Are we better than we think?

BillyC80

Heisman
Oct 23, 2006
17,536
16,168
72
Some will say, “you are what your record says you are” and that’s certainly true in the NFL, but college basketball allows for some “good losses” that do not hurt and may actually help your standing.

So, did we just experience 2 good losses, or nah?

1) Houston: We were never really in this game but kept within striking distance deep into the second half, eventually losing by 12 points, to a top ten team that just beat the #1 ranked team by 10 points. Houston may in fact be the best team in the country right now. So, I count this as a good loss.

2) Notre Dame: We had a chance to win this in regulation before folding in OT. General consensus seems to be that ND may be a top 25 and likely NCAA tournament team. Their only loss is to the aforementioned #1 team. The concern is that, even though they shot lights out (65% including 48% from three) they needed overtime to beat Rutgers. So, IMO this will only become a good loss if ND keeps winning.

Tonight’s game against UNLV now has big implications for our season and bubble potential. Winning would give more credence to the idea that the previous games were good losses, especially since it’s essentially a home game for UNLV, playing only 3 miles from their home court. A “road” win against a decent team will definitely help us evaluate where we stand, hopefully heading in the right direction.
 

BillyC80

Heisman
Oct 23, 2006
17,536
16,168
72
We might be better but that doesn't mean it will translate to wins.

and considering most of the players will transfer at year end which is the new norm in college bball, moral victories and building for the future doesn't exist anymore. So unless we're going to win games now, these losses don't help.
Not considering them as moral victories, but good losses can definitely help prepare a team to win going forward.
 

seansherm

Heisman
Feb 20, 2009
16,302
16,951
113
I think the NIL newcomers are not that good except for Gurdack.
Depends, we don't know yet.

Miteo looks like he's an upgrade on Dortch at back up C. Need better D out of him, alot to ask of someone so young.

This was kind of my expectation for Smith. Somehow his eFG% is identical to LY. Averaging one less rebound per 40 minutes, about what you'd expect with the step up in comp. Still bad on D. Maybe sporadic attempts are why his three point and FT%'s have tanked thus far.

Jones is decent, too hesitant on O, solid on D.

Diego, is probably a small step down from Zrno right now. A little better defensively, worse offensively. Zrno scored more against Tennessee last year than Diego has on the year. Need to see something on that end. Has better court awareness.

Sydnor? I don't know. I'm not convinced this lack of PT is bringing back from injury, but I hope it is. Did anyone see how his attitude was on the bench yesterday?
 

Rutgers25

All-American
Jul 29, 2001
7,981
6,648
83
Depends, we don't know yet.

Miteo looks like he's an upgrade on Dortch at back up C. Need better D out of him, alot to ask of someone so young.

This was kind of my expectation for Smith. Somehow his eFG% is identical to LY. Averaging one less rebound per 40 minutes, about what you'd expect with the step up in comp. Still bad on D. Maybe sporadic attempts are why his three point and FT%'s have tanked thus far.

Jones is decent, too hesitant on O, solid on D.

Diego, is probably a small step down from Zrno right now. A little better defensively, worse offensively. Zrno scored more against Tennessee last year than Diego has on the year. Need to see something on that end. Has better court awareness.

Sydnor? I don't know. I'm not convinced this lack of PT is bringing back from injury, but I hope it is. Did anyone see how his attitude was on the bench yesterday?

I highly doubt the Sydnor thing is injury. To me there is clearly something that B knight doesn’t like in practice
 

BillyC80

Heisman
Oct 23, 2006
17,536
16,168
72
Interesting that some think Notre Dame is a top 25 team, but don’t criticize their defense for giving up 95 points to Rutgers in regulation.

They say ND is better because their offense is better, and yet we matched their offense with 95 points of our own, and came within a foul shot of beating them in regulation.
 

bigbirdru

Senior
Mar 6, 2010
2,302
409
83
Interesting that some think Notre Dame is a top 25 team, but don’t criticize their defense for giving up 95 points to Rutgers in regulation.

They say ND is better because their offense is better, and yet we matched their offense with 95 points of our own, and came within a foul shot of beating them in regulation.
We will see what they are, but they already have a W on neutral court against Nova and a close loss to #1 Florida.
 

Simce91

All-Conference
Dec 2, 2024
2,212
3,064
113
One of the questions I have is where/how does the 4 and 3 spots play out this year ?

The 5 spot looks good as does the 3 headed guard.

Who and how do 80 minutes of Buchanan, Smith, Jones, Syndor, Garravaglia fit/mesh.

Buchanon is Buchanon, I liked what I saw from Smiths O against ND, the D needs work, Jones looks confused, Garravaglia is a foreign frosh, but has the goods to be a positive contributor, and who the heck knows what the deal with Syndor is.

I believe that Knight and staff are in the same boat.

That said, only 5 games in, I've liked what I've seen Knight do, and will have some faith and patience, that it will continue to improve
 

RAC93

All-American
Aug 11, 2023
3,845
6,383
113
Not considering them as moral victories, but good losses can definitely help prepare a team to win going forward.
Dylan and Ace experienced some good losses to Bama and A&M out in Vegas and it didn’t translate. Losses are losses, these 1-2 trips to Vegas (hopefully we win today to even have the 1-2 trip this year, 0-3 would be a disaster) just don’t do much more than add two losses to our record. Like football in some ways, at some point you have to get wins to make a difference and change a bad or meh season into a good one. It’s early, but things are looking real similar with this year’s team to our recent teams. They are better, no doubt, but maybe they win 1 more game than last year??? As far wins and losses record, we likely end up about the same, even though we are clearly improved on offense, defense……ehhhhh, not so much
 

BillyC80

Heisman
Oct 23, 2006
17,536
16,168
72
Dylan and Ace experienced some good losses to Bama and A&M out in Vegas and it didn’t translate. Losses are losses, these 1-2 trips to Vegas (hopefully we win today to even have the 1-2 trip this year, 0-3 would be a disaster) just don’t do much more than add two losses to our record. Like football in some ways, at some point you have to get wins to make a difference and change a bad or meh season into a good one. It’s early, but things are looking real similar with this year’s team to our recent teams. They are better, no doubt, but maybe they win 1 more game than last year??? As far wins and losses record, we likely end up about the same, even though we are clearly improved on offense, defense……ehhhhh, not so much
Good losses only matter if you have enough wins to at least be on the bubble, and if you can avoid other WTF losses.

You also get better as a team by playing better competition, even in a loss.

So yeah, you still have to win games, no one is arguing that.
 

-RUFAN4LIFE-

Heisman
Feb 28, 2015
36,442
56,459
113
Due to all the players they needed to replace and the budget they had, this roster was built to get Rutgers into the middle third of B1G.

They will have better overall performances than last year against top teams but still lose. Their inconsistency has the earmarks of a slightly above .500 team like I've said they would be.

The key here is to build these players up and retain about 2/3 of them so next year they can spend more dollars on upper-level talent.
 

BillyC80

Heisman
Oct 23, 2006
17,536
16,168
72
One of the questions I have is where/how does the 4 and 3 spots play out this year ?

The 5 spot looks good as does the 3 headed guard.

Who and how do 80 minutes of Buchanan, Smith, Jones, Syndor, Garravaglia fit/mesh.

Buchanon is Buchanon, I liked what I saw from Smiths O against ND, the D needs work, Jones looks confused, Garravaglia is a foreign frosh, but has the goods to be a positive contributor, and who the heck knows what the deal with Syndor is.

I believe that Knight and staff are in the same boat.

That said, only 5 games in, I've liked what I've seen Knight do, and will have some faith and patience, that it will continue to improve
All excellent points. I agree the 3 and 4 spots are a work in progress. It seems like there is some untapped potential there, so hopefully Knight and coaches can find the keys to unlocking that potential.

Also have to consider situational possibilities of playing Gurdak and Miteo together, depending on the matchups. That still leaves a question mark at the 3, which could be Smith, Garavaglia, or Sydnor. Someone has to separate themselves.
 

RUDiddy777

Heisman
Feb 26, 2015
34,097
38,635
113
So far this team is similar to Dylan/Ace year. Best offense in a while, questionable defense. Some encouraging losses. But eventually you need it to convert to wins.

I think that’s fair - but we’ll be teaching this D to grown men, not freshman. So I think an expectation for improvement is reasonable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BillyC80

Scarlet Shack

Heisman
Feb 3, 2004
26,409
16,329
73
Mark is looking into coed ans we improved the 5 spot massively over last year

How much we improve will depend on what we get out of jones , sydnor and smith

atay tuned….we don’t know yet
 
  • Like
Reactions: BillyC80

JonathanAlan

Heisman
Jan 14, 2002
6,704
10,810
113
Due to all the players they needed to replace and the budget they had, this roster was built to get Rutgers into the middle third of B1G.

They will have better overall performances than last year against top teams but still lose. Their inconsistency has the earmarks of a slightly above .500 team like I've said they would be.

The key here is to build these players up and retain about 2/3 of them so next year they can spend more dollars on upper-level talent.
I agree with much of this , especially that Rutgers will play good teams tough but lose. To continue to improve Lino Mark needs to distribute the ball more and involve the forwards. Yes he can get to the hoop and draw fouls but he needs look to pass off more and sooner. Mateo has been a revelation . At times he looks lost on defense but you can see the raw talent.
 

-RUFAN4LIFE-

Heisman
Feb 28, 2015
36,442
56,459
113
I agree with much of this , especially that Rutgers will play good teams tough but lose. To continue to improve Lino Mark needs to distribute the ball more and involve the forwards. Yes he can get to the hoop and draw fouls but he needs look to pass off more and sooner. Mateo has been a revelation . At times he looks lost on defense but you can see the raw talent.
I would say all the guards need to distribute more, the shot to assist ratio has not been great.
 

PSAL_Hoops

Heisman
Feb 18, 2008
14,559
13,934
78
Starting to think we are better than we think, after watching 6-1 Notre Dame beat Auburn today and undefeated and likely #1 Houston up by 20 points at the half over #11 Kansas.

Yeah I don’t want us getting ahead of ourselves. We still have to show we can get the job done against NCAA teams. BUT I’m cautiously optimistic about the blend of options on this roster. I say “cautious” because guys like Denis looked like a stud early against Maine and wasn’t able to do anything really against anyone decent. Grant kind of similar last season. But then this team has already played a lot of good competition early between Players era and the exhibitions.
 

RUfan1977

All-Conference
Mar 24, 2024
1,084
1,563
113
Yeah I don’t want us getting ahead of ourselves. We still have to show we can get the job done against NCAA teams. BUT I’m cautiously optimistic about the blend of options on this roster. I say “cautious” because guys like Denis looked like a stud early against Maine and wasn’t able to do anything really against anyone decent. Grant kind of similar last season. But then this team has already played a lot of good competition early between Players era and the exhibitions.
If Rutgers simply plays like they have been playing, we are already a lot better than we were predicted to be. In Kenpom, we have move up from 86 to 67. Smith has a track record of being able to score in college, while Badalau didn’t and really had only one good game. Gurdak, Francis and Mark have all shown they can score against anyone. Except for one game Davis has been great off the bench. Buchanan can play defense and is the third best rebounder. Diego and Jones play defense and are potential threats from 3. Miteo looks like he is already pretty good at either the 5 or 4 if Rutgers needs to go big and Ware and Buca could probably provide decent minutes backing up at the 5 if we needed them. This team can play better defense which is something they can improve at. The biggest weakness that I see is rebounding where Gurdak, Mark, Davis and Buchanan appear to be giving there all, but others not so much. Although part of that is probably by design as players do need to get back on defense while others look to get out on a fast break. Mark is unusual as when he grabs a rebound on defense he has shown he can take it end to end before a team can get back to stop him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RAC’emUp

mugrat86

Heisman
Dec 11, 2014
8,806
11,672
82
Due to all the players they needed to replace and the budget they had, this roster was built to get Rutgers into the middle third of B1G.

They will have better overall performances than last year against top teams but still lose. Their inconsistency has the earmarks of a slightly above .500 team like I've said they would be.

The key here is to build these players up and retain about 2/3 of them so next year they can spend more dollars on upper-level talent.
I will take your predictions with a grain of salt considering your last prediction that Gurdack will be an average center. Great call Mam
 

BillyC80

Heisman
Oct 23, 2006
17,536
16,168
72
Yeah I don’t want us getting ahead of ourselves. We still have to show we can get the job done against NCAA teams. BUT I’m cautiously optimistic about the blend of options on this roster. I say “cautious” because guys like Denis looked like a stud early against Maine and wasn’t able to do anything really against anyone decent. Grant kind of similar last season. But then this team has already played a lot of good competition early between Players era and the exhibitions.
“Starting to think we’re better than we think” is getting ahead of ourselves?

As a 50-year Rutgers fan, I’ve been conditioned to manage expectations.

All I’m saying is, we look a little better than I thought we would at this point in the season, based on the pieces we have now (and not based on the players we used to have).
 

seansherm

Heisman
Feb 20, 2009
16,302
16,951
113
I will take your predictions with a grain of salt considering your last prediction that Gurdack will be an average center. Great call Mam
If you are above average on one side of the court and below average on the other side, wouldn't that average out to average?
 

-RUFAN4LIFE-

Heisman
Feb 28, 2015
36,442
56,459
113
If you are above average on one side of the court and below average on the other side, wouldn't that average out to average?
He's squawking over a guy that is T-212 in ppg and T-111 in rebounding with a limited sample size.

He's scoring a little more than I expected but rebounding a little less than expected right now. I was thinking he'd be around 14 & 9 on a full season.

Of course, he's probably comparing Gurdak to Ogbole which as usual for him would be the wrong comparison. Just chalk it up to another PMS moment for this old dude that acts like a Karen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bac2therac

seansherm

Heisman
Feb 20, 2009
16,302
16,951
113
He's squawking over a guy that is T-212 in ppg and T-111 in rebounding with a limited sample size.

He's scoring a little more than I expected but rebounding a little less than expected right now. I was thinking he'd be around 14 & 9 on a full season.

Of course, he's probably comparing Gurdak to Ogbole which as usual for him would be the wrong comparison. Just chalk it up to another PMS moment for this old dude that acts like a Karen.
He wasn't a great rebounder last year, he's actually increased his rebounding, not sure I would have expected more, but he's much better/aggressive offensively than I was expecting him to be. I'm pleasantly surprised by that and equally let down by his D, expecially in the pick and roll which is where I thought he would be much better than what we did LY. Instead we've gotten the same.
 

goru7

All-American
Dec 12, 2005
6,506
7,859
113
He wasn't a great rebounder last year, he's actually increased his rebounding, not sure I would have expected more, but he's much better/aggressive offensively than I was expecting him to be. I'm pleasantly surprised by that and equally let down by his D, expecially in the pick and roll which is where I thought he would be much better than what we did LY. Instead we've gotten the same.
His defense failure is that he is overhedgingand getting back late causing the rotation chaos. They are being coached that way but he has to use his IQ and not every point guard deserves that kind of hedging. Our guards have to pressure the ball more and really work to get over the screens which will improve our defense immensely.

Gurdack ‘s defensive rebounding is okay but his offensive rebounding is very good and worthy of 4-6 points a game. That is another huge benefit from him. He is a really a very solid center
 

Ru-baby

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2001
6,876
3,368
66
Dylan and Ace experienced some good losses to Bama and A&M out in Vegas and it didn’t translate. Losses are losses, these 1-2 trips to Vegas (hopefully we win today to even have the 1-2 trip this year, 0-3 would be a disaster) just don’t do much more than add two losses to our record.////////////////////////

Way different.

We had good losses because Dylan Harper played like an NBA player and put the team on his back.

Nothing that could translate to an improved team if he was out or less than full go.

This year was few different players and more of a team effort which bodes far differently. Only caveat is Gurdak is so much a piece of the improvement and is the one player that if you remove things could markedly change.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report WAR ROOM: Latest Recruit Scoop and Team News on Rutgers Athletics
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Maryland Eastern Shore Press Conference
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball HC Brandin Knight's UNLV Postgame Press Conference
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball defeats UNLV, earns 7th place in Players Era 8