10-2 IOWA will make the CFP. Many "experts" are saying it. Are "the experts" right?

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,045
29,092
113
Here's how the Top 25 fared.

Will Iowa jump 2 spots, to #13, as a result?

CFP Top 25 Rankings:​

  1. WON Georgia (9-1); beat Mizzou 48-21
  2. WON Utah (10-0); beat Arizona 40-39
  3. WON Alabama (8-2); beat Vandy 21-6
  4. WON UCLA (10-0); beat Illinois 22-14
  5. WON Notre Dame (9-1); beat BC 41-7
  6. WON Texas (8-2); beat LSU 22-21
  7. WON Miami (9-1); beat duke 36-25
  8. WON Tennessee (8-2); beat T A&M 22-7
  9. WON Indiana (9-1); beat USC 27-13
  10. WON BYU (8-2); beat Baylor 28-7
  11. LOST Kentucky (7-3); 21-14 to Florida
  12. WON Texas Tech (9-1); beat OK State 52-27
  13. WON Wake Forest (9-1); beat SMU 49-7
  14. LOST Houston (7-3); 42-32 to Colorado
  15. WON IOWA (8-2); beat Purdue 28-7
  16. WON Oregon (7-3); beat Michigan 31-7
  17. LOST South Carolina (6-4); 34-6 to Arkansas
  18. LOST USC (7-3); 27-13 to IU
  19. Ole Miss (6-3)
  20. WON Ohio State (7-3); beat N'w 28-19
  21. LOST LSU (6-4); 22-21 to Texas
  22. LOST Missouri (6-4); 48-21 to Georgia
  23. LOST Arizona (7-3); 40-39 to Utah
  24. WON Boise State (8-1); beat Oregon St. 46-41
  25. LOST Oklahoma State (6-4); 52-27 to Texas Tech
 

RuggieC

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2014
639
1,272
93
We will either be 13 or 14 on Tuesday. Depends if Oregon jumps us or not. Worst case we need to move up 2 slots in two weeks. Need some help and/or committee love to get there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hawkdave007

yrunvs

Senior
Feb 18, 2012
319
540
93
There may not be a path to getting into the playoff even if Iowa wins out which is not by any means a sure thing.
I'm prepared to enjoy the rest of the season win or lose. So much about the CFP rankings is political and subjective that I have checked out on it.
If we get in great if not then a Jan1/2 bowl game is perfectly fine.
 

NorthernHawkeye

All-Conference
Dec 23, 2007
3,046
4,277
113
The remaining schedules of the teams above us look very easy. I don't see any losses coming these next couple weeks. You can point to the conference championship games in the ACC and Big 12 but I dont think those teams will get penalized for losing.
 

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,662
5,344
113
Here's how the Top 25 fared.

Will Iowa jump 2 spots, to #13, as a result?

CFP Top 25 Rankings:​

  1. WON Georgia (9-1); beat Mizzou 48-21
  2. WON Utah (10-0); beat Arizona 40-39
  3. WON Alabama (8-2); beat Vandy 21-6
  4. WON UCLA (10-0); beat Illinois 22-14
  5. WON Notre Dame (9-1); beat BC 41-7
  6. WON Texas (8-2); beat LSU 22-21
  7. WON Miami (9-1); beat duke 36-25
  8. WON Tennessee (8-2); beat T A&M 22-7
  9. WON Indiana (9-1); beat USC 27-13
  10. WON BYU (8-2); beat Baylor 28-7
  11. LOST Kentucky (7-3); 21-14 to Florida
  12. WON Texas Tech (9-1); beat OK State 52-27
  13. WON Wake Forest (9-1); beat SMU 49-7
  14. LOST Houston (7-3); 42-32 to Colorado
  15. WON IOWA (8-2); beat Purdue 28-7
  16. WON Oregon (7-3); beat Michigan 31-7
  17. LOST South Carolina (6-4); 34-6 to Arkansas
  18. LOST USC (7-3); 27-13 to IU
  19. Ole Miss (6-3)
  20. WON Ohio State (7-3); beat N'w 28-19
  21. LOST LSU (6-4); 22-21 to Texas
  22. LOST Missouri (6-4); 48-21 to Georgia
  23. LOST Arizona (7-3); 40-39 to Utah
  24. WON Boise State (8-1); beat Oregon St. 46-41
  25. LOST Oklahoma State (6-4); 52-27 to Texas Tech
Yes, we should be 13th but we need to be at least 11th come time they add Boise.

If the CFP pickers give the hawks 14-17 pts because of their defense, which they are worth holding a high scoring PU team to 7, then the hawks get in at 10-2

Still afraid the Big 12 might get 3 and SEC 4 which doesnt leave much room if ACC gets 2 and Big has 2 ahead of Iowa. Just cant imagine the weak Big 12 getting three teams in
 

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,662
5,344
113
The remaining schedules of the teams above us look very easy. I don't see any losses coming these next couple weeks. You can point to the conference championship games in the ACC and Big 12 but I dont think those teams will get penalized for losing.
If the Big 12 gets 3 teams in the hawks have no chance as they will take BYU or the hawks
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,045
29,092
113
There may not be a path to getting into the playoff even if Iowa wins out which is not by any means a sure thing.
I'm prepared to enjoy the rest of the season win or lose. So much about the CFP rankings is political and subjective that I have checked out on it.
If we get in great if not then a Jan1/2 bowl game is perfectly fine.

unfortunately you are right. the selection process is political and there's ton of bias for the SEC
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,045
29,092
113
The remaining schedules of the teams above us look very easy. I don't see any losses coming these next couple weeks. You can point to the conference championship games in the ACC and Big 12 but I dont think those teams will get penalized for losing.

I just hope we don't get jumped by Oregon this week. Then we would have to jump 3 teams in 2 weeks.

#9 Indiana (9-1):
at Washington; vs Purdue
#10 BYU (8-2): at Kansas; vs Cincinnati
#11 Kentucky (7-3) LOST; IOWA SHOULD PASS
#12 Texas Tech (9-1):
at Baylor; vs TCU
#13 Wake Forest (9-1): at Georgia Tech; vs Duke
#14 Houston (7-3) LOST; IOWA SHOULD PASS

#15 IOWA (8-2): at Illinois; vs Nebraska

#16 Oregon (7-3): at Michigan State; vs Washington
 

WeBeHerkin

All-American
Aug 5, 2016
5,732
6,492
113
I just hope we don't get jumped by Oregon this week. Then we would have to jump 3 teams in 2 weeks.

#9 Indiana (9-1):
at Washington; vs Purdue
#10 BYU (8-2): at Kansas; vs Cincinnati
#11 Kentucky (7-3) LOST; IOWA SHOULD PASS
#12 Texas Tech (9-1):
at Baylor; vs TCU
#13 Wake Forest (9-1): at Georgia Tech; vs Duke
#14 Houston (7-3) LOST; IOWA SHOULD PASS

#15 IOWA (8-2): at Illinois; vs Nebraska

#16 Oregon (7-3): at Michigan State; vs Washington
They lost to Illinois badly. Iowa plays there this week. In my opinion that is the measuring stick.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,045
29,092
113
Yes, we should be 13th but we need to be at least 11th come time they add Boise.

If the CFP pickers give the hawks 14-17 pts because of their defense, which they are worth holding a high scoring PU team to 7, then the hawks get in at 10-2

Still afraid the Big 12 might get 3 and SEC 4 which doesnt leave much room if ACC gets 2 and Big has 2 ahead of Iowa. Just cant imagine the weak Big 12 getting three teams in

Crazy that 3 Big 12 teams could make the CFP....
Utah (10-0)
BYU (8-2)
Texas Tech (9-1)
 

DukeSlater

All-American
Jul 2, 2023
2,464
5,465
113
The remaining schedules of the teams above us look very easy. I don't see any losses coming these next couple weeks. You can point to the conference championship games in the ACC and Big 12 but I dont think those teams will get penalized for losing.
Did you see Colorado beating Houston? Did you see Florida beating Kentucky on the road? Did you see Iowa coughing up the ball over and over and lining up offside on 4th and goal to hand the game to Minnesota? Stuff happens every week. Iowa takes care of business, then let's see what happens.

BTW: This season is exactly why a 24-team playoff will be welcome and why it should have been 24 all along. That many teams, which then puts FBS in line with every other division of football in terms of percent of teams qualifying for the playoffs, essentially removes the politics from the process. Sure, the 25th and 26th and 27th teams will cry foul, but they won't have a case. Twenty-four teams will include everyone who deserves it, and probably a few who don't, which is fine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hawkeyewx

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,045
29,092
113
Twenty-four teams will include everyone who deserves it, and probably a few who don't, which is fine.

Last year IOWA was really humming at the end of the season; they probably would have made noise in a 24 team playoff.

I think IOWA would make noise in a 24 team playoff this year, too.

Non-CFP bowl games are meaningless now, imo....
 

WDSMHawk

All-American
Jun 30, 2019
1,960
5,130
113
If Iowa, Ohio St, and Oregon all win out. Iowa would probably need at least two of Tennessee, Texas Tech, Wake Forest and BYU to lose one more regular season game for me to feel like they are safely in.
 

trfhawk

Senior
Jul 10, 2020
243
429
63
I am afraid they will have Oregon jump us, which is gonna suck big time if they do
What is probably going to happen is exactly what many of us who dislike the playoff system is looking probable. 3 loss SEC teams will be getting bids over one and two loss teams from other leagues.
Expanding to 24 teams will mean half the SEC will be going to the playoffs.
The SEC teams should be required to play at least 9 conference games.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,045
29,092
113

​

College Football Playoff bracket for Week 12: Projecting top four seeds, first-round matchups, bubble teams​


Bill Bender
The Sporting News
Nov 15, 2026

12 team playoff:

1. Georgia
2. Utah
3. UCLA
4. Notre Dame
5. Miami
6. Texas
7. Indiana
8. Alabama
9. Texas Tech
10. Tennessee
11. Wake Forest
12. Boise State

Projected CFP bubble teams​

BYU (8-2)​

The committee has the Cougars in the 12-team field, but the Red Raiders have a better path to the Big 12 championship game. BYU beat Baylor 28-7 behind Bear Bachmeier (14 of 24, 104 yards, TD). He added 54 rushing yards and three TDs. Baylor managed just 238 total yards. BYU plays at Kansas in Week 12.

Oregon (7-3)​

The Ducks have won three in a row after a 31-7 blowout against Michigan. That marks the second time in three seasons Oregon swept Ohio State and Michigan in the regular season. Dylan Raiola (20 of 28, 341 yards, 4 TDs) averages 311.3 passing yards per game with nine TDs and no interceptions through the winning streak. The Ducks play at Michigan State on Friday in Week 12.

Iowa (8-2)​

The Hawkeyes are another team to watch in the Big Ten. Iowa beat Purdue 28-7 behind the same methodical attack under long-time coach Kirk Ferentz. Hank Brown (20 of 29, 188 yards, TD) worked behind a rushing attack led by LJ Phillips Jr. (23-123), and safety Zach Lutmer had 10 tackles. The Hawkeyes have a road trip to Illinois in Week 12.

Ohio State (7-3)​

Ole Miss could go here depending on how the Rebels fare Sunday against Oklahoma. For now, the Buckeyes, who broke a two-game losing streak with a 28-19 victory against Northwestern, remain on the playoff fringe ahead of USC, who also has three losses. Receiver Jeremiah Smith (11-117, TD) remains in the Heisman Trophy hunt, and Ohio State can lean on its strength of schedule for an at-large case.

 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,045
29,092
113
What is probably going to happen is exactly what many of us who dislike the playoff system is looking probable. 3 loss SEC teams will be getting bids over one and two loss teams from other leagues.
Expanding to 24 teams will mean half the SEC will be going to the playoffs.
The SEC teams should be required to play at least 9 conference games.

To be eligible for next year's 24-team CFP, you have to play 10 "Power 4" games.
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Football Recruiting Inside the rankings on Iowa's 2027 recruiting class
  2. 02 On3 Basketball Women's College Basketball Rankings: AP Poll Top 25 released after Week 2
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Basketball Top takeaways from the Hawkeyes win over Vanderbilt
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Football Recruiting Following the future
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Basketball McCollum, Hawkeyes talk loss to Creighton