So no one has a real answer? Everyone has sarcasm but no solid reasoning.
My thoughts, firing Stoops actually sets the program back and shows no commitment. He gets a minimum of one more year to get to the magical 6 wins. If he doesn't, then we look. However, I'm not sure any coach is going to give is what we want.
When has Kentucky prematurely ran off coaches? 90% of the time you will know whether or not it will work out with a coach within three years. You shouldn't be getting walloped by multiple teams in your conference if you are moving in the right direction. We have gotten beat down pretty bad against UT, UGA, Florida, and Louisville in years three and four.
Brooks had a decent run here, but the difference with him and Stoops is that he did have previous results as a head coach to justify a year or two more. Even with him though, recruiting tailed off pretty bad at the end and he didn't leave it in great shape.
I think you actually can't afford to ride in mediocrity here hoping it works out. MB needs to only reward actual on the field results and not get stuck with poor coaches that he can't move out. Petrino or even Leach would of been so much better hires than this mess.
They only two options you have here is to either hire a proven coach with a little baggage or hope to find a head coach from a small conference. The Stoops name was hot a decade ago and for some reason no other program was interested in the Stoops that is here.