OT - Allar’s development

Nitt1300

Heisman
Nov 2, 2008
8,105
15,172
113
Franklin is a large reason Hack didn't make it
You're right but Franklin isn't good developing QB--especially pocket passers--watch Grunk regressing
Franklin had nothing to do with Hack not making it- Hack was always a horribly inaccurate passer, under every coach he worked with
 
  • Like
Reactions: m.knox

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Franklin had nothing to do with Hack not making it- Hack was always a horribly inaccurate passer, under every coach he worked with
Franklin had a ton to do with Hack not developing--his completion percentage dropped each year
What other coach are you talking about? With the Jets--by then Franklin already broke him mentally
You see Grunk is regressing, right? You've read all the comments about how McCarthy had to tear down Allar and build him from nothing.
Franklin doesn't hire good QB coaches--he never has--and he doesn't build offenses around what he has--he tries to make them fit his dumbass scheme that doesn't work
 

Nitt1300

Heisman
Nov 2, 2008
8,105
15,172
113
Franklin had a ton to do with Hack not developing--his completion percentage dropped each year
What other coach are you talking about? With the Jets--by then Franklin already broke him mentally
O'Brien. obviously- plus the Jets, plus the semi-pro league after that
He was never accurate
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
O'Brien. obviously- plus the Jets, plus the semi-pro league after that
He was never accurate
O'Brien had him for 1 year--which was his best--he would have continued to improve had he received decent or real coaching
By the time he left Penn State he was broken beyond repair
You can't watch Hack as a freshman and pretend he wasn't on the right track--you can't. It's insincere.
Watch Grunk--the proof is right there. He's scared in the pocket already--it will get worse.
 

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
538
271
63
Franklin had a ton to do with Hack not developing--his completion percentage dropped each year
What other coach are you talking about? With the Jets--by then Franklin already broke him mentally
You see Grunk is regressing, right? You've read all the comments about how McCarthy had to tear down Allar and build him from nothing.
Franklin doesn't hire good QB coaches--he never has--and he doesn't build offenses around what he has--he tries to make them fit his dumbass scheme that doesn't work
Who coached becht this year?
 

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
538
271
63
O'Brien had him for 1 year--which was his best--he would have continued to improve had he received decent or real coaching
By the time he left Penn State he was broken beyond repair
You can't watch Hack as a freshman and pretend he wasn't on the right track--you can't. It's insincere.
Watch Grunk--the proof is right there. He's scared in the pocket already--it will get worse.
Did becht improve this year?
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Who coached becht this year?
What does Becht have to do with the discussion? Did someone claim he was an NFL QB or would have been?
Thankfully he didn't play for Franklin though or he wouldn't have had the success he has
Hack was overrated to begin with. Statue, no mobility, and no accuracy.
Yeah, that's why many said he'd be the first pick in the draft after his freshman year and still went in the second despite Franklin ruining him
 

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
538
271
63
Yes, his QBR is higher than the past two years and his numbers across the board are better in a far more difficult league without his best WR for most of the year--and no run games for half of it
Yes, his QBR is higher than the past two years and his numbers across the board are better in a far more difficult league without his best WR for most of the year--and no run games for half of it
Did lonergon improve with obrien or did obrien ruin him? Kid could have been a star.
 

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
538
271
63
What does Becht have to do with the discussion? Did someone claim he was an NFL QB or would have been?
Thankfully he didn't play for Franklin though or he wouldn't have had the success he has

Yeah, that's why many said he'd be the first pick in the draft after his freshman year and still went in the second despite Franklin ruining him


They say that about someone every year and half of them are busts.
 

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
538
271
63
Sure...and often times it's largely due to the lack of coaching and development.
Sure...and often times it's largely due to the lack of coaching and development.
Bs. Alabama and teams with great coaches have plenty of busts.


Which incoming freshman do you have penciled in as a first round pick? Take your pick of any qb with any great coach.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: KingLando

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Bs. Alabama and teams with great coaches have plenty of busts.


Which incoming freshman do you have penciled in as a first round pick? Take your pick of any qb with any great coach.
We don't know where they'll be of who their coaches will be. No one is going anywhere for sure other than Rivers kid with play for daddy
 

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
538
271
63
We don't know where they'll be of who their coaches will be. No one is going anywhere for sure other than Rivers kid with play for daddy


You supposedly could see the future with hack and he was going to develop into a pro bowl qb with obrien . Tell us which incoming qb will be a first rounder. You can pick any qb.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
You supposedly could see the future with hack and he was going to develop into a pro bowl qb with obrien . Tell us which incoming qb will be a first rounder. You can pick any qb.
We saw Hack play in college...we haven't seen any incoming freshman play
See how that works
I also didn't say he would be a first round pick...I said he was projected to be then Franklin decided to force him to run read option.
 

SkiSkiSki

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
4,031
1,635
113
How Rodgers Is Helping Allar Develop
  • On-field mechanics and drills. According to reports from The Athletic and NBC Sports, Rodgers frequently pulls Allar aside during practice to offer specific pointers on drill work, drop depths, footwork, and hand signals.
  • Film room sessions. Allar noted that Rodgers quizzes him during film study—asking what he sees on specific plays, where his eyes are looking, and why he makes certain reads—to help speed up his processing against NFL defenses.
  • System familiarity. Because Rodgers spent over a decade playing in head coach Mike McCarthy's West Coast offense in Green Bay, he has served as an extra resource helping Allar master the nuances of McCarthy's scheme.
 

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
538
271
63
We saw Hack play in college...we haven't seen any incoming freshman play
See how that works
I also didn't say he would be a first round pick...I said he was projected to be then Franklin decided to force him to run read option.


Ok. Tell us the college freshman who is going to be a first round pick. See how that works?
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Ok. Tell us the college freshman who is going to be a first round pick. See how that works?
You're still not following the conversation--the entire discussion is a QB that has first round potential can be stunted by bad coaching.
Keelon Russell is the only one we've actually really seen a lot of from the true freshman to make that decision but will he stay at Bama, will DeBoer cater the offense to him, will DeBoer stay--these are factors that can hinder one's development as we saw when James ruined Hack then later Allar. Hopefully Allar's career can still be salvaged.
 
  • Like
Reactions: psu83

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Franklin severely damaged Allar’s development by hiring a gimmicky OC that runs a scheme meant for a dual threat qb, not a dropback gunslinger. And Danny O’Brien was an awful qb coach.
Exactly. Not even sure why anyone would dispute this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: psu83

Kroixklk

All-Conference
Aug 16, 2006
603
1,185
93
Did becht improve this year?
Rocco’s issues aren’t talent related. They are decision making. He throws some inaccurate balls but what kills him are poor decisions. Can’t find holes to run, throws late, stares down receives.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Rocco’s issues aren’t talent related. They are decision making. He throws some inaccurate balls but what kills him are poor decisions. Can’t find holes to run, throws late, stares down receives.
Rocco was awful in 2 games (Wisconsin & Michigan) but other than that he's been fine. I'm not sure what people were expecting. He's done better this year than the prior 2 years while playing in a far better conference.
 

PSU89er

Junior
Nov 22, 2023
304
399
63
First team All-American WR Allen Robinson was the reason.

Hack regressed immediately after Robinson went to the NFL.

Id argue that four other guys had a bigger impact on Hack than losing Robinson.

Gress, Urschel, Stankewitch all graduated and Dieffenbaugh had a career ending injury. The Hack oline of 2013 might have been the worst in the history of PSU football. They moved two defensive lineman to the oline just to get 10 olineman on scholarship and that included four true freshman.

That oline was getting Hack killed if BOB, Franklin or god was the head coach, and people dont understand why Hack regressed.
 

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
538
271
63
You're still not following the conversation--the entire discussion is a QB that has first round potential can be stunted by bad coaching.
Keelon Russell is the only one we've actually really seen a lot of from the true freshman to make that decision but will he stay at Bama, will DeBoer cater the offense to him, will DeBoer stay--these are factors that can hinder one's development as we saw when James ruined Hack then later Allar. Hopefully Allar's career can still be salvaged.



He is in his second year. Same class as underwood who was already benched and tavian st Clair whi can't get on the field.
 

SummitLion

Freshman
Oct 14, 2021
71
74
18
Rocco’s issues aren’t talent related. They are decision making. He throws some inaccurate balls but what kills him are poor decisions. Can’t find holes to run, throws late, stares down receives.
And he throws sidearm and gets a lot of passes batted down. Ive never seen anything like it.
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Penn State TE Benjamin Brahmer announces he'll return for the 2027 season
  2. 02 BWI Football Penn State Transfer Portal Preview: Four Potential Quarterback Targets to Know for 2027
  3. 03 BWI Football Trimmings: Penn State's Senior Day list and what we're hearing on those who could come back for 2027
  4. 04 BWI Basketball Penn State set to add international point guard Savo Drezgic
  5. 05 BWI Football Matt Campbell says Penn State became a real team, now wants to prove it for 60 minutes