On tv broadcasts, if they're not going to show the player's degree status/college major in the introductions...

Erial_Lion

All-American
Nov 1, 2021
4,339
5,146
113
I posted in the basketball thread...but Kansas just added a player yesterday that was drafted into the NBA, played in the summer league, but never signed a contract. He registered at Kansas on Sunday, and is currently eligible while under a court injunction. How can someone register for classes on October 18th for the fall semester, when Kansas publishes September 21st as the last day to register for fall classes?
 

Lion84

All-Conference
Oct 7, 2021
788
1,155
93
They should also not announce the schools they have attended already in the interest of time - seems to be three or more for every player.
 

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
12,928
21,446
113
I posted in the basketball thread...but Kansas just added a player yesterday that was drafted into the NBA, played in the summer league, but never signed a contract. He registered at Kansas on Sunday, and is currently eligible while under a court injunction. How can someone register for classes on October 18th for the fall semester, when Kansas publishes September 21st as the last day to register for fall classes?

Nonsense GIF by mesigugu
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chumboshifko1

Binder74

Senior
Nov 1, 2021
501
860
93
They should also not announce the schools they have attended already in the interest of time - seems to be three or more for every player.
Should probably include the schools they are considering when they transfer next year to get a jump on buying that schools apparel.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SleepyLion

NoBareFeet

Senior
Oct 25, 2021
411
657
93
This is what the college football media has been lobbying for all these years. This is what they wanted. At last, these poor college football and basketball players aren't exploited victims. It's a wonder how they were able to fill out rosters for all these years considering how badly all the players were victimized.
Stephen Colbert No GIF by The Late Show With Stephen Colbert
 

PSUFTG

All-Conference
Nov 1, 2021
2,806
4,030
113
I posted in the basketball thread...but Kansas just added a player yesterday that was drafted into the NBA, played in the summer league, but never signed a contract. He registered at Kansas on Sunday, and is currently eligible while under a court injunction. How can someone register for classes on October 18th for the fall semester, when Kansas publishes September 21st as the last day to register for fall classes?
Why should he have to register for classes?

We have guys playing football right now - at PSU - who don't.
 

Erial_Lion

All-American
Nov 1, 2021
4,339
5,146
113
Why should he have to register for classes?

We have guys playing football right now - at PSU - who don't.
Is that actually true? My understanding was that they needed to be registered and making "progress" (with the progress being a much lower bar than it used to be). You're telling me we have players that never registered for any classes?
 

SkiSkiSki

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
3,987
1,492
113
I posted in the basketball thread...but Kansas just added a player yesterday that was drafted into the NBA, played in the summer league, but never signed a contract. He registered at Kansas on Sunday, and is currently eligible while under a court injunction. How can someone register for classes on October 18th for the fall semester, when Kansas publishes September 21st as the last day to register for fall classes?
Half semester courses that last 7-8 weeks -- "accelerated", "intensive", and "mini-mester" they are sometimes called. He probably made it just inside the window to have enough time to be there for the entire course(s).
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
764
869
93
Is that actually true? My understanding was that they needed to be registered and making "progress" (with the progress being a much lower bar than it used to be). You're telling me we have players that never registered for any classes?
Why still have academic requirements. They can’t be enforcing anything
 

BUFFALO LION

All-Conference
Oct 4, 2001
1,271
2,085
113
Half semester courses that last 7-8 weeks -- "accelerated", "intensive", and "mini-mester" they are sometimes called. He probably made it just inside the window to have enough time to be there for the entire course(s).

I hope these guys are saving all that quick cash they’re getting.
 

mh-larch

Senior
Nov 20, 2019
333
718
93
This is what the college football media has been lobbying for all these years. This is what they wanted. At last, these poor college football and basketball players aren't exploited victims. It's a wonder how they were able to fill out rosters for all these years considering how badly all the players were victimized.
Stephen Colbert No GIF by The Late Show With Stephen Colbert
Exactly....I remember them reporting about players going hungry (BTW, don't players get free food...training table, etc?) and all they wanted was a chance to get min wage job, to cover expenses, etc, etc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobPSU92

BUFFALO LION

All-Conference
Oct 4, 2001
1,271
2,085
113
Exactly....I remember them reporting about players going hungry (BTW, don't players get free food...training table, etc?) and all they wanted was a chance to get min wage job, to cover expenses, etc, etc.

Ya. I remember some reporter saying they couldn’t even afford a pack of chewing gum. Drove me nuts.
 

manatree

All-American
Oct 6, 2021
3,567
6,441
113
Is that actually true? My understanding was that they needed to be registered and making "progress" (with the progress being a much lower bar than it used to be). You're telling me we have players that never registered for any classes?

The NCAA standards for academic progression has always been very weak. Back when I used to give a s#!t we had a basketball player who failed half of his credits in the Fall Semester yet was still in fine standing by the NCAA and played in the Spring Semester. It's basically all about accumulating credits, not if those credits are actually leading to a degree. While Penn State may not be as bad as some, we are far from blameless in the charade.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SkiSkiSki

Erial_Lion

All-American
Nov 1, 2021
4,339
5,146
113
The NCAA standards for academic progression has always been very weak. Back when I used to give a s#!t we had a basketball player who failed half of his credits in the Fall Semester yet was still in fine standing by the NCAA and played in the Spring Semester. It's basically all about accumulating credits, not if those credits are actually leading to a degree. While Penn State may not be as bad as some, we are far from blameless in the charade.
Oh, I agree that they are very weak. But I thought that "being registered for a class" was a minimum requirement.
 

manatree

All-American
Oct 6, 2021
3,567
6,441
113
Exactly....I remember them reporting about players going hungry (BTW, don't players get free food...training table, etc?) and all they wanted was a chance to get min wage job, to cover expenses, etc, etc.

Ya. I remember some reporter saying they couldn’t even afford a pack of chewing gum. Drove me nuts.

That is what some fans claimed drove Sean Oakman to steal that hoagie and grape juice while shoving the cashier into the wall. :cautious:
 

BobPSU92

Heisman
Aug 22, 2001
45,934
38,138
113
That is what some fans claimed drove Sean Oakman to steal that hoagie and grape juice while shoving the cashier into the wall. :cautious:

Now that student-athletes (😞) have ample cash money, they are responsible citizens. No more illegal activity. 🙂

😞
 

PSUFTG

All-Conference
Nov 1, 2021
2,806
4,030
113
Oh, I agree that they are very weak. But I thought that "being registered for a class" was a minimum requirement.
Nope

Individual schools can. of course, set any additional requirements (over and above NCAA minimums) if they want to. I expect very few "want to"

The current NCAA requirements on this topic (Using the standard minimum credits to earn a degree as being 120 credits) This is of course a bit of a synopsis:

First 2 years - maintain a 1.8 or higher GPA

By the beginning of their 3rd year, accumulate at least 40% (48 credits) of number of credits required for a degree (they don't even have to "count" for a degree), and a 1.9 GPA

By the beginning of their 4th year, accumulate at least 60% (72 credits) of number of credits required for a degree and a 2.0 GPA

By the beginning of their 5th year, accumulate at least 80% (96 credits) of number of credits required for a degree (they don't even have to "count" for a degree), and a 2.0 GPA


So, at no point do they even have to actually be on track for earning a degree. And certainly not on pace with being "full time".
And, it is far worse than that:


After getting to 72 credits (or 96 for a 5th year guy) there requirements are essentially nil.
This is one of the reasons the older transfers are often not even real students.

Unless PSU (and other programs) is blatantly "breaking the law", there ain't nothing.
PSU has several guys on the roster that will never take a real PSU class (I am sure PSU is not alone in that).

As an example, not to pick on Becht, because he is not even an outlier (there are many in the same boat), but his situation kind of went more "public" than most:
He is not an undergrad student at PSU.... He is not required to be enrolled in the graduate school (and hasn't been since he started here).

He is - supposedly - taking a "certificate course" (1) as an on-line asynchronous course (IYKYK). That is not a degree program or even a degree course (or require one to be a student at PSU). He will likely never see the inside of a PSU classroom (unless he accidently walks in on one), or sit for a single PSU program course, by the time he leaves here.

And no one cares. Certainly not the NCAA, and certainly not PSU (or most other schools)

It is a complete misnomer to ever call these folks "student athletes" (though some fans and what not like to cling to that belief.... I know some people who still swear all these guys have to be full time students - or at least enrolled students - but it just isn't so)

To be clear: PSU is not an outlier here.
Back in the day, maybe they would have been - back when some folks at PSU felt there should be some relationship between "student" and "athlete" - but any of those folks are long gone.

FWIW: PSU ICA went to lengths (after HCJF was fired) to assure that they would be allowed to bring in scads of these types of transfers - to make it possible for Campbell (or whomever the next coach was going to be) to fill out a roster with no hindrances from having to get kids enrolled in actual programs.


And, BTW, kids who "meet those requirements" outlined above?
According to the NCAA (when they compile those things people THINK equate to "graduation rates") they would count as a "+". How does one NOT meet those "requirements"? (amazingly some don't - especially at PSU in recent years)
Digest this:
PSU's "NCAA Academic Score" will probably go UP - now that they have all these kids on the football team that are not even students (I kid you not - that's the way it works)

So be it. People can care or not.
 
Last edited:

BUFFALO LION

All-Conference
Oct 4, 2001
1,271
2,085
113
Nope

Individual schools can. of course, set any additional requirements (over and above NCAA minimums) if they want to. I expect very few "want to"

The current NCAA requirements on this topic (Using the standard minimum credits to earn a degree as being 120 credits) This is of course a bit of a synopsis:

First 2 years - maintain a 1.8 or higher GPA

By the beginning of their 3rd year, accumulate at least 40% (48 credits) of number of credits required for a degree (they don't even have to "count" for a degree), and a 1.9 GPA

By the beginning of their 4th year, accumulate at least 60% (72 credits) of number of credits required for a degree and a 2.0 GPA

By the beginning of their 5th year, accumulate at least 80% (96 credits) of number of credits required for a degree (they don't even have to "count" for a degree), and a 2.0 GPA


So, at no point do they even have to actually be on track for earning a degree. And certainly not on pace with being "full time".
And, it is far worse than that:


After getting to 72 credits (or 96 for a 5th year guy) there requirements are essentially nil.
This is one of the reasons the older transfers are often not even real students.

Unless PSU (and other programs) is blatantly "breaking the law", there ain't nothing.
PSU has several guys on the roster that will never take a real PSU class (I am sure PSU is not alone in that).

As an example, not to pick on Becht, because he is not even an outlier (there are many in the same boat), but his situation kind of went more "public" than most:
He is not an undergrad student at PSU.... He is not required to be enrolled in the graduate school (and hasn't been since he started here).

He is - supposedly - taking a "certificate course" (1) as an on-line asynchronous course (IYKYK). That is not a degree program or even a degree course (or require one to be a student at PSU). He will likely never see the inside of a PSU classroom (unless he accidently walks in on one), or sit for a single PSU program course, by the time he leaves here.

And no one cares. Certainly not the NCAA, and certainly not PSU (or most other schools)

It is a complete misnomer to ever call these folks "student athletes" (though some fans and what not like to cling to that belief.... I know some people who still swear all these guys have to be full time students - or at least enrolled students - but it just isn't so)

To be clear: PSU is not an outlier here.
Back in the day, maybe they would have been - back when some folks at PSU felt there should be some relationship between "student" and "athlete" - but any of those folks are long gone.

FWIW: PSU ICA went to lengths (after HCJF was fired) to assure that they would be allowed to bring in scads of these types of transfers - to make it possible for Campbell (or whomever the next coach was going to be) to fill out a roster with no hindrances from having to get kids enrolled in actual programs.


And, BTW, kids who "meet those requirements" outlined above?
According to the NCAA (when they compile those things people THINK equate to "graduation rates") they would count as a "+". How does one NOT meet those "requirements"? (amazingly some don't - especially at PSU in recent years)
Digest this:
PSU's "NCAA Academic Score" will probably go UP - now that they have all these kids on the football team that are not even students (I kid you not - that's the way it works)

So be it. People can care or not.

Man. I heard that about Becht and some of the others, but had a hard time believing it. That is 180 degrees different from when Joe was here and I was in school in the early 70s.

Football players were REAL students back then. Most got their degrees, played hard nosed, fundamentally sound football, and made you proud to be a Penn Stater. That mentality reflected Nationally in an incredibly positive way on every Penn State student and alumnus. It was a GREAT time to be alive.

It’s crap like this Becht shi+ that makes me respect this team even less and look at these guys as no more than uninterested, pay for play vagabonds. They look at their jerseys and helmets more as Halloween costumes than Penn State uniforms. No connection to the University and fans whatsoever other than the paycheck they cash. Explains why, with a few exceptions, they appear to play soft and uninterested.
 

OUIrPSU

All-Conference
Oct 6, 2021
1,396
1,743
113
...which is laughable at this point, then they should show the NIL $$$ they are being paid.

This is a 2-way street.
Or, better yet, say the school and/or where they’re from so the audience can actually hear - and understand - what they’re saying!
 

BiochemPSU

All-Conference
Jun 13, 2016
1,184
1,682
113
Nope

Individual schools can. of course, set any additional requirements (over and above NCAA minimums) if they want to. I expect very few "want to"

The current NCAA requirements on this topic (Using the standard minimum credits to earn a degree as being 120 credits) This is of course a bit of a synopsis:

First 2 years - maintain a 1.8 or higher GPA

By the beginning of their 3rd year, accumulate at least 40% (48 credits) of number of credits required for a degree (they don't even have to "count" for a degree), and a 1.9 GPA

By the beginning of their 4th year, accumulate at least 60% (72 credits) of number of credits required for a degree and a 2.0 GPA

By the beginning of their 5th year, accumulate at least 80% (96 credits) of number of credits required for a degree (they don't even have to "count" for a degree), and a 2.0 GPA


So, at no point do they even have to actually be on track for earning a degree. And certainly not on pace with being "full time".
And, it is far worse than that:


After getting to 72 credits (or 96 for a 5th year guy) there requirements are essentially nil.
This is one of the reasons the older transfers are often not even real students.

Unless PSU (and other programs) is blatantly "breaking the law", there ain't nothing.
PSU has several guys on the roster that will never take a real PSU class (I am sure PSU is not alone in that).

As an example, not to pick on Becht, because he is not even an outlier (there are many in the same boat), but his situation kind of went more "public" than most:
He is not an undergrad student at PSU.... He is not required to be enrolled in the graduate school (and hasn't been since he started here).

He is - supposedly - taking a "certificate course" (1) as an on-line asynchronous course (IYKYK). That is not a degree program or even a degree course (or require one to be a student at PSU). He will likely never see the inside of a PSU classroom (unless he accidently walks in on one), or sit for a single PSU program course, by the time he leaves here.

And no one cares. Certainly not the NCAA, and certainly not PSU (or most other schools)

It is a complete misnomer to ever call these folks "student athletes" (though some fans and what not like to cling to that belief.... I know some people who still swear all these guys have to be full time students - or at least enrolled students - but it just isn't so)

To be clear: PSU is not an outlier here.
Back in the day, maybe they would have been - back when some folks at PSU felt there should be some relationship between "student" and "athlete" - but any of those folks are long gone.

FWIW: PSU ICA went to lengths (after HCJF was fired) to assure that they would be allowed to bring in scads of these types of transfers - to make it possible for Campbell (or whomever the next coach was going to be) to fill out a roster with no hindrances from having to get kids enrolled in actual programs.


And, BTW, kids who "meet those requirements" outlined above?
According to the NCAA (when they compile those things people THINK equate to "graduation rates") they would count as a "+". How does one NOT meet those "requirements"? (amazingly some don't - especially at PSU in recent years)
Digest this:
PSU's "NCAA Academic Score" will probably go UP - now that they have all these kids on the football team that are not even students (I kid you not - that's the way it works)

So be it. People can care or not.
I've said it before on here. It's only a matter of time until one of these 7th year professional student athletes finds themselves in a criminal or civil lawsuit over their off the field conduct. Conduct that some will argue was surely aided and abetted (or foreseen) by the NIL money and a general lack of background vetting, lack of supervision, and fake student status that they were given by the school. Then the school is going to find itself sharing the defendant's position on the lawsuit heading. The players should be paid. But the bulk of the money should be thrown into a trust account that they have limited access to until after they exit college.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Binder74
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Penn State fan survey: What do Lions fans think the team's final record will be, and what gives them hope moving forward?
  2. 02 BWI Recruiting Intel: Penn State lands a huge recruiting win in running back Jordan Hall; What's next for the Nittany Lions?
  3. 03 BWI Recruiting Penn State beats Ohio State for 2027 running back Jordan Hall
  4. 04 BWI Mike Rhoades breaks down Penn State basketball's backcourt, defense and rotation
  5. 05 BWI Football Where do Penn State’s defensive linemen rank nationally according to PFF?