I watched the entire OSU/Nebby match. My overall feeling is it was a match that would have gone over really well in Piscataway, NJ. Take Forrest out of the equation (and Raney since he was wrestling a guy that wasn't a serious D1 candidate) and what are you left with - 8 one takedown or zero takedown matches. Yawn.
And on the OSU/PSU question - I don't see OSU winning any matches on the back end and the best I see is 3 on the front end (but it could be zero in a worst case). 125 and 141 are virtual locks for PSU. Throw in likely bonus points for PSU on the back end and no bonus for OSU and it's not a close dual meet.