Cael Sanderson releases a cookie: Cael's Cookie

[GregPickel]

Yes, this is serious.

"This cookie had to hit a few non-negotiables: It had to be good for you, light on your stomach, and actually taste good," Sanderson says on the company's website.

The first flavor out is chocolate chip. Preorders are being taken now with a January 2026 expected shipment date.

More details:

Cael's Cookie — Deconstructed

caelscookie.com

 

[GregPickel]

 

[Dogwelder]

Didn’t Cael have a cookie that he was selling more than 10 years ago? I keep thinking it might’ve been called Undefeated.

 

[GregPickel]

Didn’t Cael have a cookie that he was selling more than 10 years ago? I keep thinking it might’ve been called Undefeated.

You are correct:

 

[GregPickel]

Didn’t Cael have a cookie that he was selling more than 10 years ago? I keep thinking it might’ve been called Undefeated.

You are correct:

 

[Dogwelder]

I hope there are safeguards in place to prevent Okie State from ordering these cookies. We can’t let them gain access to our competitive advantage.

 

[El_Jefe]

First one isn't Mountain Dew flavored?

 

[Misalorales]

Yes, this is serious.

"This cookie had to hit a few non-negotiables: It had to be good for you, light on your stomach, and actually taste good," Sanderson says on the company's website.

The first flavor out is chocolate chip. Preorders are being taken now with a January 2026 expected shipment date.

More details:

Cael's Cookie — Deconstructed

caelscookie.com

Do you think Kalani Sitake will order a few? Big cookie guy.

 

[GregPickel]

Do you think Kalani Sitake will order a few? Big cookie guy.

Ha, going to go with no, but, maybe!

 

[Just another PSU Fan]

hard no from me ... give me the sugar and carbs with a tall glass of milk!

 

[Foreverinbluejeans57]

Jeez so much for the 3 part documentary series I was hoping for. Yes I’ll still order the cookies

 

[Cstroke]

 

[nerfstate]

The Keebler Elves are worried Cael is about to corner the cookie market, so they’ve turned to Tom and Terry for help. Unfortunately, the only advice the Brands could give was how to scream at a chocolate chip and still place 4th.

 

[manatree]

And the slush fund just got sweeter.

 

[El_Jefe]

The Keebler Elves are worried Cael is about to corner the cookie market, so they’ve turned to Tom and Terry for help. Unfortunately, the only advice the Brands could give was how to scream at a chocolate chip and still place 4th.

In other words, the Keebler Elves turned to each other?

 

[pawrstlersinpa]

Yes, this is serious.

"This cookie had to hit a few non-negotiables: It had to be good for you, light on your stomach, and actually taste good," Sanderson says on the company's website.

The first flavor out is chocolate chip. Preorders are being taken now with a January 2026 expected shipment date.

More details:

Cael's Cookie — Deconstructed

caelscookie.com

 

[TrooperPSU]

is it a NIL flavored cookie?

 

[Fatwoodchuck]

coaches get NIL too, lol. I wonder if he lost a bet or made a deal with the team.?

 

[Matter7172]

When I first saw the topic title, I thought maybe Cael was getting a little looser with the "state secrets". I was really disappointed the thread was about an actual cookie.

 

[GregPickel]

Jeez so much for the 3 part documentary series I was hoping for. Yes I’ll still order the cookies

Ha, I guess if I thought more about the history he has, I might have gotten to the cookie idea, but might have needed 1,000 guesses. Definitely was thinking the teasers would lead to something else.

 

[GregPickel]

When I first saw the topic title, I thought maybe Cael was getting a little looser with the "state secrets". I was really disappointed the thread was about an actual cookie.

Ha, there is a reason I the first sentence is 'Yes, this is serious.' I almost put 'News' in the thread title and then thought that would make people react a certain kind of way when they saw what the 'news' actually was.

 

[nerfstate]

In other words, the Keebler Elves turned to each other?

They're cousins, I'm sure.

 

[randyl]

Sheesh ... doesnt anyone eat Wheaties any more?

 

[fortheglory94]

Do you think Kalani Sitake will order a few? Big cookie guy.

I heard he put an order in, but then canceled it before it shipped.

 

[JoeBagobagels]

I ordered two boxes. Of course I'll also eat half a pizza .

 

[manatree]

Perhaps Cael has found a new way to settle lineup disputes. Whichever ever wrestler sells the most cookies at a table outside of WalMart wins the spot. Weigh-ins will prevent the classic trick of buying and eating them yourself.

 

[Nitlion1986]

I ordered two boxes. Of course I'll also eat half a pizza .

Half a pizza. Not hungry?

 

[manatree]

Half a pizza. Not hungry?

The two boxes of cookies should take the edge off.

 

[psumac]

hard no from me ... give me the sugar and carbs with a tall glass of milk!

52g of carbs is the same as like 6 oreos. i was hoping these would be able to replace Quest cookies for my diabetes but no such luck.

 

[Tom McAndrew]

 

[Lil Nicky Scarfo]

So the Flo Guys gave Cael’s cookies a thumbs up on FRL. They had a live taste test

 

[Dogwelder]

So the Flo Guys gave Cael’s cookies a thumbs up on FRL. They had a live taste test

Cool! My birthday is coming up soon. I think I will buy myself some cookies!

 

[Lil Nicky Scarfo]

Cool! My birthday is coming up soon. I think I will buy myself some cookies!

Definitely sounds like these are cookies to have before cranking out an 8000 yard swim session, 50 mile bike ride or you’re a thru-hiker.

 

[Cstroke]

What's the record on how many cookies have been consumed at one sitting??
I'd love to hear Cael's reaction to someone eating 15 cookies in 15 minutes.

 

[amattaro]

It’s not an ookie cookie, buddy.

 

[Cstroke]

It’s not an ookie cookie, buddy.

Go ahead and that in the best G rated fashion that you can..

 

[Tom McAndrew]

 

[WaffleShopper]

Just tried one before my workout later this afternoon. It’s pretty good! It’s better than most mass produced cookies like Keebler or Chips Ahoy although I’m not really a fan of those anyway. If you’re comparing it to your favorite homemade cookie it might be a 6/10 and not worth the price but for workout fuel it’s probably 9/10.

 

[shotofespresso]

Tried to get some but they are sold out already.. On the waiting list

 

[lionlover]

Just tried one before my workout later this afternoon. It’s pretty good! It’s better than most mass produced cookies like Keebler or Chips Ahoy although I’m not really a fan of those anyway. If you’re comparing it to your favorite homemade cookie it might be a 6/10 and not worth the price but for workout fuel it’s probably 9/10.

Yeah, this cookie was meant for athlete's and or young people (with higher burning metabolisms) who are burning tons of carbs.

Each cookie has 46 net carbs (52carbs-6 fiber) which is approximately 11.5 teaspoons of sugar! If you aren't really active and/or on some type of fasting or caloric restriction regimen, your *** will blow up like a beach ball if you consistently over indulge in this treat.