3 fumbles in the last 2 games. Minnesota fumble was at a critical time. Have to wonder going forward how long of a leash he's on.
X Williams
- Thread starter yrunvs
- Start date
Coming in after the Minnesota game, of all games, and fumbling twice was a horrible look.
But Williams didn't fumble against Minnesota. Are you thinking of Braeden Jackson's fumble?
But Williams didn't fumble against Minnesota. Are you thinking of Braeden Jackson's fumble?
I really like X, but historically Iowa coaches have had no patience for not protecting the Rock. I gotta think Philips totes the Rock vs Northwestern. With limited touches from the rest...
I think you're correct my fault but still 2 fumbles vs Wisc.
I just looked and those were actually Williams' first two fumbles of his career. That surprised me.
Well lucky him the other three fumbled the week before, so someone still has to carry the ball.
Phillips needs to be the guy … can’t have a RB with slippery hands
Phillips fumbled against Minny iirc, XW has more wiggle than Phillips
One was a punchout fumble as he churned for extra yardage but agree that he needs to pull that ball in super tight just before contact and keep it tight.
XW has very good feet, stutter step etc. Start XW but maybe split the carries a little more evenly between backs to keep them fresh, and strong
And when Braedon Jackson is at running back we could maybe better use his as a receiver or on wide sweep type runs as he doesnt seem to have the bulk on the inside runs to withstand that first contact without getting knocked off strideYeah, good point - I think both will probably split carries...
McNeil is like #4 RBack now but he is a pretty good glider for some outside runs and passes
X needs to learn to wrap up when making contact,... Today's defensive squads have been coached to punch the ball and tackle.
I’m hopeful he can still breakout but it just hasn’t been clicking for him so far.
Yep,.. In today's game you can't be one arming the ball and reaching into contact.
I've thought about this a lot more lately, especially after watching an NFL game last week, where one particular guy spent far more energy and attempts at "punching" than he did tackling for the entire game. Was pretty good at it too. (Linebacker I believe....)
Football is a violent sport and I loved playing it more than any other sport personally as well, so not the squeamish type in regards to stepping on that field and the risk involved. But we're on a bit of a slippery slope trajectory in regards to "the punch" IMO. It seems to be more prevalent these days, and it's leaning more like boxing/football in that regard.
We know there have been MANY rule changes over the decades in regards to "player safety", and it will only take one incident/injury from a "missed" punch to a "star" player and the NFL Rules Committee will be all over it in a heartbeat (and/or the NCAA). (granted, most of the safety changes are head/neck area related, targeting, etc., so the emphasis isn't on the midsection with ball carriers)
I do believe it's just a matter of time that "the punch" gets far more attention than it currently does. (but in the meantime, I hope the Hawks are excellent at it........
).Except to this point Phillips still look like he isn't 100% healthy. I bet X starts and we'll see from there.
Based on what. #21 has been dinged up all season and has not impressed at all to this point.
That's why there is so much reaction pointed at him when we had 4 fumbles last game. Except it wasn't him last week.
X. is thick and difficult to bring down but dang he is slow. Wish we could see a full game with Brevin Doll as RB1 
He's had a couple of pretty long runs the last couple of season. As much as some on here said he wasn't, its obvious once again that the coaches had the right guy starting. Moulton......X. is thick and difficult to bring down but dang he is slow. Wish we could see a full game with Brevin Doll as RB1
Moulton easily the top RB in the room.
Great post, I am actually surprised the 'Peanut Punch' had not caught on years ago...I do think it has gotten out of hand lately (especially in the NFL), and I foresee a rule change coming a la the horse collar restriction.I've thought about this a lot more lately, especially after watching an NFL game last week, where one particular guy spent far more energy and attempts at "punching" than he did tackling for the entire game. Was pretty good at it too. (Linebacker I believe....)
Football is a violent sport and I loved playing it more than any other sport personally as well, so not the squeamish type in regards to stepping on that field and the risk involved. But we're on a bit of a slippery slope trajectory in regards to "the punch" IMO. It seems to be more prevalent these days, and it's leaning more like boxing/football in that regard.
We know there have been MANY rule changes over the decades in regards to "player safety", and it will only take one incident/injury from a "missed" punch to a "star" player and the NFL Rules Committee will be all over it in a heartbeat (and/or the NCAA). (granted, most of the safety changes are head/neck area related, targeting, etc., so the emphasis isn't on the midsection with ball carriers)
I do believe it's just a matter of time that "the punch" gets far more attention than it currently does. (but in the meantime, I hope the Hawks are excellent at it........
Yea. This. His fumbles weren’t on first contact if I remember correctly. It was the second and third attempts when he didn’t wrap up after first contact.
need to roll with #21 & give him 20-25 carries to let him get into the groove.
#21 definitely seeems hungry to prove himself!
He will get the rep of a fumbler so it will make the opposing defense work even harder to knock it out when he has it.
X is slow laterally and north/south.
Philips is better at fighting for yards.
yep. they have no patience because of how they need to win games.
Latest
-
01
Hawkeye Report Basketball
Top takeaways from the Hawkeyes win over Eastern Illinois
-
02
Hawkeye Report Football
Game Preview: Iowa at Northwestern
-
03
Hawkeye Report Basketball
Tip Time Preview: Eastern Illinois at Iowa
-
04
Hawkeye Report Basketball
PHOTO GALLERY: Iowa Women's Basketball vs Eastern Illinois
-
05
Hawkeye Report Basketball
Hawkeyes cruise to a 41-point win over Eastern Illinois