While I appreciate the view and sentiment to some degree, I’m not sure it is all that accurate. Surely there has been addictive driven carnage within Rock and Rap. That also applies to Jazz and even the more spiritually based R&B (of which I’m a big fan). There is a long list of R&B performers who developed addictive and destructive over indulgence behaviors. To say that Rockers were suicidal and Rappers homicidal, that is a very generalized and I think overall inaccurate take on things. Millions of all types of people listen to Rock and Rap and certainly are not drawn to suicidal and homicidal tendencies. For me personally, Rap and Hip Hop music doesn’t “move” me emotionally at all. Neither does very heavy, distorted Heavy Metal music. The Rock , R&B soul based music I listen to is the true thing in life that nourishes my spirit. Formal religion does not do that for me. My belief is that the music of all those “suicidal, homicidal” artists does a lot more saving and healing than any clergy, political or other “leader” could possibly do.
I never liked Jazz much either - the pop jazz is ok.
Yes there is tragedy among R&B but not like rockers and rappers.
When I was a kid and first listened to Zeppelin I felt dirty lol (I grew to like Stairway though),
Earth, Wind and Fire, Stylistics, Chi-Lites, Temptations, Dianna Ross, Stevie, Isley Brothers, Aretha, 5th Dimension, Kool & the Gang and others - not a lot of short lives or ODs in that crowd.
They used to dress sharp and and used nice lyrics. Compare Marilyn McCoo to the Megan the Stallion. Its like all class vs all a$$.
The black churches were the place for black people to socialize and music was more a part of that than other churches/groups. Rhiannon Giddens often talks about how Americans have lost their traditional music learning and cant even sing Happy Birthday well. That wasn't not true of black churches. My town was mixed and my sports teams where 30-40% black and on bus rides home or around campfires they could all sing like crazy because they learned as kids.
I suspect a lot of that is gone now because the rappers aren't generally trained in church. Nobody despised rap as much as the black grandparents that came-up from the South after the 60s.
List of murdered hip hop musicians
en.wikipedia.org