school calendars?

JonathanW_rivals

New member
Jan 3, 2003
145,535
938
0
Are there options where you live?
What is your preference?
What would be your ideal calendar (meeting the current # of days/hours requirements)?

In my county about 1/3 of the elementary and middle schools are on the "year-round" calendar. It was used at first because the county (population) was growing faster than they could build schools, and having a school as a year-round school allowed it to enroll more students. The year-round schools work as such: there are 4 tracks, so a student is on 1 of the 4 tracks the entire year. Roughly every 3 weeks, a track "tracks-out" and the group that was tracked-out "tracks back in". So you are in school for 9 weeks, get 3 weeks off, and then do it over again. Everyone gets the week from Christmas to New-Year's off, and everyone gets the first week of July off. So if you had an equal distribution of students in each track (which we don't), then you could have 33% more students in a school.

Families either love or hate year round schools. Some really enjoy the long summer vacation, especially those with a beach-house or lake-house. Others really enjoy being able to take a vacation in the spring or fall when it's less crowded and less expensive. Also it is believed that kids retain more when they don't have a 3 month break from school. However we have no year-round high schools, I think because there are many more specialty subjects in high school, for example a school may not be able to have multiple physics, calculas, and other advanced subject teachers.

But there is 1 (out of about 20) high school in the county that is on a "modified calendar". I like this one a lot (but unfortunately the school is not close, nor does it seem to have good test scores (doubt it's due to the calendar). The modified calendar is almost the "traditional school calendar", except they give a 2 week fall break, give an extra week at Christmas, and an extra week at spring break, so the summer break is 4 weeks shorter (so 2 months instead of 3). This seems to me like the best of both, and a great compromise. I mean, in most places we no longer use our kids to "work the farm" in the summer, wasn't that the original purpose for them getting summers off.

The one problem with year-round schools is that once they get to high school, they switch to a traditional calendar, and so families don't want/like having one kid on a traditional calendar and another kid on a year-round calendar. Although if you were to get your kid into a school with a Modified calendar, then there could be some overlap.
 

JHB4UK

New member
May 29, 2001
31,836
2,637
0
love for my kids to have a year round. but since we don't, I hate that what we have starts in early August. If they are gonna be off for summer break, then be off for touching summer and dont start back until late Aug/after Labor day.
 

JonathanW_rivals

New member
Jan 3, 2003
145,535
938
0
Being at a year-round school, the past 4-5 years we've taken our family vacation in mid-Sept. Weather is still great, prices are even better, and there are no crowds. Going to miss year-round school calendar next year.
 

We-Todd-Did

New member
May 2, 2007
2,711
941
0
My kids had the modified calendar one year and it was great. IMO, my kids didn't get as tired of classes with more breaks and it helped them focus better. It seemed like my kids enjoyed the longer breaks and the shorter summer break didn't bother them. As with all things, people don't adapt well to even minor changes so it got scrapped. People were writing letters to the local paper to complain because that's not the calendar they had when they went to Hoghead Holler Elementary.
 

rmattox

New member
Nov 26, 2014
6,786
886
0
love for my kids to have a year round. but since we don't, I hate that what we have starts in early August. If they are gonna be off for summer break, then be off for touching summer and dont start back until late Aug/after Labor day.
Was responsible for developing school calendars in a previous life. Board member once asked me why we couldn't start until after Labor Day. The reason is simple....you have to get in 175 days of instruction, but you are also expected to take 2 days at Thanksgiving, a week+ for Christmas and a spring break. If you started after Labor Day, your initial calendar would have school ending well into June.....and that's before you start adding days missed due to weather.
 

JonathanW_rivals

New member
Jan 3, 2003
145,535
938
0
I think he was saying he would rather go well into June than start before Labor Day.
I never really got that myself, to me early June feels more like summer than early Sept, even though technically it is not.