Toggle sidebar

OT: Is Aaron Judge the second coming of Babe Ruth?

K

Kbee3

Heisman
Aug 23, 2002
43,724
35,255
0
TMCB said:
Mets pitchers allowed 1 run a game over last 6. As we get healthy mets will head to playoffs for 3rd yr in a row. Mets have great pitching but injuries have caused a few bumps.
Click to expand...

Maybe the mets just hit some teams that were struggling offensively at the time. Every team has hot and cold streaks. Mets team ERA is 12th of 15 teams in the National League thus far this season...after 60 games. Why you would talk of the playoffs for the Amazins is kinda hard to figure.
And I know their fans are just anticipating the next starter to go on the DL. I'm guessing Degrom.
Besides, everybody knows the Yankees own this town.
 
CranfordKnight

CranfordKnight

All-Conference
Jun 23, 2006
4,056
3,885
113
TMCB said:
Mets pitchers allowed 1 run a game over last 6. As we get healthy mets will head to playoffs for 3rd yr in a row. Mets have great pitching but injuries have caused a few bumps.
Click to expand...

Lot of teams for the Mets to climb over. I think they are further from a WC than the division. The NL West is crazy good at the top this year. And if you are being honest, the Mets pitchers aren't much more proven than Judge. Unless you are counting on Harvey to be good again.
 
T

TMCB

Senior
Jul 25, 2001
7,592
575
0
CranfordKnight said:
Lot of teams for the Mets to climb over. I think they are further from a WC than the division. The NL West is crazy good at the top this year. And if you are being honest, the Mets pitchers aren't much more proven than Judge. Unless you are counting on Harvey to be good again.
Click to expand...
Cesp bruce and conforto more proven than judge. Mets pitching will be fine, degrom complete game, wheeler good all yr, matz throws a gem, lugo a gem, harvey gaining arm strength as expected, thor will be rested. The biggest ques is familia, does he come back this yr? Mets have bats and rosarrio will be here soon. Yes they have a few teams to climb over but Mets are talented. 100 games to go.......
 
C

csphi

Heisman
Jul 26, 2001
17,185
18,987
102
TMCB said:
Cesp bruce and conforto more proven than judge. Mets pitching will be fine, degrom complete game, wheeler good all yr, matz throws a gem, lugo a gem, harvey gaining arm strength as expected, thor will be rested. The biggest ques is familia, does he come back this yr? Mets have bats and rosarrio will be here soon. Yes they have a few teams to climb over but Mets are talented. 100 games to go.......
Click to expand...
Conforto proven......HAAAAA
 
M

matty666

All-American
Dec 18, 2004
38,177
7,647
108
RUPartisan said:
Ah yes, thank you for reminding everyone why yankees fans are so annoying. He is having a good rookie season. Cant you just leave it at that?
Click to expand...


Yeah. No thank God no teams have fans that say crazy or
Dumb stuff. We can bet from your post your favorite team has at least one annoying fan.
 
B

Big East Beast

All-Conference
Jul 26, 2001
7,486
3,608
72
Some random thoughts:

Judge has 50 lbs on Dave Winfield. He's a very large human.

Obviously, the Ruth comparison is click-bait. When I look at him, I can't help but think he's the love child of Jose Canseco & Mark McGwire.

I endured the Ordonez - Jeter nonsense as well. It wasn't in jest.

I just hope Judge is clean and keeps it up because there's no doubt it's exciting every time he steps to the plate.
 
C

chase07470

All-American
Oct 16, 2010
10,099
8,344
113
The Ruthian pace continues...30 home runs before all star break. New Yankee rookie HR record with half a season to go. Too bad the bullpen imploded and key pieces in the middle of the order are on the bench...
 
K

knightfan7

Heisman
Jul 30, 2003
93,411
67,234
113
chase07470 said:
The Ruthian pace continues...30 home runs before all star break. New Yankee rookie HR record with half a season to go. Too bad the bullpen imploded and key pieces in the middle of the order are on the bench...
Click to expand...

Bullpen has been a horror show for almost a month now. They started off so well that the collapse is head scratching.

Judge is half a season away from striking out every other AB. Let's not make that Cooperstown plaque just yet. The thing is he's so strong when he makes contact the ball goes a long, long way.

I heard a stat that at one point across MLB there had been 47 times where exit velocity off the bat has been faster than 115mph. Of those 47 times, Judge had 17 of them.
 
PiscatawayMike

PiscatawayMike

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
16,961
14,446
113
knightfan7 said:
Judge is half a season away from striking out every other AB. Let's not make that Cooperstown plaque just yet. The thing is he's so strong when he makes contact the ball goes a long, long way.

I heard a stat that at one point across MLB there had been 47 times where exit velocity off the bat has been faster than 115mph. Of those 47 times, Judge had 17 of them.
Click to expand...
Judge's HRs are not what impresses me most. It's that his OBP is .448. Simply incredible for a right-handed hitter in this day and age. I could not care less if every one of his outs is a K if he keeps up his current pace.
 
  • Like
Reactions: daneman100
K

knightfan7

Heisman
Jul 30, 2003
93,411
67,234
113
Don't want to anticipate too much and be disappointed but Judge should put on quite a show in the HR Derby (Monday?)
 
R

RUBOB72

All-American
Aug 5, 2004
23,385
7,924
0
Happy for Yankees but keep in mind he needs to stay healthy and that's # 1 ... Judge must continue to adjust to the changes which teams will make going forward...the Yankees must have someone else in the lineup to protect against pitching around him...a true physical specimen who must also be able to withstand a major slump...at some point that will happen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NickyNewark51
R

RUhasarrived

All-Conference
May 7, 2007
8,035
2,037
0
One note of caution:In 1985,Bob Gibson observed Dwight Gooden,then stated:"Dwight Gooden will never again be as good as he is right now."

Judge has a weakness for pitches up in the zone.If the pitchers can consistently place the ball there,he won't be as dominant as he is now.
 
B

batts

All-Conference
Jun 6, 2001
6,859
1,148
113
RUhasarrived said:
One note of caution:In 1985,Bob Gibson observed Dwight Gooden,then stated:"Dwight Gooden will never again be as good as he is right now."

Judge has a weakness for pitches up in the zone.If the pitchers can consistently place the ball there,he won't be as dominant as he is now.
Click to expand...

Judge is a very serious student of hitting. You have to think that he will work on his weaknesses.

You have to love the Yankees' future with players like Judge, Sanchez, Frazier and Gregorius.
 
R

ruready4somefootball_rivals

All-Conference
Nov 10, 2003
11,777
3,298
0
Proud NJ Sports Fan said:
Judge is the next Great Yankee.

Hall of Fame is in his cards.
Click to expand...
 
C

chase07470

All-American
Oct 16, 2010
10,099
8,344
113
I've seen enough of his hand eye, balance, bat speed and pitch selection to ease any flash in teh pan concerns. He's so long that he can stand off the plate and take away the inside pitch while still being long and quick enough to handle the outside stuff. Scary as it may seem, I think he only gets better. In terms of injuries....he's young. Chances of the freak injury, yes but 90% odds he's in the middle of that line up for 10 years.

As someone else said, he just smokes the ball...line drives go out of the park, fly balls go out of the park...WHat if he hits 65 HR's his rookie year? It's possible.
 
czxqa

czxqa

All-American
Oct 31, 2008
8,593
6,825
113
The rookie home run record is 49, by McGwire for the A's. It's stood for 30 years. Vegas is giving 5-2 odds on Judge hitting 50. Rookies are notorious for second half slumps, but somehow Judge seems different. It will be fun to watch, that's for sure
 
R

RUMBA-JK

All-Conference
Jun 13, 2014
2,717
1,606
0
Looking forward to the Home Run Derby - but with a bit of apprehension - - a number if players have had the Derby take the wind out of their sails for weeks afterward.

Has to have a high potential to mess with some players heads - every pitch grooved to them - just have to wallop it & the temptation must be to tee-off on every one - at then end ... I'd much rather see Judge emerge with his mechanics intact than some trophy - but if he can do both great!
 
RULoyal

RULoyal

Heisman
Jul 28, 2001
14,886
17,614
113
RUMBA-JK said:
Looking forward to the Home Run Derby - but with a bit of apprehension - - a number if players have had the Derby take the wind out of their sails for weeks afterward.

Has to have a high potential to mess with some players heads - every pitch grooved to them - just have to wallop it & the temptation must be to tee-off on every one - at then end ... I'd much rather see Judge emerge with his mechanics intact than some trophy - but if he can do both great!
Click to expand...
Isn't every pitch grooved in normal BP everyday? Although they may not try to hit an HR on every swing.
 
R

RUMBA-JK

All-Conference
Jun 13, 2014
2,717
1,606
0
RULoyal said:
Isn't every pitch grooved in normal BP everyday? Although they may not try to hit an HR on every swing.
Click to expand...

"Grooved" ? well considering that the intent is it try to work on the hitter' skill - there is some effort to put a bit of a challenge into the process - to mix in kinds of pitches where the hitter "needs improvement"
- that is why they call it "Batting Practice" ... and not "Home Run Practice"
 
RULoyal

RULoyal

Heisman
Jul 28, 2001
14,886
17,614
113
RUMBA-JK said:
"Grooved" ? well considering that the intent is it try to work on the hitter' skill - there is some effort to put a bit of a challenge into the process - to mix in kinds of pitches where the hitter "needs improvement"
- that is why they call it "Batting Practice" ... and not "Home Run Practice"
Click to expand...
You must have stayed at a Holiday Inn Express last night.
 
NewJerseyHawk

NewJerseyHawk

Heisman
Jan 11, 2007
23,958
37,746
113
Judge is a freakish athlete that is playing at a high level, in a ballpark that allows right center field power....you can't pitch him away and expect to get him out and he's showing plate discipline.

I'm as far from a Yankee fan as anyone, but he's more than what the Yankees had in Jeter or the "Core 4"....he is right now an icon in a dying sport for media coverage, in the right media market. Giancarlo Stanton has been doing this for 4-5 years now in South Florida and is the standard of what to expect for Judge, but is just now getting his due with the general public..... If Stanton's first 4-5 years were in Yankee Stadium, this conversation would be drastically different....Stanton would already have a statue outside Yankee Stadium.....Let's get Judge through a couple of seasons before crowning him, he's not Stanton.....yet.....
 
A

Abro1975

Heisman
Nov 21, 2009
24,499
12,979
0
NewJerseyHawk said:
Judge is a freakish athlete that is playing at a high level, in a ballpark that allows right center field power....you can't pitch him away and expect to get him out and he's showing plate discipline.

I'm as far from a Yankee fan as anyone, but he's more than what the Yankees had in Jeter or the "Core 4"....he is right now an icon in a dying sport for media coverage, in the right media market. Giancarlo Stanton has been doing this for 4-5 years now in South Florida and is the standard of what to expect for Judge, but is just now getting his due with the general public..... If Stanton's first 4-5 years were in Yankee Stadium, this conversation would be drastically different....Stanton would already have a statue outside Yankee Stadium.....Let's get Judge through a couple of seasons before crowning him, he's not Stanton.....yet.....
Click to expand...

Hawk, Stanton is an amazing player, no doubt, but Trout may be the best player in baseball. Compare their stats, Trout hits almost the same HRs, almost same RBIs , more runs scored, better average than Stanton in an average year.

http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/s/stantmi03.shtml

http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/t/troutmi01.shtml
 
Last edited:
M

mikebal9

All-Conference
Oct 15, 2005
5,731
4,961
113
Where did he say Stanton is the best player in baseball? All he said was that he's the best comp for Judge, which is true.
I have to say, this thread is really funny.
 
A

Abro1975

Heisman
Nov 21, 2009
24,499
12,979
0
mikebal9 said:
Where did he say Stanton is the best player in baseball? All he said was that he's the best comp for Judge, which is true.
I have to say, this thread is really funny.
Click to expand...

Hawk didn't say it, I didn't say he did, but I'm saying Trout probably is. The combination of power, average, speed, defense.

Stanton has never hit 40 HRs in a season once, and only knocked in 100 RBIs once. . Trout has hit 40 HRs and knocked in 100 RBIs twice. Scores more runs too.
 
T

tico brown

Heisman
Oct 16, 2005
43,278
13,311
93
jmc11201 said:
Seems really impressive so far. Quite a job by Yankee management to building a very good and young team so quickly. I'm not a Yankee fan, but you have to give credit where due. Could be a dangerous team for a long time with some of the younger guys they have assembled.
Click to expand...
They have a good young core whonhas the potential to be great. If they can find some young pitchers to match, this may be a great one for at least 5 years. Not a fan but hope they spend their FA money wisely (esp for pitchers) instead of signing one player to a $400 Million contract simply because theyre the Yankees.
 
C

chase07470

All-American
Oct 16, 2010
10,099
8,344
113
A lot of people saying, "put on the breaks!" regarding what this half season means. How about a game of "I told you so!" predict Judge's final HR/RBI/AVG season totals.

55/126/.308
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom