Smoking a bird- to brine or not to brine?

ctdub

All-American
Dec 11, 2003
14,313
5,513
112
I've done one before without brining and it came out pretty good. What are your all thoughts? What about injections?
 

JimmyBob

Heisman
May 29, 2001
17,344
22,135
93
Brine, 86 the injections. Have Ken Schaefer's (Boston Deli) recipe for brining pork, and have books from several courses at Hasty-Bake classes. Too many beers to find now - lol - but tomorrow is another day!
 

GreenEggPoke

Redshirt
Sep 29, 2008
253
7
0
Google Mad Max Turkey. Been using it for years...good stuff. He does't brine and I don't either (same reasons...no room to do it). But the man has a good set up and recipe.
 

Orange Jennyslipper

All-Conference
Jan 4, 2005
9,673
2,021
0
My family won't let me smoke a turkey without it. You can put a dark brown on the skin, cook the bird thoroughly and the meat will still gush juice when you slice it. No comparison to dry smoking. Best ever.

Being able to submerge the bird in a 3- to 5-gallon bucket in a refrigerator is easiest, but if you're short on space, use a 2-1/2 gallon ziplock bag.

Put the turkey in the bag and place upright in an ice chest. Fill bag with brine to cover bird and zip bag. Keep chest iced overnight and smoke bird tomorrow.

Caution: no matter the brand, the ziplock zipper will not withstand the weight of a turkey and 2-3 gallons of brine. Just sayin'.

If your chest is big enough, you could use a food grade plastic bucket and put your ice outside the bucket. Don't dilute the brine.

Two notes: Don't use a trash bag for the brine and anyone who is on a reduced salt diet may find the smoked bird too salty. People who consume the normal American diet say it does not taste salty at all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marshal Jim Duncan
Dec 22, 2013
32,011
40,041
113
I do both personally - brine and injections of butter/broth. Melts in your mouth. This will be my 7th year doing it this way.
 

dtspoke

Heisman
Aug 18, 2003
21,899
27,069
113
We are smoking wild turkey's this week and we always brine them.

Also smoking an elk brisket for the first time. It will probably not work out, but giving it a shot
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marshal Jim Duncan

PDT816

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
11,490
3,527
113
The correct answer to this is don't brine a bird that was already brined when you bought it. Most birds you buy at the store are brined already.

I use a dry rub instead a couple hours before putting it on the smoker
 

BvillePoker

All-Conference
Dec 29, 2004
6,818
1,579
0
I always brine poultry overnight before smoking it. Poultry loses moisture very quickly during cooking. I also baste with a spray bottle of apple juice to create a "crust" to help keep moisture in. Please Please Please do not forget to cover with foil and wrap with towels to let the bird rest after smoking. Resting is the most important part of cooking meat and the thing people usually skip.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Orange Jennyslipper

hollywood

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
50,693
3,319
0
As PTD pointed out, you have to be careful when picking a turkey. It's not so easy to find a turkey that hasn't already been injected with a brining solution. You brine one of those and it will be way too salty to be enjoyable.
 

ctdub

All-American
Dec 11, 2003
14,313
5,513
112
Ok. Thanks for the advice. I guess I'll brine unless it's pre brined.