Toggle sidebar

BUILD YOUR RECRUITING CLASS

Reply
V

Volatility_rivals135605

New member
Jun 27, 2018
873
0
0
You get 24 recruits:

1 QB
4 WR/TE/Slot
1 RB
5 OL

5 DL (WDE/SDE/DT)
3 LB (2OLB 1 ILB)
2 CB
3 SA (SS,FS,SPS)

_______________________________________________________________________________

You Get

2 5 Star Recruits 99+

3 high 4 star recruits 95-98.99

4 low-mid 4 star recruits 90-94.99



4 high 3 star recruits 87-89.99

7 mid 3 star recruits 85-86.99

4 low 3 star recruits 83-84.99



Which positions would you allocate the 3,4,5 stars?

QB
WR1
WR2
WR3
TE
RB
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL


DT
DT
SDE
WDE
(DT/SDE/WDE)
ILB
OLB
OLB
CB
CB
SS
FS
SPS
 
V

Volatility_rivals135605

New member
Jun 27, 2018
873
0
0
For 3 stars = use 3+ 3 3-
for 4 stars = use 4+ 4

QB - 5
WR1 - 4+
WR2 - 4
WR3 - 3+
TE - 3-
RB - 3+
LOT - 4+
ROT - 4
LOG - 3+
ROG - 3
C - 3


DT - 4
DT - 3-
SDE - 3
WDE - 4+
(DT/SDE/WDE) - 3
ILB - 3
OLB - 3-
OLB - 4
CB - 5
CB - 3
SS - 3
FS - 3+
SPS - 3-
 
V

Volatility_rivals135605

New member
Jun 27, 2018
873
0
0
In essence, if every year, you hypothetically had these allocations of "stars", what positions would you "weight" as being more valuable/impactful in determining outcomes?

Obviously stars do not = potential/impact/skillset/etc, but in the modern game, there are some positions that have or can have a greater impact on determining outcome..

Which positions do you weight as most valuable, or which positions has a higher probability of determining Wins/Losses?

1. QB
2. CB
3. OL
4. Edge
5. WR

etc

The complexities of "building" a roster as a perfectionist at work, I would absolutely have paralysis by analysis.. If in a positions like Saban at Bama, where he can pretty much build whatever roster he wants, finding symbiosis among skillsets, talent, attitude, leadership, intelligence.... There are so many factors in building a consistent roster that go far beyond stars, or a recruits film..

EX: skillset diversity, or certain players may do one thing extremely well, which compliments another recruits skillset that may offer a scheme to deploy..

Often, we as fans get caught up on recruiting rankings, stars, etc... WVU finally gaining some momentum here is great, but for an analytical coach like Brown, I would wager a months salary there are 100+ variables he's analyzing that we never see/hear/think of...
 
T

The Bell Tolls for Thee

New member
Feb 15, 2005
7,083
60
0
In order of importance.
QB
Edge rusher
D-Line
O-line (Center and blindside tackle particularly)
CB (particularly ones that can play man)
Remainder are all pretty close, but I personally think LB, RB, S, WR, and TE is the order of importance I prefer.

Despite all the bells and whistles of the game, defense and controlling the line of scrimmage still gives you the best chance to win. On offense a solid QB can make up for a lot of deficiencies where as stud RB's, TE's and WR's can't do as much for a deficient QB and O-line.
 
Top Bottom
Reply