Are Utley and Rollins the best 2B-SS duo to play 10+ years together in NL history?

saturdaysarebetter

All-Conference
Jun 19, 2018
948
1,383
111
Are Utley and Rollins the best second baseman and shortstop duo to play 10+ years together in NL history? I'd pick them over Lopes and Russell. Not many duos played 10+ years together. Trammell and Whitaker the best in AL history to play 10+ years together?

Utley-Rollins-Handshake-1.jpeg

Trammell Whitaker.jpg
 

LionJim

Heisman
Oct 12, 2021
13,739
19,197
113
I’d go with Trammel and Whitaker. Or Wagner and whoever played second base for the Pirates.
 

MrTailgate

All-Conference
Oct 19, 2021
973
1,810
93
It’s hard to find a better statistical pairing than J Roll and Utley. They were both offensive forces, easily both MVP caliber players. Rollins was an elite defensive player to boot.

10 years is an eternity though to have an infield combo together. You had Aparicio and Fox but not for 10 years. But both made the Hall. You had a great combo of Alley and Maz in Pittsburgh and Morgan and Davey in Cincinnati. And of course Trammel and Whitaker and Lopes and Russell as mentioned.
 
  • Like
Reactions: saturdaysarebetter

LionJim

Heisman
Oct 12, 2021
13,739
19,197
113
It’s hard to find a better statistical pairing than J Roll and Utley. They were both offensive forces, easily both MVP caliber players. Rollins was an elite defensive player to boot.

10 years is an eternity though to have an infield combo together. You had Aparicio and Fox but not for 10 years. But both made the Hall. You had a great combo of Alley and Maz in Pittsburgh and Morgan and Davey in Cincinnati. And of course Trammel and Whitaker and Lopes and Russell as mentioned.
Bill James has said that Maz is the undisputed best defensive 2nd-baseman ever, by a wide margin. A huge outlier, nobody else is that much better than #2 at any one position.
 

razpsu

Heisman
Jan 13, 2004
13,560
13,390
113
Jeter and cano
Dent and Randolph
Rizzuto and gordon
Koenig and lazzeri

yep all yankees
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim

saturdaysarebetter

All-Conference
Jun 19, 2018
948
1,383
111
Jeter and cano
Dent and Randolph
Rizzuto and gordon
Koenig and lazzeri

yep all yankees
Cano was a Yankee for nine years. Great thought though. Dent only six. Gordon only seven. Koenig only six. Perhaps something to be said for middle infield double-play combos playing together for a while as being integral to a team's success.
 

saturdaysarebetter

All-Conference
Jun 19, 2018
948
1,383
111
Bill James has said that Maz is the undisputed best defensive 2nd-baseman ever, by a wide margin. A huge outlier, nobody else is that much better than #2 at any one position.
Pete Rose once said that the greatest double play combination ever was "Bill Mazeroski and whoever played shortstop for the Pirates."
 

NoSoup4U

Senior
Jan 17, 2002
644
897
93
I would be partial to the 6 year combo of Cronin and Doerr but yeah 10 years together with high output by both year and year out is pretty special from Uts and JRoll
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim

LionJim

Heisman
Oct 12, 2021
13,739
19,197
113
I would be partial to the 6 year combo of Cronin and Doerr but yeah 10 years together with high output by both year and year out is pretty special from Uts and JRoll
I’m trying to find another ten year combination other than the Tigers duo. Johnny Pesky was Bobby Doerr’s regular shortstop, not sure if they played 10 years together but they came close.
 

NoSoup4U

Senior
Jan 17, 2002
644
897
93
I’m trying to find another ten year combination other than the Tigers duo. Johnny Pesky was Bobby Doerr’s regular shortstop, not sure if they played 10 years together but they came close.
cronin played 10 years with the sox albeit 4 of them as player manager at the tail end of his career from 35 to 45 ----- pesky came in at 42-51 replacing cronin but lost the 3 years to the war ----- doerr was 37 to 51 so both pesky and Cronin had about 6-7 yrs with Doerr both good combos for their stints
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim

MrTailgate

All-Conference
Oct 19, 2021
973
1,810
93
Bill James has said that Maz is the undisputed best defensive 2nd-baseman ever, by a wide margin. A huge outlier, nobody else is that much better than #2 at any one position.
My mind remembers the precision and rhythm that Alley and Maz had turning two but Robbie Alomar made plays that you shook your head over. For a brief time, the combo of Alomar and Omar Vizquel was spectacular. I would always go to Clearwater when the gates opened just to watch Omar‘s fielding practice. What a treat that was.
 
  • Love
Reactions: LionJim

Mufasa94

Senior
Jan 9, 2009
1,112
953
113
I’m trying to find another ten year combination other than the Tigers duo. Johnny Pesky was Bobby Doerr’s regular shortstop, not sure if they played 10 years together but they came close.
Without bothering to check, did Gehringer have one infield partner in the decades earlier Tigers years? His numbers give Hornsby a run for the money as best for any 2B/SS player.
 
  • Like
Reactions: saturdaysarebetter

NoSoup4U

Senior
Jan 17, 2002
644
897
93
Without bothering to check, did Gehringer have one infield partner in the decades earlier Tigers years? His numbers give Hornsby a run for the money as best for any 2B/SS player.
Not really Billy Rogell (similar to Rick Burleson )from 30-39 when the mechanical man was in his prime