Few things:You are correct that I didn’t watch or closely follow all of the college field hockey games this year (I don’t think that should disqualify me from stating an opinion that I’ll try to support more with evidence here). I see scores and have a general understanding of the teams, programs and trends and I’m not totally uneducated about the landscape. I’ll maintain that the sport is “predictable” in the sense that upsets are rare, and the consensus preseason favorites generally have the seasons the polls suggest they will.
Predictably to me in any sport is when ranked teams win 88% of matches against unranked opponents (which is what happened this year, consistent with the last decade), the top seeds advance to the Final Four (which happened this year, and there have only been 4 unseeded teams to make the FF in the last 5 years, so out of 20 teams, and until this year only the top 4 were even seeded), and when teams ranked 5 or places higher than their opponent win 72% of the time (men’s basketball is around 60% for comparison).
My only real point is that I don’t think we played up to expectations and my initial question on this board was to ask why (which is admittedly hard to quantify no matter how close one is to the program).
We were #2 preseason without the assumption that we’d have our grad players. In my opinion, it is rare for a team in this sport to underperform to that degree - and I doubt there has been another team in the last decade who was that highly ranked (and later added a trio of stars), yet struggled like we did through the regular season to barely make the NCAAT.
I was proud of them today and they almost had a backdoor FF to show for their tremendous goalkeeping and defense, but we were severely out-played and I won’t be convinced that they had the season they expected, the prognosticators expected, or the fans that are more engaged than me expected.
1. If that’s your view on predictability, fair. However, I’ve watched enough field hockey to know the margins the thin, especially amongst ranked teams. The best team doesn’t always win. Will just have to agree to disagree on that. Even Karen’s team would lose often when favored. Duke, Wake Forest and UNC all lost in the ACC tourney this year via upsets.
2. Yes, we were ranked #2, but a lot of that was due to our name. We didn’t look great at all in the Spring exhibitions, and many on here felt that we were extremely over ranked coming into the year. Erin’s interviews over the summer also made it pretty clear this was a transition year. We can’t help that we were being overrated. I know this might seem like “cope”, but if you scroll back to the earlier pages, you’ll see the discussion that took place over being over ranked. @3397char will back me up on this as he was one the key people warnings others that this might be a rebuilding year.
3. I don’t think anyone on here would say we met our expectations after the 3 stars became eligible. Don’t get me wrong, we should have done better. However, there is context to explain why the struggles continued, and I wouldn’t blame Erin.
4. The problem I had with your initial point was that it seemed that you were implying Erin’s social media posts and/or other actions led to this year being unsuccessful and that she might not be doing the best job she could be. If that was not your implication, I apologize.
As a whole, Erin faces a lot of scrutiny from the field hockey community, and it’s just disheartening to see our fans feed into it as well. It takes a few minutes to make a social media post. That’s not impacting her work whatsoever. In four years, she’s won 3 ACC titles, been the #1 seed in the ACC title each year, 3 Final Fours and 1 national title. She gets work done. I just think the social media narrative is lazy, and honestly was the only reason why I decided to quote your post. If anything social media is a strength and has helped grow our program. We’re the most visible program in college field hockey, and that’s important. Her social media has supported that visibility.
Last edited: