KSR Football
Starting professional baseball journey now is 'Option 1A' for Kentucky signee Matt Ponatoski

The MLB Draft is just a month away. Numerous Kentucky players will be selected. Shortstop Tyler Bell will likely come off the board in the first round. However, there is one prospect that both Will Stein and Nick Mingione will be watching closely. What will Matt Ponatoski decide? No one really knows.
The Cincinnati (Ohio) Moeller quarterback and pitcher sat down with Over-Slot’s Joe Doyle over the weekend to discuss his upcoming draft decision. This two-sport star wants it known that his top goal is to become a professional baseball player sooner rather than later.
“The goal has always been how do I get drafted…It’s what I want to do. I want to be a professional baseball player,” Ponatoski said. “And I don’t know who I need to sell myself to, but I want to be a professional baseball player. That’s been my dream since I was a little kid.’
Matt Ponatoski called his commitment to Kentucky last July “a baseball first decision” with the plan always being to become a Major League Baseball player. Ponatoski said he fell in love with baseball when he was a t-ball player and that passion has not gone away. The football opportunity presented itself late. While a great option, Ponatoski plans on making a baseball-first decision.
“I came on late with the recruiting in football, and now I think it portrays that I want to be a football player. And yes, that’s a great option if I don’t go to the draft,” said Ponatoski. “But I want to be a professional baseball player as fast as possible. That’s where my heart’s been and where it’s always been.”
“Option 1A is to go be a draft pick.”
Matt Ponatoski has been sitting between 92-95 while reaching 96 mph with his fastball this baseball season. Ponatoski says this was accomplished without ever having full-individual instruction from a pitching coach. Ponatoski believes he has a ton of room to improve as a pitcher and that upside will be met once he begin a professional baseball journey.
This has been a long waiting game for Ponatoski, Kentucky football, and Kentucky baseball. A final decision will be made once the draft arrives in July. If Ponatoski likes where he’s drafted and what an organization is financially offering, it sounds like he will jump at the opportunity to begin a minor league career. If that doesn’t occur, there is the fallback option of playing two sports at Kentucky.
Ponatoski currently sounds like a prospect that is ready to make the jump to professional baseball this summer.
KSR+ Recommendations
Curated by editors
KSR Basketball RecruitingKSR's top takeaways from our first day at Peach Jam
After an early morning and a long drive from the Bluegrass State, KSR arrived in North Augusta, SC, on Wednesday afternoon, ready to watch some...
Read Full Story
KSR BasketballAndrew Harrison is undefeated against Louisville and wants to keep it that way in TBT
Andrew Harrison has never lost to Louisville, and he doesn't want to start now, even in The Basketball Tournament. Ahead of La Familia's opening...
Read Full Story
KSR BasketballMarcus Lee joins La Familia for TBT 2026
That didn't take long. Earlier today, KSR reported that La Familia was working toward adding former Cat Marcus Lee to its roster for The Basketball...
Read Full Story
KSR Basketball RecruitingKSR Live Blog: Peach Jam (Wednesday Edition)
After a long eight-hour drive from Lexington, KSR has boots on the ground in North Augusta for the Nike EYBL Peach Jam -- the premier recruiting...
Read Full Story
KSR Women's BasketballKentucky will address lack of center depth by switching between big lineups, small ball
Kentucky women's basketball has about as stacked of a roster that we've ever seen. A former top five high school recruit in Ayanna Patterson may be...
Read Full Story
KSR BasketballAaron Harrison has a very good reason for sitting out this year's TBT run with La Familia
When it comes to representing Kentucky, Andrew and Aaron Harrison aren't used to not playing basketball together. But the twin brothers will be...
Read Full Story
KSR BasketballArchie Goodwin just played in a hostile one-on-one game on pay-per-view
Add Archie Goodwin to the list of last-minute roster shakeups with La Familia ahead of The Basketball Tournament. Goodwin isn't a complete scratch,...
Read Full Story
KSR BaseballABS approved for college baseball. Kentucky already got a preview.
Get ready to see ABS in college baseball this upcoming season. That's the automated ball-strike challenge system. Think robot umps, but only when a...
Read Full Story
KSR FootballMatt Ponatoski enrolls at Kentucky, choosing the Wildcats over the Reds
The wait is over for dual-sport star Matt Ponatoski. He has made his decision and his move to Lexington. A four-star quarterback commit in...
Read Full Story
KSR Cats in the NBAMore details emerge from the Bam Adebayo-Tyler Herro scuffle in Las Vegas
More details are slowly trickling out from last week's scuffle in Las Vegas between former Kentucky players Bam Adebayo and Tyler Herro. As a quick...
Read Full Story






