Elite 8 momentum = gone

ComradeKirk

All-Conference
Jan 12, 2026
544
1,509
93
Wild take ya say? Get some fresh air ya say? Iowa's last Elite 8 appearance was in 1987. Don't know how your math is, but that's awhile ago.

But now I'm off the rails because Ben McCollum (mini Coach Wooden to some of you apparently) made one in his first season, with a middling 9th place, 10-10 Big Ten Team and that's going to be repeatable? 😂 Ummm, OK.

Go ahead and take your fresh air and bet all your money that Iowa is going to make more of these Elite 8 runs anytime soon and see how you fare. I know reality is difficult for the Sunshine and Puppies crowd, but deal with it as best you can. It's OK if they're just OK, and that's likely what they'll be. When the Basketball Program historically tells you who they are, believe them. (oh yeah, Ben is playing his Son and losing 5 star point guards to Arkansas, that ain't momentum in any way, shape or form)

You can go outside, Chicken Little. The sky isn't falling.
 

The Big Z

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2023
2,349
4,556
113
Wild take ya say? Get some fresh air ya say? Iowa's last Elite 8 appearance was in 1987. Don't know how your math is, but that's awhile ago.

But now I'm off the rails because Ben McCollum (mini Coach Wooden to some of you apparently) made one in his first season, with a middling 9th place, 10-10 Big Ten Team and that's going to be repeatable? 😂 Ummm, OK.

Go ahead and take your fresh air and bet all your money that Iowa is going to make more of these Elite 8 runs anytime soon and see how you fare. I know reality is difficult for the Sunshine and Puppies crowd, but deal with it as best you can. It's OK if they're just OK, and that's likely what they'll be. When the Basketball Program historically tells you who they are, believe them. (oh yeah, Ben is playing his Son and losing 5 star point guards to Arkansas, that ain't momentum in any way, shape or form)
Yep, Ben’s fault he couldn’t come up with 4 million to get him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hawkeye7

HawksRule25

All-American
Sep 8, 2023
6,147
8,824
113
Yep, Ben’s fault he couldn’t come up with 4 million to get him.

 

AndreTheHawk

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2025
1,266
2,629
113
I'm more concerned about players not executing on defense and FTs. I'm fully confident in Ben.
I was far more confident in Ben until he started playing his Son over far more highly recruited players. That sends a bad message to current and future recruits. If his kid stood out would be a different story, but he predictably has not nor will he anytime soon IMO. (he may possibly have some "moments", which anyone playing as much as he has should, that is not a barometer for more playing time at others expense however)

For supposedly being a life long Hawkeye fan, Ben isn't reading the room very well. Doing the exact same thing Fran did, which ultimately led to something called empty seats. If Ben thinks his Son and situation is different, he's going to be in for a letdown.

The question is, who are Iowa's current Keegan and Kris Murray that sat early on and proved that was a huge mistake. All the way to the NBA. This nepotism deja-vu **** is tiring.
 

Hawksfor3

Heisman
Dec 5, 2016
9,870
10,796
113
I was far more confident in Ben until he started playing his Son over far more highly recruited players. That sends a bad message to current and future recruits. If his kid stood out would be a different story, but he predictably has not nor will he anytime soon IMO. (he may possibly have some "moments", which anyone playing as much as he has should, that is not a barometer for more playing time at others expense however)

For supposedly being a life long Hawkeye fan, Ben isn't reading the room very well. Doing the exact same thing Fran did, which ultimately led to something called empty seats. If Ben thinks his Son and situation is different, he's going to be in for a letdown.

The question is, who are Iowa's current Keegan and Kris Murray that sat early on and proved that was a huge mistake. All the way to the NBA. This nepotism deja-vu **** is tiring.
If this happens again, (giving a generous share of minutes to his son, while sitting two others) then I'll jump on your wagon and present you a glass of lemonade. I've given Ben the benefit of the doubt with the roster, because he knows what he has and he is the coach, after all, but my opinion is subject to change at a moment's notice. A privilege I reserve for myself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AndreTheHawk

hawkeyemark18

Senior
Aug 16, 2019
361
618
93
I was far more confident in Ben until he started playing his Son over far more highly recruited players. That sends a bad message to current and future recruits. If his kid stood out would be a different story, but he predictably has not nor will he anytime soon IMO. (he may possibly have some "moments", which anyone playing as much as he has should, that is not a barometer for more playing time at others expense however)

For supposedly being a life long Hawkeye fan, Ben isn't reading the room very well. Doing the exact same thing Fran did, which ultimately led to something called empty seats. If Ben thinks his Son and situation is different, he's going to be in for a letdown.

The question is, who are Iowa's current Keegan and Kris Murray that sat early on and proved that was a huge mistake. All the way to the NBA. This nepotism deja-vu **** is tiring.
Ben not reading the room stands out for me as the key point of this post. It concerned me for example reading that Cooper Koch hung his head in the post game media session. Not involving Cooper in that last play scenario still baffles me. High time for Ben to figure out how he wants to handle end of game situations.

Playing Peyton this much maybe seems to Ben a way of pushing some players he wants to see more out of. If so this has consequences Ben doesn't seem to see. This seems a critical point to see where things go from here. I just want to see a badly needed course correction.
 

MacMiney

Senior
Jul 3, 2025
382
708
93
I found Tyler Tachman's quote from the coach revealing. It's at around 8 minutes left in the Hawk Central podcast. They talk football for most of the pod, then at around 1:01:00 they Tyler goes into the last basketball game.

The impression is that BM is sending a message to the "higher talent guys." He pretty much spelled it out to Tyler.

I think we just need to relax a bit. I mean, very soon we play two very winnable games - at Purdue, home to Indiana. I would imagine whatever BM is being stubborn about now - it's probably important and needs to be resolved now, not in December.

So the son playing thing. I think we all noticed the energy level boost, better passing maybe when he was put in, not much beyond that. So maybe it's just as simple as that for the time being. BM's getting his point across and then some.

It's been a strange start to the season for sure. But also, what was the prevailing opinion of the team last year after their last game prior to Clemson? Hopefully we will have quite a few interesting posts to bump in February. :LOL:

 
Last edited:

J-Prof

Redshirt
Mar 7, 2004
8
23
3
If you have everyone telling you how great you are all the time, it can distort judgment (i.e., not reading the room). I just hope we're not seeing Ben do what Kirk did a few years back: when critics screamed about nepotism, he doubled down (for example, made BF the quarterbacks coach).
Going by what I have seen in games so far, Coon has been highly effective and seems to have the no-fear attitude that Sage had last year. He's the kind of guy you want in at the end of the game.
What little I've seen of Thompson and Harris, albeit in garbage time versus crappy teams, had me impressed. That's not much to go on, I know. Peyton looked good against a couple of crappy teams too, but he has not looked good in the last two games. I'd have loved to know if Thompson (or Harris, who's supposedly a two-guard) could have done better against those quality teams.
 

J-Prof

Redshirt
Mar 7, 2004
8
23
3
So the son playing thing. I think we all noticed the energy level boost, better passing maybe when he was put in, not much beyond that. So maybe it's just as simple as that for the time being. BM's getting his point across and then some.
I don't buy the 'sending a message' thing. You'd sooner lose a game by playing someone a lot of minutes who isn't playing all that well? What's the logic in that?
Also, why play the mind games?
 

MacMiney

Senior
Jul 3, 2025
382
708
93
I don't buy the 'sending a message' thing. You'd sooner lose a game by playing someone a lot of minutes who isn't playing all that well? What's the logic in that?
Also, why play the mind games?
Because he took a 9 seed Iowa team to the elite 8, going through a defending national champ 1 seed in the process. And the crazy thing, if not for that weird horn moment.. we had Illinois on their heels just bit, before that. So it's a trust thing based on something proven. On reality.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hawkeye7

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,101
8,712
113
If you have everyone telling you how great you are all the time, it can distort judgment (i.e., not reading the room). I just hope we're not seeing Ben do what Kirk did a few years back: when critics screamed about nepotism, he doubled down (for example, made BF the quarterbacks coach).
Going by what I have seen in games so far, Coon has been highly effective and seems to have the no-fear attitude that Sage had last year. He's the kind of guy you want in at the end of the game.
What little I've seen of Thompson and Harris, albeit in garbage time versus crappy teams, had me impressed. That's not much to go on, I know. Peyton looked good against a couple of crappy teams too, but he has not looked good in the last two games. I'd have loved to know if Thompson (or Harris, who's supposedly a two-guard) could have done better against those quality teams.
If you have everyone telling you how great you are all the time, it can distort judgment (i.e., not reading the room). I just hope we're not seeing Ben do what Kirk did a few years back: when critics screamed about nepotism, he doubled down (for example, made BF the quarterbacks coach).
Going by what I have seen in games so far, Coon has been highly effective and seems to have the no-fear attitude that Sage had last year. He's the kind of guy you want in at the end of the game.
What little I've seen of Thompson and Harris, albeit in garbage time versus crappy teams, had me impressed. That's not much to go on, I know. Peyton looked good against a couple of crappy teams too, but he has not looked good in the last two games. I'd have loved to know if Thompson (or Harris, who's supposedly a two-guard) could have done better against those quality teams.
I still think its hilarious that after 28 years people still think Kirk bases decisions (basically do the opposite) on what fans think or post. Here's a hint. He doesn't "double down". He doesn't care what we think, nor should he. Any coach who bases his decisions based on what "fans " want or don't want, shouldn't be coaching. That's a weird fan thing, thinking we have some role in decisions. We don't.
 

AndreTheHawk

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2025
1,266
2,629
113
I still think its hilarious that after 28 years people still think Kirk bases decisions (basically do the opposite) on what fans think or post. Here's a hint. He doesn't "double down". He doesn't care what we think, nor should he. Any coach who bases his decisions based on what "fans " want or don't want, shouldn't be coaching. That's a weird fan thing, thinking we have some role in decisions. We don't.
Well you can do that when you have the greatest gig on Planet Earth, Coaching College (or Pro) Sports. You can get paid thru the nose for maybe having 1 good year (not Kirk or many others, but it certainly happens), then you suck and get fired and get a huge $buyout$. The real world doesn't operate that way, and all the rest of us should be very Thankful it doesn't. Somebody always pays, and it ain't just Mark Cuban and friends.
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Football Recruiting Inside the rankings on Iowa's 2028 recruiting class
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Football Recruiting Tracking where Iowa's recruits play this week
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Football Throwback Thursday: Looking back at Illinois' starters as recruits
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Football Throwback Thursday: Looking back at Iowa's starters as recruits
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Basketball Ben McCollum talks recruiting, previews Xavier