Who's the best team you have watched this season?

LHSTigers94

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2004
3,201
2,502
93
MC. Their schedule, expect for ESL, has been ridiculous. And St Joes NJ losses are to national powers. Mc had ESL had ESL in the 4th.
Incorrect narrative regarding the MC/ ESL game.
ESL scored first. MC Answered. ESL scored again MC answered. ESL had a blocked punt safety followed by a kick return for TD. ESL answered with 28-0. At NO point did MC control or dominate the game. MC is a very good team and if played today the game will be different however, the FACTS of that game is there was a series where special team mistakes cost ESL 9 points to which they responded with 28 points.

There is no need to create a narrative that didn't exist. MC don't need help in that area. They are good enough to let the facts speak for themselves.
 

Louie1999

Freshman
Sep 13, 2025
59
67
18
MC. Their schedule, expect for ESL, has been ridiculous. And St Joes NJ losses are to national powers. Mc had ESL had ESL in the 4th.
Well if you’ve seen ESL play Mount Carmel than ESL is the best team that you have seen play. They beat MC by 20 points bc football is played for 4qs. Otherwise we should ding MC for being down 30-0 in the 1q in embarrassing fashion to St Joes. MC is a great team but you cannot say they are better than ESL if you have seen them both play.
 

geaux_tigers

Redshirt
Sep 12, 2026
1
1
3
Well if you’ve seen ESL play Mount Carmel than ESL is the best team that you have seen play. They beat MC by 20 points bc football is played for 4qs. Otherwise we should ding MC for being down 30-0 in the 1q in embarrassing fashion to St Joes. MC is a great team but you cannot say they are better than ESL if you have seen them both play.
Hm, you can definitely argue that MC has a better quality loss tho
 
  • Like
Reactions: crusader_of_90

LHSTigers94

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2004
3,201
2,502
93
MCs loss was to the #33 ranked team. ESL loss was to the #47 ranked team. It was a compliment, i think.
You can't use rankings now, you have to use the rankings at the time.

The question is how can losing to a team that lost to another team is somehow a better loss?
 

jha618

All-Conference
Jan 1, 2018
3,493
4,113
113
You can't use rankings now, you have to use the rankings at the time.

The question is how can losing to a team that lost to another team is somehow a better loss?
Im not saying I agree. But I think that was the point the other poster was trying to make.

But lets just say ESL had lost to Edwardsville Week 2 instead of AH. You could certainly say MC had a better loss than ESL.
 

PowerI66

Senior
Jul 10, 2025
824
703
93
I'm definitely going to miss some, but tops for me would be...
ESL
MC
LWE/LA
Geneva
Rochester
Batavia
HF

I need to watch Montini, PC, and a few others near the top.
 

LWN_Pheonix

Senior
Oct 30, 2023
969
774
93
I highly suggest that you guys watch Alan vs Desoto

the sophomore QB at Alan is supposed to get his 5th star very soon

I don’t know how you can justify them not being the top team in the country

Illinois

Hersey has a bad *** offense that is really fun to watch
 

DR.Eireog

Junior
Nov 26, 2025
144
202
43
ESL.
I’ve watched MC nearly every week. MC is an incredibly talented team. It might be the best MC team I’ve seen. They got beat by ESL and I watched it happen.
I’ve seen about a quarter of BR games, and I’ve been very impressed. I’ve seen bits of PC, equally impressed.
I have not seen any of LA. I’m sure they’re impressive and I need to see them play. Who am I missing? Rochester? LWE? Bolingbrook?
 

Anon1775581746

Redshirt
Apr 7, 2026
5
6
3
ESL.
I’ve watched MC nearly every week. MC is an incredibly talented team. It might be the best MC team I’ve seen. They got beat by ESL and I watched it happen.
I’ve seen about a quarter of BR games, and I’ve been very impressed. I’ve seen bits of PC, equally impressed.
I have not seen any of LA. I’m sure they’re impressive and I need to see them play. Who am I missing? Rochester? LWE? Bolingbrook?
ESL’s best team in years. Gomiller is the difference. I honestly think if he were 6'2", he’d be rated even higher. Cincinnati is getting a great player.

It’s cold in November, trophies are there to be won, and I’ve got a feeling MC will not disappoint.
 

LHSTigers94

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2004
3,201
2,502
93
Im not saying I agree. But I think that was the point the other poster was trying to make.

But lets just say ESL had lost to Edwardsville Week 2 instead of AH. You could certainly say MC had a better loss than ESL.
If E’ville beat ESL that means they deserved to observed as a better team. Paper rankings do not weigh more than the actual game.
 

Caravan92

Freshman
Jul 28, 2025
51
88
18
ESL. They won the head to head matchup so as long as they win state they HAVE to finish #1 In IL. I believe the only way they should be unseated is if they don’t win the 7A title.
MC. I see more growing pains than I normally see. Mistakes that I’ve rarely seen before for this program. The penalties it seems have been increasing every year, but I think that’s more of how the game is played and amplified by the coaches tolerance. I believe by the end of the year a lot of this is put to rest and if they close out the season with the 8A trophy they should be a very close #2.
SJR better than both ESL national opponents. Time will tell how their season plays out.
LA They are rolling. If they stay healthy in a couple key positions they will give MC a tough game.
 
Edgy Tim

Latest

  1. 01 Edgy Tim Football Breakdown: Lincoln Way Central
  2. 02 Edgy Tim Football Breakdown: Bolingbrook Raiders
  3. 03 Edgy Tim Football New: The 3rd and Leng Podcast
  4. 04 Rivals Football Recruiting Rivals300 recruits give Nebraska high marks after weekend trip to Lincoln
  5. 05 Edgy Tim Football QB Carter recaps his recent visits