Toggle sidebar

Addverpoke why is it so hard to make a memorable Super Bowl commercial?

H

HighStickHarry_

Hall of Famer
Apr 21, 2006
63,219
120,160
0
I take a camera crew to my local senior center and I construct a soul train dance line. Put them all in flamboyant big collared outfits with platform shoes, turn on some al green and let them go. Show 30 seconds of slow motion dancing and they are all holding dads root beers. Best commercial of the night and I thought of that on the *******.

What's so hard about this?
 
A

anon_ph7vrsh7abnty

Guest
Entertainment is fun but is wrapped in a brand loyalty metric that is very hard to move.

What you saw is brands being focused on a sales message sprinkled with others tying in topical issues.

It may not have been "fun" for you, but that isn't what these MBAs are learning in business school.

If you want to know what it's like working on national/international brands, I've laid it it for you in both responses.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CowboyJD
F

FMPoke

Heisman
Jan 12, 2002
64,967
17,486
113
Everyone tries too hard now. Expectations are too high. How many memorable Superbowl commercials have there ever really been? Thought this years were okay. Really liked the Superbowl babies all dressed up, easy rider one was okay, skittles was cute. Nothing people are going to be talking about in ten years but not terrible.
 
MegaPoke

MegaPoke

Heisman
May 29, 2001
75,208
84,035
103
Adverpoke said:
Entertainment is fun but is wrapped in a brand loyalty metric that is very hard to move.

What you saw is brands being focused on a sales message sprinkled with others tying in topical issues.

It may not have been "fun" for you, but that isn't what these MBAs are learning in business school.

If you want to know what it's like working on national/international brands, I've laid it it for you in both responses.
Click to expand...

Whenever.

They were in ge
CowboyJD said:
Saw plenty of calls for heads and boycotts from the other side last night as well.

"Middle path" and all that.
Click to expand...


I saw Audi catch a lot of twitter **** for their sanctimonious dog whistle ad about wage gap, gender equality etc. Their board is all male, all white.
 
C

CowboyJD

Heisman
Dec 12, 2002
30,977
20,811
0
I saw boycott Coke tweets, boycott Budweiser tweets, and boycott Lumber84 tweets and calls for their metaphorical heads as a result of their ads....some quite hysterically "how dare they" in nature.

I'm all for boycotting companies if you disagree with their message or conduct. Let's just not act like snowflake hysterics are the exclusive purview of any section of American politics.

Also saw that alt-right Spencer guy trying to turn the NE win into a victory for the white culture....which was very weird.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheRedSon and MegaPoke
A

anon_ph7vrsh7abnty

Guest
HighStickHarry said:
They don't suck. You just don't know what sucking is because you aren't a classically trained marketing expert. They were actually great. Sorry about your ignorance.
Click to expand...
Your title asked for an objective opinion (specifically, mine) as to why it is hard. I spelled it out in two different ways. I never made any statement on quality of any given ad. I gave the perspective of the clients I work with every day.

I'm sorry my response didn't align with your alt facts version of what reality looks like.

You are quite sensitive to feedback. That's a trait you'd need to abandon if you ever wanted to make ads.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Air_Thurman and CowboyJD
MegaPoke

MegaPoke

Heisman
May 29, 2001
75,208
84,035
103
CowboyJD said:
I saw boycott Coke tweets, boycott Budweiser tweets, and boycott Lumber84 tweets and calls for their metaphorical heads as a result of their ads....some quite hysterically "how dare they" in nature.

I'm all for boycotting companies if you disagree with their message or conduct. Let's just not act like snowflake hysterics are the exclusive purview of any section of American politics.

Also saw that alt-right Spencer guy trying to turn the NE win into a victory for the white culture....which was very weird.
Click to expand...

It is weird, but no weirder than the tons of posts lamenting the Patriots win as more unfair success for white supremacists.

Maybe the internet is full of idiots.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alpha Poke and TheRedSon
C

Cowpoke

Heisman
May 29, 2001
89,079
10,347
113
MegaPoke said:
It is weird, but no weirder than the tons of posts lamenting the Patriots win as more unfair success for white supremacists.

Maybe the internet is full of idiots.
Click to expand...


 
  • Like
Reactions: CowboyJD and MegaPoke
C

Cordellhall83

Senior
May 29, 2001
1,879
561
0
Tons of funny stuff out on YouTube...steal some ideas! Our family liked the Buick and KIA commercials. That was it.
 
J

JonnyVito

Heisman
Mar 12, 2008
24,405
10,422
0
Last week the term douche canoe was used on a show I watch and I am now 100% convinced that a writer for major TV is on this site stealing our ****.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HighStickHarry_
H

HighStickHarry_

Hall of Famer
Apr 21, 2006
63,219
120,160
0
If the advertising community has the same sense of humor as our resident expert we might have found the issue.
 
A

anon_ph7vrsh7abnty

Guest
HighStickHarry said:
If the advertising community has the same sense of humor as our resident expert we might have found the issue.
Click to expand...
Don't feel frightened, snowflake. You and your über touchy friends stick together on these boards. It's a safe space.
 
H

HighStickHarry_

Hall of Famer
Apr 21, 2006
63,219
120,160
0
I guess I just don't understand this world. I reread this thread and I just can't get to the place where I was the sensitive one. I'm sorry spandex ghandi.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom