How losing kills the next generation of RU fans

eddynyse

Sophomore
Jul 7, 2025
67
100
18
RU loses so much that we can't even build or grow the fanbase in a meaningful way.

My son is 12 and has grown up watching games with me (poor kid). Because losing is mostly what he’s seen, he already has that classic East Coast cynicism about Rutgers. He doesn't even get his hopes up anymore, he just expects them to lose. My 8 year old is already on that same mindset. My nephew who currently goes to RU doesn't even go to the games anymore.

That's how you lose the next generation of fans.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,661
4,016
108
Wait 10 years til he’s 22 and at Rutgers like mine is after watching since he’s about 6. It’s SO frustrating. He’s brought 20-30 students to my tailgates over his time there and nobody has been treated to a good season or signature win.

And then we have dolts out there calling Rutgers fans ‘cheap’. LOL. It’s a miracle we’ve been able to get 30-40k to the stadium until the wheels totally came off this season, given the history.
 

Rutgers Chris

All-American
Nov 29, 2005
6,030
7,356
97
RU loses so much that we can't even build or grow the fanbase in a meaningful way.

My son is 12 and has grown up watching games with me (poor kid). Because losing is mostly what he’s seen, he already has that classic East Coast cynicism about Rutgers. He doesn't even get his hopes up anymore, he just expects them to lose. My 8 year old is already on that same mindset. My nephew who currently goes to RU doesn't even go to the games anymore.

That's how you lose the next generation of fans.
It’s amazing that we get as many fans as we do when there is a glimmer of hope. And then…
Charlie Brown Football GIF
 

eddynyse

Sophomore
Jul 7, 2025
67
100
18
Wait 10 years til he’s 22 and at Rutgers like mine is after watching since he’s about 6. It’s SO frustrating. He’s brought 20-30 students to my tailgates over his time there and nobody has been treated to a good season or signature win.

And then we have dolts out there calling Rutgers fans ‘cheap’. LOL. It’s a miracle we’ve been able to get 30-40k to the stadium until the wheels totally came off this season, given the history.
Different topic, but I do think the RU fanbase is cheap. I don't think I'll ever get over the missed opportunity to financially support the basketball program when Ace and Harper were on the team. We should have gone to the final 4 with that level of talent and we didn't even get to the tournament. but that’s a topic for another thread.
 

Bueller

Senior
Nov 28, 2025
866
714
93
He might be better off - wont start gambling and wasting weekends . I've been reading about how Zoomers are into individual athletes more than teams. I love football but my current interest is lowest its ever been and I kinda like it. I feel bad for youngs though

"More than a quarter (27%) of Americans and over half (52%) of men aged 18 to 49 say they have an active online sportsbook account, according to a Siena Poll from February.

Many young adult sports bettors are making what financial professionals say is a particularly risky wager: that their sports predictions will help fund their futures. Over half — 52% — of Gen Z investors (those born between 1997 and 2007) have redirected money intended for investing to sports bets, a Betterment survey of 1,000 investors finds."

52% of Gen Z investors have redirected investing money to sports bets​

 
  • Like
Reactions: eddynyse

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,661
4,016
108
Different topic, but I do think the RU fanbase is cheap. I don't think I'll ever get over the missed opportunity to financially support the basketball program when Ace and Harper were on the team. We should have gone to the final 4 with that level of talent and we didn't even get to the tournament. but that’s a topic for another thread.
It’s the same argument as the OP. Decades of losing render your fan base as small so when an opportunity comes around like the Ace/Harper season, we are tapping a fan base literally multiples smaller than our peers and we didn’t even have a NIL program to try and aggressively tap the small fan base. How is the small fan base going to outspend our peers, regardless of Ace and Dylan coming in, when not even supporting NIL??

It’s more SMALL than it is cheap.
 

T2Kplus20

Heisman
May 1, 2007
32,875
20,952
113
RU loses so much that we can't even build or grow the fanbase in a meaningful way.

My son is 12 and has grown up watching games with me (poor kid). Because losing is mostly what he’s seen, he already has that classic East Coast cynicism about Rutgers. He doesn't even get his hopes up anymore, he just expects them to lose. My 8 year old is already on that same mindset. My nephew who currently goes to RU doesn't even go to the games anymore.

That's how you lose the next generation of fans.
Never brought my little one to an RU game and never will. I will not inflict such pain and suffering on my child. This disease (RU fandom) dies with me.
 

RU#1fan

Heisman
Mar 7, 2003
24,449
13,070
113
Wait 10 years til he’s 22 and at Rutgers like mine is after watching since he’s about 6. It’s SO frustrating. He’s brought 20-30 students to my tailgates over his time there and nobody has been treated to a good season or signature win.

And then we have dolts out there calling Rutgers fans ‘cheap’. LOL. It’s a miracle we’ve been able to get 30-40k to the stadium until the wheels totally came off this season, given the history.
There have not been 30-40k at the Stadium this year. Next year will be a ghost town.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,661
4,016
108
There have not been 30-40k at the Stadium this year. Next year will be a ghost town.
You are probably right but Umass was announced as 42k. Umass was a Thursday too so even if it was 30-35k, that not bad for Thursday versus a MAC team. The support relative to the product has always been good IMO.

Either way, that loss killed any interest there may have been for the season.
 

eddynyse

Sophomore
Jul 7, 2025
67
100
18
It’s the same argument as the OP. Decades of losing render your fan base as small so when an opportunity comes around like the Ace/Harper season, we are tapping a fan base literally multiples smaller than our peers and we didn’t even have a NIL program to try and aggressively tap the small fan base. How is the small fan base going to outspend our peers, regardless of Ace and Dylan coming in, when not even supporting NIL??

It’s more SMALL than it is cheap.
I think you’re partially right. Between a smaller fanbase and an AD who didn't properly position RU for the new landscape, the school failed to push hard enough to get the NIL money needed to build a complete roster.

At the same time, a huge chunk of our fanbase is still stuck in the old-school college model and refuses to contribute to paying players. That combination is exactly why we lost Cliff to Alabama right when we needed him most.

But again, different topic. Just sad that my kids are unlikely to enjoy or feel proud of our state university. I still hope they go to RU for the academics and the financial advantage of staying in-state rather than going to a private or out of state schol.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,661
4,016
108
I think you’re partially right. Between a smaller fanbase and an AD who didn't properly position RU for the new landscape, the school failed to push hard enough to get the NIL money needed to build a complete roster.

At the same time, a huge chunk of our fanbase is still stuck in the old-school college model and refuses to contribute to paying players. That combination is exactly why we lost Cliff to Alabama right when we needed him most.

But again, different topic. Just sad that my kids are unlikely to enjoy or feel proud of our state university. I still hope they go to RU for the academics and the financial advantage of staying in-state rather than going to a private or out of state schol.
It’s a circular point. A large part of why our fan base is stuck in an old school model is BECAUSE while presidents, ADs and and head coaches from other schools were screaming from the mountain tops that they needed NIL to compete, ours were not and even worse were obstructing the grass roots effort from KOTR.

Small fan base from decades of losing

+

No NIL support or even obstruction from Rutgers

=

FAIL
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: eddynyse

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,661
4,016
108
We honestly have no idea how committed this fan base is because there are very few similar benchmarks to compare to because nobody has lost at this level for this long.

What we DO know is that even with just a taste of winning
  • We were able to sell the stadium out by 2007/2008, even after doubling the price of tickets and people were willing to pony up multiples for premium parking.
  • About 3-4 years ago, we were able to sell the RAC out with roughly doubled prices and parking had progressively been increased over the Pike era.

We aren’t even talking about winning conference championships, making deep runs into the NCAAs, making big time bowls. Just a taste of winning.
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,664
151,489
113
RU loses so much that we can't even build or grow the fanbase in a meaningful way.

My son is 12 and has grown up watching games with me (poor kid). Because losing is mostly what he’s seen, he already has that classic East Coast cynicism about Rutgers. He doesn't even get his hopes up anymore, he just expects them to lose. My 8 year old is already on that same mindset. My nephew who currently goes to RU doesn't even go to the games anymore.

That's how you lose the next generation of fans.
Fans can be loyal. But they need to see the people in charge are competent. Grego Schiano is incompetent.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RW90

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,664
151,489
113
NJ is the most negative cynical place I’ve personally ever experienced. And Rutgers Footbsll does nothing but enhance it.
 

RedChucken123

Senior
Oct 21, 2015
497
586
88
What school admins and critics need to understand is that donor bases are built through generations. It’s hard to just turn on the whim and ask for money.

My generation (Millennials) experienced Schiano 1.0 and had fond memories of those years. And even though I went to the big football games back then and rarely went to basketball games, I’ve now been a Men’s basketball season ticket holder for 7-8 years. Schiano is washed up and he needs to go now, but I can’t deny the memories and Rutgers pride I had back then. Trust me. If I had millionaire/billionaire money, I’d be donating, but us Millennials right now are trying to get through life right now starting families and buying first homes. We can’t donate a lot right now, but at the moment, we contribute by buying tickets.

So then what about the generation(s) before Millennials? I can’t speak for their memories surrounding athletics. I am sure we have hardcore fans and that’s probably what’s consisting of our current donor base. Correct me if I’m wrong. Thank you to those of you that do donate. But we need moments that capture lasting memories. That way this donor base hopefully would’ve been bigger. Let’s be real. If your memories were more fond of academics, then you’d probably donate to that department before you donate to athletics. When you haven’t been to March Madness in 30+ years and have barely been to any decent bowl games, this is what happens leading up to Schiano 1.0. I don’t blame anyone for not donating bigger amounts of money when we have barely proven ourselves. For those of you that donate, you had to have had moment(s) that stick out in your memories. You’re not just writing checks for the hell of it, right?

In this time of crappy football, what Kelli needs to do is at least get us to March Madnesses again (men & women). In that case, at least the next generation of hardcore sports fans haven’t been completely lost. The Duke, Indiana, UNC’s out there have always been basketball schools, but I’m sure they still have better budgets for football than we do.
 

iReC89

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2014
2,551
1,971
78
Remind me again, which generation experienced winning? Rutgers football has been a gathering place for the broader Rutgers community, which remains strong. Rutgers remains a highly sought after destination for many high school seniors, and the prestige of the university as a whole continues to reach new heights. There are a lot of positive ways to join the Rutgers community without football winning. I’m not worried about a season like this affecting the Rutgers I have to known.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tomatocan

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,661
4,016
108
Remind me again, which generation experienced winning? Rutgers football has been a gathering place for the broader Rutgers community, which remains strong. Rutgers remains a highly sought after destination for many high school seniors, and the prestige of the university as a whole continues to reach new heights. There are a lot of positive ways to join the Rutgers community without football winning. I’m not worried about a season like this affecting the Rutgers I have to known.
There are small pockets. Basketball mid 70s and football 2005-2011 had SOME success but it’s not like we win a national title or even a conference title.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RedChucken123

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,661
4,016
108
I have two years until my oldest is in college. She said last week she wants to go to a school with a football team. Two more years and I can ethically root for someone else. Counting down the days
Many students want this. My son did and some of his Rutgers friends, even a kid from Vermont chose Rutgers because of big time athletics. They are not leaving with any type of good memories.
 

NewHondo77

Junior
Jul 8, 2025
192
202
43
Remind me again, which generation experienced winning? Rutgers football has been a gathering place for the broader Rutgers community, which remains strong. Rutgers remains a highly sought after destination for many high school seniors, and the prestige of the university as a whole continues to reach new heights. There are a lot of positive ways to join the Rutgers community without football winning. I’m not worried about a season like this affecting the Rutgers I have to known.
My dad took me to games when Bateman was the coach. I was in school when Frank Burns was coach. I helped tear down Princeton’s goalposts in the 6-6 game.
 

ScarletKid2008

Heisman
Sep 8, 2006
8,098
10,683
113
This post and thesis is the single most frustrating point of the program since Flood imploded.

the direct financial and indirect branding / perception fallout of these ongoing years is getting more severe. We’re literally going to bleed ourselves out and dry. Losing generations of potential fans, students, sponsors , season ticket holders , etc.

Even if you start winning … it would need to be sustained to restart and refill the pipeline.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tomatocan and SF88

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,661
4,016
108
This post and thesis is the single most frustrating point of the program since Flood imploded.

the direct financial and indirect branding / perception fallout of these ongoing years is getting more severe. We’re literally going to bleed ourselves out and dry. Losing generations of potential fans, students, sponsors , season ticket holders , etc.

Even if you start winning … it would need to be sustained to restart and refill the pipeline.
Exactly, it is not like the day you start winning, you 100% gain all of the people that would have been fans for decades had the program not been terrible. You do get a nice bump, let’s call it the low hanging fruit, as we saw with basketball and football when they had some moderate success, but it takes decades to build the type of fan base we are competing against.
 

ScarletKid2008

Heisman
Sep 8, 2006
8,098
10,683
113
Next season is going to be epically bad and pathetic. Today’s crowd was boosted by 7-10k of Nebraska fans. And even still it was a morgue in there. Maybe 200 students. That’s not an exaggeration at all.

next season is dead on arrival .
even if you get a top 20 transfer portal class , nobody is coming because nobody will know or care anymore outside the same 200 people posting on these boards.
 

kupuna133

All-American
Jul 13, 2015
7,816
9,047
113
Next season is going to be epically bad and pathetic. Today’s crowd was boosted by 7-10k of Nebraska fans. And even still it was a morgue in there. Maybe 200 students. That’s not an exaggeration at all.

next season is dead on arrival .
even if you get a top 20 transfer portal class , nobody is coming because nobody will know or care anymore outside the same 200 people posting on these boards.
There were 23 students in the student section midway through the 3rd quarter.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,661
4,016
108
Next season is going to be epically bad and pathetic. Today’s crowd was boosted by 7-10k of Nebraska fans. And even still it was a morgue in there. Maybe 200 students. That’s not an exaggeration at all.

next season is dead on arrival .
even if you get a top 20 transfer portal class , nobody is coming because nobody will know or care anymore outside the same 200 people posting on these boards.
There is a growing number that have jumped on board the idea that with a top 20 portal class, the team still wouldn’t be good. It is good to be very hard for Schiano to generate interest.
 

Rutgers Chris

All-American
Nov 29, 2005
6,030
7,356
97
There is a growing number that have jumped on board the idea that with a top 20 portal class, the team still wouldn’t be good. It is good to be very hard for Schiano to generate interest.
I will say to all of them…
GIF by South Park

To clarify, I stopped reading at top 20 portal class lol
 
Last edited:

hinson32

All-American
Jul 29, 2005
7,986
6,315
57
RU loses so much that we can't even build or grow the fanbase in a meaningful way.

My son is 12 and has grown up watching games with me (poor kid). Because losing is mostly what he’s seen, he already has that classic East Coast cynicism about Rutgers. He doesn't even get his hopes up anymore, he just expects them to lose. My 8 year old is already on that same mindset. My nephew who currently goes to RU doesn't even go to the games anymore.

That's how you lose the next generation of fans.
After 40 years of bad foot
RU loses so much that we can't even build or grow the fanbase in a meaningful way.

My son is 12 and has grown up watching games with me (poor kid). Because losing is mostly what he’s seen, he already has that classic East Coast cynicism about Rutgers. He doesn't even get his hopes up anymore, he just expects them to lose. My 8 year old is already on that same mindset. My nephew who currently goes to RU doesn't even go to the games anymore.

That's how you lose the next generation of fans.
indiana was horrible at football for 40 years. Two good seasons and they sel out every game. What happened to their lost generations?
 

RedChucken123

Senior
Oct 21, 2015
497
586
88
There’s a difference between selling tickets versus having donors. When you have something to sell and can be in contention, anyone can justify buying tickets whether you’re an alumni or not. You have to get good first and that’s where maintaining generations of fans who can donate will play a role.

I’d argue you don’t have to specifically be a Rutgers football fan, but at least a Rutgers sports fan to maintain a generation of potential donors (I.e. Mark Cuban & Indiana basketball) Just because many of us experienced Schiano 1.0 doesn’t mean that we wouldn’t support men’s basketball in the future. The only issue is that football is a bigger draw for potential sports fans in general and future prospective Rutgers students/donors.
 

RUfrom NJ

Senior
Jul 22, 2025
322
468
63
I’m trying my hardest with my 2 daughters (aged 6 and 4). They’re too young to understand the lengths and depths of the suffering. We live in Florida now, so the novelty of going to a game, seeing the horse, the cannon, For Whom the Bell Tolls (which they love) is there regardless of how miserable the program is. They know Rutgers as “daddy’s team” and “where mommy and daddy became friends.” They’ll sit with me and watch on tv for as long as I can stand it. My 4 year old asks “is Rutgers gonna win Dada?” at the start of every game. I don’t have the heart to tell her what I really think.

We’ll be up in NJ for Thanksgiving. They’ve been asking to go to a game, so I’m planning to take them against MSU. Its just disheartening that the experience will be nothing like their parents know the place can be.
 

Rutgers Chris

All-American
Nov 29, 2005
6,030
7,356
97
I’m trying my hardest with my 2 daughters (aged 6 and 4). They’re too young to understand the lengths and depths of the suffering. We live in Florida now, so the novelty of going to a game, seeing the horse, the cannon, For Whom the Bell Tolls (which they love) is there regardless of how miserable the program is. They know Rutgers as “daddy’s team” and “where mommy and daddy became friends.” They’ll sit with me and watch on tv for as long as I can stand it. My 4 year old asks “is Rutgers gonna win Dada?” at the start of every game. I don’t have the heart to tell her what I really think.

We’ll be up in NJ for Thanksgiving. They’ve been asking to go to a game, so I’m planning to take them against MSU. Its just disheartening that the experience will be nothing like their parents know the place can be.
Raised my two the same way, it’s character building. They both love college football and will choose their own schools accordingly now
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUfrom NJ

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,661
4,016
108
After 40 years of bad foot

indiana was horrible at football for 40 years. Two good seasons and they sel out every game. What happened to their lost generations?

After 40 years of bad foot

indiana was horrible at football for 40 years. Two good seasons and they sel out every game. What happened to their lost generations?
Few thoughts here:

1. Selling out every game is great but doesn’t mean that Indiana’s fan support has caught up to the massive fan bases that have been building for decades. If I’m not mistaken, Indiana has 30-40 million in NIL whereas some programs have 50 million. Although NIL is not supplied by the fan baee, I’m assuming the NIL level has some correlation to the level of fan support.

2. Indiana has even more living alumni than we do, 700,000 I think. We always say that Rutgers is a sleeping giant but Indiana was too. There aren’t that many alumni bases this large.

3. What happened at Indiana is a one off and can’t be used as an example. That type of turnaround may not happen again for 25 years or more as it took a crazy combo of Cuban + Cignetti to lead to the playoff in year 1. See Northwestern who is usually also bad in football and only has 260,000 living alumni and they are struggling with attendance despite having a good season in a new stadium.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,661
4,016
108
Probably having a successful basketball program, one that has won multiple championships and been to the tournament over 40 times, helped maintain and grow their fanbase.
Yeah, I left that out of my post but unlike us with both sports typically awful, they had one of the largest bball fan bases established.

Thats why I said it’s hard to even find a ‘comp’ for Rutgers. Northwestern is the closest.
 

RU#1fan

Heisman
Mar 7, 2003
24,449
13,070
113
Few thoughts here:

1. Selling out every game is great but doesn’t mean that Indiana’s fan support has caught up to the massive fan bases that have been building for decades. If I’m not mistaken, Indiana has 30-40 million in NIL whereas some programs have 50 million. Although NIL is not supplied by the fan baee, I’m assuming the NIL level has some correlation to the level of fan support.

2. Indiana has even more living alumni than we do, 700,000 I think. We always say that Rutgers is a sleeping giant but Indiana was too. There aren’t that many alumni bases this large.

3. What happened at Indiana is a one off and can’t be used as an example. That type of turnaround may not happen again for 25 years or more as it took a crazy combo of Cuban + Cignetti to lead to the playoff in year 1. See Northwestern who is usually also bad in football and only has 260,000 living alumni and they are struggling with attendance despite having a good season in a new stadium.
When you charge $250 per ticket per game any program will have trouble selling tickets not just Northwestern.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Men's Soccer earns NCAA Tournament berth for first time since 2022
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football versus Michigan State Game Time Announced
  3. 03 The Knight Report Basketball Rutgers vs. Albany: How to Watch, Starting Lineups, Rankings & More
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Wrestling Takes Down No. 13 Lehigh - Breaking Down Huge Ranked Win - TKR Pod
  5. 05 On3 Football Over 35% of Power Four starting quarterbacks missed games with injuries in 2026