Best, greatest retrospective not hits album

yeahtoasty

Member
Oct 12, 2021
92
204
33
Not what I expected since there are only a couple of songs that were actually "hits" on there -- but as a career retrospective of one of rock's truly unique artists is spectacular. It was the box set of his first decade of music before box sets were even a thing.

Since we're talking Neil, I'll nominate his "Homegrown" as best never-released or long-delayed-released album (recorded in '74 and '75 and finally released in 2020. I realize that it has to compete with the Beach Boys "Smile" in this category.) I bought it on vinyl and it's been in my regular rotation ever since. Some of those songs made it onto other records, including "Love is a Rose" and "Star of Bethlehem" which appeared on "Decade" and "Little Wing" showed up on "Hawks and Doves."
homegrown.jpg
 

Midnighter

Well-known member
Jan 22, 2021
10,461
16,627
113


 

razpsu

Well-known member
Jan 13, 2004
11,934
11,123
113
Yea I would agree with Queen. Then there is elo, billy Joel abba and paul
McCartney. Every song is better than the one before it.
 

massimoManca II

Active member
Apr 12, 2018
149
303
63
back in the day when i spun / aggregated vinyl, had little use for “greatest hits” collections as there was fun / satisfaction in discovering an artist’s deep tracks ...

however, had one Greatest Hits compilation that stood above everything else, unique in that it:

a) was excellent front ta back
b) documented the truly finest era of the act ( their 80’s comeback “hits” and everything after that was largely garbage
c) was a greatest hits album i would actually reach for / listen to

7837A410-BFED-4141-AF4D-BD1D5B08D5DB.jpeg
 

bbrown

Well-known member
Jul 26, 2001
10,935
22,681
113
I don't generally care for greatest hits packages, but I have a German pressing of this that just SLAYS.

I’m surprised that The Beatles 62-66 or 67-70. Hasn’t been mentioned yet.
Also The Worst of Jefferson Airplane is pretty good.
 

ODShowtime

Well-known member
Aug 17, 2017
3,030
6,041
113
I’m surprised that The Beatles 62-66 or 67-70. Hasn’t been mentioned yet.
Also The Worst of Jefferson Airplane is pretty good.

I agree that, like Hot Rocks, The red and blue Beatles albums are both iconic comps. I've never heard the Worst, but I'm sure the Airplane could fill 40 minutes.