Johnson can't hold onto the bean!
 

WildcatofNati

Heisman
Mar 31, 2009
8,183
12,420
0
Luke Wright Looked really comfortable to me in the spring game. Didn't get many opportunities, but the 1 deep ball he threw was dead on the money (wasn't caught beacause of a good defensive play) ! He also probably knows this offense inside and out since he came to UK from Cinci. with Gran & Hinshaw. I look for him to get a shot at some point if Johnson can't hold onto the bean!
I know very little about Wright. If he's at all competent, then I would prefer him to throwing Hoak to the wolves (and burning a crucial redshirt), if Johnson gets hurt.
 

buckkiller

All-Conference
Nov 6, 2003
131,233
2,466
0
UK's failure to recruit a QB for two years and a bad OC hire have crippled the offense. The offensive coaches we have now are very good but we don't have the talent we need.

Love Gran and Hinshaw and woukd not be upset if Stoops does get fired. HAVE the incoming coach keeps these 2 around. They do not have much to work with from QB spot right now. I like what they are doing with the backs no doubt.
 

zcats

Heisman
May 29, 2001
38,094
40,312
98
ZCats, who was the bad OC hire. Brown went to Troy and is successful and Dawson is at USM, and they beat us. Gran is at UK, and our offense hasn't been that great. Seven points against Florida, and 6 against Alabama. One TD in two games won't cut it.

OLD STOLL FIELD GUY!
Dawson was on the rocks with Stoops the first week of the season and by mid season was accepted to be on his way out. His play calling, use of personnel and teamwork were clearly destructive to what UK needed. I would call that a bad hire. Maybe he beat us at USM but beating UK is nothing to write home about.

On the other hand, you picked Florida and Bama to judge our offense? They are the 7th and 11th ranked defenses in the country and both games were on the road. Believe me I don't like where our program is one bit but the bar you set is ridiculously high. A lot of good offensive football teams would struggle to get 7 points in those games much less a program which has been flirting with free fall like UK.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tuck66