OT: USAA Insurance Alternatives

Dawgg

Heisman
Sep 9, 2012
10,127
10,136
113
So, I live in Texas and I’ve pretty much always had USAA for home and auto insurance, but I’m coming up on renewal next month and I’m thinking of shopping around.

Anybody have a favorite insurance they’d recommend?
 

HotMop

All-American
May 8, 2006
7,111
5,111
113
So, I live in Texas and I’ve pretty much always had USAA for home and auto insurance, but I’m coming up on renewal next month and I’m thinking of shopping around.

Anybody have a favorite insurance they’d recommend?
I switched to Progressive, USAA had horrible rates for Florida, it's at least one I'd get a rate from. I went through an independent agent who shopped around for me, saved about $4k a year in insurance, bundled everything with them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dawgg

Villagedawg

All-Conference
Nov 16, 2005
1,566
1,353
113
Looked at USAA recently. Progressive auto with Farmers home through independent agent beat USAA pretty well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dawgg

TaleofTwoDogs

All-Conference
Jun 1, 2004
3,973
1,704
113
Had USAA for years in Texas but the rates got to high so I switched to Farmers and saved a bunch. Moved back to the 'Sip in '23 but Farmer's was not licensed here so I switched to Travelers which had similar rates. Unfortunately, Traveler's rates jumped this year and I switched back to USAA and saved 25% over Travelers. Talking about going full circle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dawgg
Aug 22, 2012
277
235
43
Had USAA for years in Texas but the rates got to high so I switched to Farmers and saved a bunch. Moved back to the 'Sip in '23 but Farmer's was not licensed here so I switched to Travelers which had similar rates. Unfortunately, Traveler's rates jumped this year and I switched back to USAA and saved 25% over Travelers. Talking about going full circle.
Farmers sells in Mississippi under their Foremost brand. Competitive rates in MS. Having an auto claim serviced now and it’s been great experience. Give them a shot through an independent agent.
 

The Peeper

All-American
Feb 26, 2008
14,612
9,329
113
Two current policy holders I know say they are tired of USAA home and car and are shopping. They had no complaints with health insurance though.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
54,570
22,704
113
Have a good friend with USAA and they totaled 3 brand new cars in 8-12 months and USAA somehow didn't drop them. They're fans for life
Yeah. You might find cheaper premiums. But that's a terrible way to choose an insurance company. What matters is how they pay claims. I've had a few over the years and it's been easy every time.
 

JY1947

All-Conference
Oct 5, 2023
994
1,138
93
Yeah. You might find cheaper premiums. But that's a terrible way to choose an insurance company. What matters is how they pay claims. I've had a few over the years and it's been easy every time.
yep, all claims for them have been paid no questions asked really.
 

johnson86-1

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
13,866
4,384
113
USAA is high as a cat's back, but they pay claims. Several years ago, a hailstorm hit our neighborhood, USAA overpaid for my roof, folks with State Farm weren't treated as well.
State Farm treating their "customers" poorly? I shan't believe it. I just shan't.
 

Trojanbulldog19

All-American
Aug 25, 2014
9,694
5,412
113
State Farm treating their "customers" poorly? I shan't believe it. I just shan't.
State Farm has always paid my claims on vehicle insurance no problems. They didn't cover homes in my area or they would be my insurance company for that too. They services me through using another company insurance that keeps going up crazy high so I dropped them for usaa. But never had a problem when I had State Farm in another location where they carried home insurance
 

johnson86-1

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
13,866
4,384
113
State Farm has always paid my claims on vehicle insurance no problems. They didn't cover homes in my area or they would be my insurance company for that too. They services me through using another company insurance that keeps going up crazy high so I dropped them for usaa. But never had a problem when I had State Farm in another location where they carried home insurance
I think they are actually ok on vehicle claims. But even if they pay 90% of homeowners claims on the up and up, that's a lot of money to pay every year to have just a 90% chance of them not 17ing you if you ever have a significant claim. If you can't afford to self fund a lawsuit without hiring a lawyer on contingency, you arguably can't afford to have State Farm insurance on your home.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trojanbulldog19

Dawgg

Heisman
Sep 9, 2012
10,127
10,136
113
I can’t complain about USAA’s claim payments or service. 100%, they are super easy to deal with. Our costs are going to skyrocket with the next renewal in December (we’ve had a roof claim and added a teen driver… who promptly had a fender bender, so some of that’s expected) and I just think it’s worth shopping around.
 

Trojanbulldog19

All-American
Aug 25, 2014
9,694
5,412
113
I think they are actually ok on vehicle claims. But even if they pay 90% of homeowners claims on the up and up, that's a lot of money to pay every year to have just a 90% chance of them not 17ing you if you ever have a significant claim. If you can't afford to self fund a lawsuit without hiring a lawyer on contingency, you arguably can't afford to have State Farm insurance on your home.
Team I'm sure you are right. I had renters insurance with them a long time ago and they paid out when my apart ent building burned down. Although I got pissed that the agent kept asking if there was anything salvageable and she even drove out there to look. It was all over news too.
 

msualohadog

Senior
Oct 25, 2014
402
542
93
I dropped USAA for Farmers about 5 years ago. Farmers ended up being the most polite set of claims reps to tell me they weren't going to honor my claims. I ended up going back to USAA.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

HammerOfTheDogs

All-Conference
Jun 20, 2001
10,670
1,438
113
USAA is super. Had serious water damage to my house. Had to stay in a temporary apartment for 5 months. totally rebuilt the inside of my house. All I had to pay was the deductible.

Also has free towing service. Saved me and my family from a ton of headaches and hassles.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog