I don't want to give up on Campbell but he looks like Franklin 2.0

bdgan

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,769
5,586
113
I remember one of Franklin's early games vs Maryland. PSU was winning late with the ball in our own end but had completely lost momentum. He called conservative runs that were going nowhere. Then we punted and Maryland only needed 1 first down to put their excellent FG kicker in position for the win. When asked after the game about his decision he said "the book says".

I'm not a Bill O'Brien fan but in the 4 OT win over Michigan he decided to go for 2 and the win. After the game he said he did that because his defense was gassed and didn't think they could keep going. That's something "the book" wouldn't know.

The other week vs Washington PSU blew a second half lead. Our D was gassed and Washington's offense was moving at will. A TD would have ended the game but Campbell ran conservative plays instead of going for the win. Maybe that's "what the book said to do" but It only worked because Washington had 12 men on the field which allowed PSU to run out the clock.

Today the same thing. PSU's defense played well for 3 quarters but they were totally gassed after Rutgers marched down the field for 8 minutes to pull within one score. PSU's runs between the tackles were completely shut down after the first quarter. A FG wins the game but Campbell called conservative runs with 5 minutes remaining which put us into an obvious passing situation on 3rd down which failed. Once again trying to run the clock instead of playing to win. Maybe that's "what the book said to do". The problem is the book doesn't know that our run game had been totally shut down and our defense was reeling.

I know it's easy to be an armchair QB but it was all predictable. I guess he's thinking our defenders have been missing tackles and failing to get pressure on the QB but it was due to poor execution and the next play will be different. IMO that's the definition of insanity. Sometimes you have to have a feel for what's going on in the game and stop relying on "the book".
 

Moogy

All-American
Jul 28, 2017
8,149
5,834
113
I remember one of Franklin's early games vs Maryland. PSU was winning late with the ball in our own end but had completely lost momentum. He called conservative runs that were going nowhere. Then we punted and Maryland only needed 1 first down to put their excellent FG kicker in position for the win. When asked after the game about his decision he said "the book says".

I'm not a Bill O'Brien fan but in the 4 OT win over Michigan he decided to go for 2 and the win. After the game he said he did that because his defense was gassed and didn't think they could keep going. That's something "the book" wouldn't know.

The other week vs Washington PSU blew a second half lead. Our D was gassed and Washington's offense was moving at will. A TD would have ended the game but Campbell ran conservative plays instead of going for the win. Maybe that's "what the book said to do" but It only worked because Washington had 12 men on the field which allowed PSU to run out the clock.

Today the same thing. PSU's defense played well for 3 quarters but they were totally gassed after Rutgers marched down the field for 8 minutes to pull within one score. PSU's runs between the tackles were completely shut down after the first quarter. A FG wins the game but Campbell called conservative runs with 5 minutes remaining which put us into an obvious passing situation on 3rd down which failed. Once again trying to run the clock instead of playing to win. Maybe that's "what the book said to do". The problem is the book doesn't know that our run game had been totally shut down and our defense was reeling.

I know it's easy to be an armchair QB but it was all predictable. I guess he's thinking our defenders have been missing tackles and failing to get pressure on the QB but it was due to poor execution and the next play will be different. IMO that's the definition of insanity. Sometimes you have to have a feel for what's going on in the game and stop relying on "the book".

You're speculating WILDLY at what "the book says" ... "the book" is rarely as conservative as your traditional coach, or your traditional college football fan, so you trying to attach all of these bad things to "the book" is wrong-minded.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NitFan89

Big_O

All-Conference
Jun 28, 2001
1,833
2,962
113
He seems to be CJF 2.0 when it comes to coaching prowess. However, he doesn’t seem to be as good in the recruiting game. Now recruits see today’s debacle and they will run away from signing with Penn State.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nits74

RTRMR

Redshirt
Oct 14, 2018
12
10
3
HE’S A HORRIFICALLY HORRIFICALLY HORRIFICALLY TERRIBLE COACH THAT WILL NEVER EVER EVER EVER EVER EVER FINISH BETTER THAN 8–4!
Off to buy an Alabama jersey, I want a root for a team to least cares about winning!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Knickslions69

Moogy

All-American
Jul 28, 2017
8,149
5,834
113
HE’S A HORRIFICALLY HORRIFICALLY HORRIFICALLY TERRIBLE COACH THAT WILL NEVER EVER EVER EVER EVER EVER FINISH BETTER THAN 8–4!
Off to buy an Alabama jersey, I want a root for a team to least cares about winning!

"I want a root for a team to least cares" ... yup, you'll fit right in at Bama, I reckon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Indian rocks rich

m.knox

All-American
Aug 20, 2003
6,443
6,224
113
It’s too early to be off the CMC train. (Meaning for me. Everyone else is entitled to their opinion). Today was not good though. We lost a game we should have won. Played not to lose. That was a major setback.

Bless you. But, no, it isn't. He's made a season of showing he cannot finish a game. It's enough.
 

bdgan

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,769
5,586
113
You're speculating WILDLY at what "the book says" ... "the book" is rarely as conservative as your traditional coach, or your traditional college football fan, so you trying to attach all of these bad things to "the book" is wrong-minded.
Franklin came right out and said it a couple of times.

Campbell didn't say it but he turtled up and relied on his gassed defense vs Washington and again today. Wasn't it obvious to you that our defense was gassed and just trying to run the clock with 5 minutes, 2 Rutgers TOs, and the 2:00 time out was a bad strategy?

If you look back at the game thread I was warning about this before it happened. A screen pass, a slant to Robinson, or a 7 yd pass to Brahmer/Rapp on 1st down. Not runs that have been shut down since the 1st quarter and putting it on our gassed defense.

Seriously, did you think our run game was going to suddenly change or our defense would suddenly get a second wind?
 
  • Like
Reactions: DaytonRickster

Dbsteel

Junior
Jan 15, 2014
219
315
63
That was up there with one of the worst losses Ive seen. Rutgers gets outplayed, but every play Rutgers needed, they got. That QB had the worst flat footed mechanics Ive ever seen. Didnt matter. Embarrassing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PSUoh90.

psu83

Senior
May 29, 2001
330
422
63
Gotta love all these new posters coming out of the woodwork to condemn Campbell; gotta be new names for all the knuckle dragging, Fraudlin Goo Gobblers
 

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,410
1,377
113
I'd take JF 2.0 any day. This isn't even close to as good as a JF team.

Laughable to claim Campbell has accomplished a fraction of what Franklin has. How many 10 win seasons did Campbell have at ISU? How many CFP-Sponsored bowls did he make at ISU? What was Campbell's record while coaching P4 teams? Etc., etc., etc... - Franklin's record at P4 schools blows away Campbell's. PSU is hadn't lost to Buttgers in two decades and has only lost twice to them in the history of PSU Football - this is one of the worst losses in PSU history - Rutgers came into the game 2-8 and 1-6 in b1g play! We were beat by an awful Rutgers team - not a good one. Think about that we just lost to one if the worst P4 teams in the nation!
 

Steve JG

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2024
1,272
2,079
113
I remember one of Franklin's early games vs Maryland. PSU was winning late with the ball in our own end but had completely lost momentum. He called conservative runs that were going nowhere. Then we punted and Maryland only needed 1 first down to put their excellent FG kicker in position for the win. When asked after the game about his decision he said "the book says".

I'm not a Bill O'Brien fan but in the 4 OT win over Michigan he decided to go for 2 and the win. After the game he said he did that because his defense was gassed and didn't think they could keep going. That's something "the book" wouldn't know.

The other week vs Washington PSU blew a second half lead. Our D was gassed and Washington's offense was moving at will. A TD would have ended the game but Campbell ran conservative plays instead of going for the win. Maybe that's "what the book said to do" but It only worked because Washington had 12 men on the field which allowed PSU to run out the clock.

Today the same thing. PSU's defense played well for 3 quarters but they were totally gassed after Rutgers marched down the field for 8 minutes to pull within one score. PSU's runs between the tackles were completely shut down after the first quarter. A FG wins the game but Campbell called conservative runs with 5 minutes remaining which put us into an obvious passing situation on 3rd down which failed. Once again trying to run the clock instead of playing to win. Maybe that's "what the book said to do". The problem is the book doesn't know that our run game had been totally shut down and our defense was reeling.

I know it's easy to be an armchair QB but it was all predictable. I guess he's thinking our defenders have been missing tackles and failing to get pressure on the QB but it was due to poor execution and the next play will be different. IMO that's the definition of insanity. Sometimes you have to have a feel for what's going on in the game and stop relying on "the book".
not nearly as good as Franklin, mid tier Big 12 coach
 

Nits1989

All-Conference
Oct 29, 2021
1,492
2,129
113
The game coverage mentioned the last time PSU lost to Rutgers and bingo PSU loses. He’s been very consistent with sh!tt!ng the bed in the second half. Just when I thought it was safe to watch PSU football, this happened. Rutgers wanted it more and fought hard to the end.
 

Moogy

All-American
Jul 28, 2017
8,149
5,834
113
Franklin came right out and said it a couple of times.

Campbell didn't say it but he turtled up and relied on his gassed defense vs Washington and again today. Wasn't it obvious to you that our defense was gassed and just trying to run the clock with 5 minutes, 2 Rutgers TOs, and the 2:00 time out was a bad strategy?

If you look back at the game thread I was warning about this before it happened. A screen pass, a slant to Robinson, or a 7 yd pass to Brahmer/Rapp on 1st down. Not runs that have been shut down since the 1st quarter and putting it on our gassed defense.

Seriously, did you think our run game was going to suddenly change or our defense would suddenly get a second wind?

Franklin usually referenced "the book" in regard to "new age" stuff he would do that your typical Paterno-age fan couldn't/didn't want to comprehend. Going for 2, etc.

Turtling up is an old school thing. It's something that's frustrated me for years about a great many coaches ... many, many more coaches than Franklin and Campbell have suffered from it.

That's an entirely different thing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NitFan89

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
897
952
93
Franklin came right out and said it a couple of times.

Campbell didn't say it but he turtled up and relied on his gassed defense vs Washington and again today. Wasn't it obvious to you that our defense was gassed and just trying to run the clock with 5 minutes, 2 Rutgers TOs, and the 2:00 time out was a bad strategy?

If you look back at the game thread I was warning about this before it happened. A screen pass, a slant to Robinson, or a 7 yd pass to Brahmer/Rapp on 1st down. Not runs that have been shut down since the 1st quarter and putting it on our gassed defense.

Seriously, did you think our run game was going to suddenly change or our defense would suddenly get a second wind?
But we have the most experience QB in semi pro football with his long term coach. They’d have plenty of plays to win the game!
 

NittPicker

Heisman
Jun 30, 2001
6,909
14,689
113
Team discipline blows too. The sloppy looking guys with their undershirts flapping in the wind look ridiculous. I'm sitting here watching Maryland @ USC and I see ZERO guys with their guts and shirts hanging out. Have some damned pride in yourselves ffs.

When Gen. Patton was given command of the II Corps in 1943, he immediately instituted standards of dress. Clean uniforms, grooming, etc. It went way beyond just being a jerk and making them dress well. It created an attention to detail which carried over into their battlefield performance.
 

Dbsteel

Junior
Jan 15, 2014
219
315
63
Team discipline blows too. The sloppy looking guys with their undershirts flapping in the wind look ridiculous. I'm sitting here watching Maryland @ USC and I see ZERO guys with their guts and shirts hanging out. Have some damned pride in yourselves ffs.

When Gen. Patton was given command of the II Corps in 1943, he immediately instituted standards of dress. Clean uniforms, grooming, etc. It went way beyond just being a jerk and making them dress well. It created an attention to detail which carried over into their battlefield performance.
Thats not why they lost.
 

CyphaPSU

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2021
1,421
2,454
113
Campbell does not look like Franklin 2.0. Franklin had some clunkers, but his teams typically took care of the teams they were supposed to beat. Campbell has had an issue with his teams dropping some bad games against inferior opposition going back to his ISU days. Also, so far, Franklin did a bit more with recruiting.
 

psu31trap

All-Conference
Oct 29, 2021
1,359
1,280
113
After Pat Kraft fired James Franklin he dragged his feet and waited too long with his search. Kraft was not able to leverage Penn State, its resources and rich football history in landing a top 10 coach. A part of me feels that Matt Campbell deserves three years to prove himself, the other part says if things don’t improve significantly next year there can’t be a year 3.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bdgan

Moogy

All-American
Jul 28, 2017
8,149
5,834
113
Franklin was frustrating at times, but he had done enough good things to build up some goodwill that allowed him to "get away" with some of the suboptimal moves/decisions. By "get away with" I mean I could grin and bear it, while cursing under my breath. He seemed stuck between new age data-driven thinking and old school "feel" nonsense.

Campbell hasn't built up any of the goodwill. I don't feel at all comfortable with what is happening. I don't know what to expect week in and week out, though it tends toward failure more than success, at this point. I also don't have a great feeling about the future (recruiting, etc.), so that doesn't help offset the animus toward the current situation.

Again, while there was some wheel-spinning, with the occassional laid egg with Franklin, there was an expectation the ship would right itself, and we'd have some good times thrown in. Now, that hope ... that base ... it just isn't there. I see bad moves, I see head-scratching moves, and occasionally something good happens ... and I can't look to the future to appease my uneasiness.

Campbell has a ways to go to be considered "Franklin 2.0." Right now it seems like we've taken a big step back as a program, overall.

Again, this whole situation was gravely mismanaged. I'm guessing this is the result of idiot boosters, whose opinions were like a lot of the anti-Franklin whiners on this board, putting pressure on Kraft to make stupid decisions at the wrong time, and he caved. And here we are.
 

bdgan

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,769
5,586
113
But we have the most experience QB in semi pro football with his long term coach. They’d have plenty of plays to win the game!
PSU lot a lot of players but Campbell brought in nine 4* players

QB Becht
RB Hansen
TE Brahmer
TE Burkle
WR Sowell
LB Bacon
CB Cooper
S Patton
S Neal

Sowell is the only player who has lived up to his rankings. Becht is a decent QB but nowhere near what we expected considering his experience. Brahmer was supposed to be a big target who could take advantage of his size but he doesn't block well and he struggles to catch the ball in traffic. Hansen has been decent but not spectacular.

Of the 9 I'd say one has exceeded expectations, two have been decent but less than expected, and the rest have been a dissappointment.
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Recruiting Rivals300 CB Damontae Butler commits to Penn State following visit
  2. 02 BWI Football How did Penn State's players perform vs. Rutgers? PFF Snap Counts & Grades
  3. 03 Rivals Football Recruiting Prediction: Penn State close to adding four-star defender
  4. 04 BWI Football Penn State's Loss to Rutgers Proves Running Backs Matter
  5. 05 BWI Football Penn State Sunday situation: Following historic failure, will Matt Campbell put the future in focus at Maryland?