Dishwasher Question

Boogie Fan

Member
Jun 6, 2010
651
57
28
I'm getting ready to buy a dishwasher for the first time in my life in the next few days. Not looking for anything fancy and definitely not looking to break the bank. Anyone bought a dishwasher recently that they liked or disliked? Also where did you buy it? Are places like Lowe's or Home Depot my best choices? Also it looks like a lot of these places will deliver it for free but charge you to install and haul away your old dishwasher. Anyone know what this costs, and could a guy with my average home improvement skills remove the old one install a new dishwasher?

Thanks
 

AustinTXCat

Well-known member
Jan 7, 2003
51,721
30,452
113
I'm getting ready to buy a dishwasher for the first time in my life in the next few days. Not looking for anything fancy and definitely not looking to break the bank. Anyone bought a dishwasher recently that they liked or disliked? Also where did you buy it? Are places like Lowe's or Home Depot my best choices? Also it looks like a lot of these places will deliver it for free but charge you to install and haul away your old dishwasher. Anyone know what this costs, and could a guy with my average home improvement skills remove the old one install a new dishwasher?

Thanks
In Summer of 2014, we purchased a new dishwasher, clothes washer and clothes dryer from Best Buy. At the time, our old Maytag dishwasher was 15 years old and essentially worn out. Our old clothes washer/dryer pair (unknown brand) were perhaps over 20 years old at the time.

We went with Best Buy because they offered free delivery and no-interest financing for 18 months. There was a $75 charge for installation, if memory serves me correctly. Total cost for all three units came to $1,752 with sales tax and installation. Our new dishwasher is a Whirlpool brand. We paid off the loan in 15 months.

My recommendation: First shop around online for some ideas about various models and features. Keep in mind your old dishwasher unit also requires disposal, covered in our case by Best Buy under installation.

Good luck.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: UKGrad93

UKGrad93

New member
Jun 20, 2007
17,437
12,538
0
I've done that my local appliance store will make deals that are just as good as Best Buy, but they actually know about the products.

I have a Bosch. It's a little smaller inside than most, but it does a great job and is very quiet. Read some reviews.
 

Barleycorn

Active member
Jan 12, 2004
1,851
161
63
I'll second the Bosch. Very quiet. We got one half price from Lowe's a few years ago. They had moved the last unit they had to the back to make room for new models. My brother in law worked there at the time and had clued us in on the clearance models in the back they have once or twice a year to make room for the new.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cawoodsct

55wildcat

Well-known member
Jan 4, 2006
33,736
15,124
113
This is similar to mine..Mine is a 57 model, built in the U S of A, still very proficient. Seems the older it gets the more noise it makes but still does a wonderful job..financing was free although the payments never end. My model has all the bells n whistles too. Twice a week "oiling" keeps her running like new..

 

kyhusker2

New member
Aug 2, 2011
1,325
86
0
I bought a whirlpool from HH Gregg last year. Very nice, plenty of room inside, and extremely quiet. Get the stainless steel tub instead of plastic. It helps with the noise, is more energy efficient, and allows the dishwasher to operate at higher temps so the dishes get cleaner.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big_Blue79

ndk_rivals308474

New member
Feb 8, 2004
115
67
0
I'm getting ready to buy a dishwasher for the first time in my life in the next few days. Not looking for anything fancy and definitely not looking to break the bank. Anyone bought a dishwasher recently that they liked or disliked? Also where did you buy it? Are places like Lowe's or Home Depot my best choices? Also it looks like a lot of these places will deliver it for free but charge you to install and haul away your old dishwasher. Anyone know what this costs, and could a guy with my average home improvement skills remove the old one install a new dishwasher?

Thanks
They aren't all that hard to install. Make sure power and water to the unit are turned off. Should be a few screws holding in the current unit. Once you get the old one out and disconnected, just follow the installation guide for the new unit. You may need another guy to help you carry the old one out, or use a dolly. I'd leave the face plate off and run a cycle, then check underneath to make sure there aren't any leaks. It's not terribly complicated, but a little time consuming and a hassle to haul out the old one. $75 is probably a pretty fair price.

Go with the Bosch.
 

Crushgroove

New member
Oct 11, 2014
7,331
1,961
0
- Recently replaced a Maytag DW that was about 15 y/o due to the simple fact that it was "the wrong color" and in doing so, made a huge mistake that led to a series of headaches trying to adequately replace it.
- Keep in mind, things are not built to last like they used to be, rather, built to be replaced. After much discussion with other homeowners and hearing their appliance horror stories, it became clear that spending more than the basic minimum for any appliance is borderline foolish these days. Styles/amenities change too quickly, poor overall quality, poor materials/parts used, poor workmanship, expensive repair costs and decreased warranties all contribute to this ideology. Odds are very good you'll run into a situation where repair cost vs replacement cost will be an issue within 5-10 years of use.
- The above holds true until you reach the very high-end, very expensive brands that go the extra mile to address all issues mentioned. The Bosch cited above is a very good example. However, at this point, initial cost to value/longevity/usage becomes the new line of decision. Will you keep it for 20+years if it lasts that long? Will your wife be looking for the next best thing when SS is no longer the rave in 5-10 years? Will you be okay with paying that premium?
- From my direct experience, avoid Frigidaire and Samsung appliances like the GD plague. It would be a good street fight between the two to tell which manufacturer sucks the hardest. MIL remodeled kitchen a few years back, used all new Samsung appliances. Everything but the microwave has already been replaced under warranty or repaired out of warranty. As for Frigidaire, just do a little searching to verify. It's all out there.
- Again, from direct experience, we've had excellent luck with LG products- and that spans the gamut of their product line; TVs, washer/dryer/fridge/dishwasher... not the most expensive, but not complete crap, either.

Hope this helps.
 

Supreme Lord Z

New member
Jan 7, 2016
3,447
2,368
0
- Recently replaced a Maytag DW that was about 15 y/o due to the simple fact that it was "the wrong color" and in doing so, made a huge mistake that led to a series of headaches trying to adequately replace it.
- Keep in mind, things are not built to last like they used to be, rather, built to be replaced. After much discussion with other homeowners and hearing their appliance horror stories, it became clear that spending more than the basic minimum for any appliance is borderline foolish these days. Styles/amenities change too quickly, poor overall quality, poor materials/parts used, poor workmanship, expensive repair costs and decreased warranties all contribute to this ideology. Odds are very good you'll run into a situation where repair cost vs replacement cost will be an issue within 5-10 years of use.
- The above holds true until you reach the very high-end, very expensive brands that go the extra mile to address all issues mentioned. The Bosch cited above is a very good example. However, at this point, initial cost to value/longevity/usage becomes the new line of decision. Will you keep it for 20+years if it lasts that long? Will your wife be looking for the next best thing when SS is no longer the rave in 5-10 years? Will you be okay with paying that premium?
- From my direct experience, avoid Frigidaire and Samsung appliances like the GD plague. It would be a good street fight between the two to tell which manufacturer sucks the hardest. MIL remodeled kitchen a few years back, used all new Samsung appliances. Everything but the microwave has already been replaced under warranty or repaired out of warranty. As for Frigidaire, just do a little searching to verify. It's all out there.
- Again, from direct experience, we've had excellent luck with LG products- and that spans the gamut of their product line; TVs, washer/dryer/fridge/dishwasher... not the most expensive, but not complete crap, either.

Hope this helps.
I've done very well with LG.
 

vhcat70

New member
Feb 5, 2003
57,418
1,222
0
DW's are labeled by decibels, dB, for quietness. Under 50 is good. Some expensive ones as low as 38, but mid-40's good. We're in the process of buy this Bosch model, 46 dB: SHP53T55UC for a little over $700.
 

dgtatu01

New member
Sep 21, 2005
8,673
506
0
We bought an LG stove recently and I think it is top notch. We are getting ready to replace our dishwasher too. The one we have is a Frigidaire. It sucks. We had a GE at our old house that was better than the Frigidaire but not great. Glasses never come out of this Frigidaire without film on them and it burns through that stuff for clear glassware much quicker than our GE did.
 

Big_Blue79

New member
Apr 2, 2004
52,487
846
0
Just got a Maytag dishwasher about 2 weeks ago. I think I got it from Lowes, but might have been Home Depot. Anyways, they usually deliver for free and take the old one for free or a minimal (~$15) cost. Install is easy so long as you don't have PEX (hard plastic, about 3/4" diameter) hosing, which can be a problem if the hose is not long enough for the new dishwasher (it's also cheap and can develop leaks at the crimp points). Some helpful tips if installing yourself:
  • Never hurts to have a $0.90 package of shims handy.
  • You may want to remove some parts from the old dishwasher that could come in handy - hose adapters, tension relief for the wires (if hard wired), etc...
  • Always replace your drain hose because 1) gross, 2) new one is free, and 3) new one is easy to install.
  • If you have PEX running to your dishwasher, someone should get punched in the face.
I have an open floor plan and can't hear the 48 db dishwasher at all; barely hear it from 5 feet away. You can go quieter, but price tends to go up exponentially.
 

DSmith21

New member
Mar 27, 2012
8,297
2,036
0
We bought an LG stove recently and I think it is top notch. We are getting ready to replace our dishwasher too. The one we have is a Frigidaire. It sucks. We had a GE at our old house that was better than the Frigidaire but not great. Glasses never come out of this Frigidaire without film on them and it burns through that stuff for clear glassware much quicker than our GE did.

Glassware comes out of dishwashers today with a film on them because the EPA mandated that phosphates be taken out of detergents several years ago. Many people assume that the their old dishwasher is the problem but its your new formulation of Cascade or whatever. However, restaurants were exempted from the no phosphate rule. You can buy the old phosphate detergents (that work much better) if you go to a restaurant supply store or on Amazon. Procter & Gamble sells it as "fryer boil out" but its really the old dish detergent fomula.
 
Last edited: