I want to preface this with I support college players making any money they can off of their name, image and likeness. I also support a player being able to transfer. The problem is that both, as currently set-up, are going to kill college sports long-term by making the playing field more unequal than it already is.
NIL
The Supreme Court ruled college athletes cannot be prevented from making money from NIL. That is simple enough, but there is a big difference between player X making money doing a commercial spot for an auto dealership and colleges setting up these collectives to pay players directly. Why can’t the NCAA ban the collectives? I keep hearing on KSR that only Congress could do something about this. Players can make all the money they want, but the colleges should not be permitted to facilitate it.
Portal
The transfer portal should allow one transfer for any reason, but the second one should require an act of God and approval under limited circumstances. If a player is contacted by a school (coach, booster, representative of school) before entering the portal (tampered with) that should be a major violation and the player should be ruled ineligible at the new school.
Wonder if anyone else is as confused as I am about why the current free for all system can’t be better regulated.
NIL
The Supreme Court ruled college athletes cannot be prevented from making money from NIL. That is simple enough, but there is a big difference between player X making money doing a commercial spot for an auto dealership and colleges setting up these collectives to pay players directly. Why can’t the NCAA ban the collectives? I keep hearing on KSR that only Congress could do something about this. Players can make all the money they want, but the colleges should not be permitted to facilitate it.
Portal
The transfer portal should allow one transfer for any reason, but the second one should require an act of God and approval under limited circumstances. If a player is contacted by a school (coach, booster, representative of school) before entering the portal (tampered with) that should be a major violation and the player should be ruled ineligible at the new school.
Wonder if anyone else is as confused as I am about why the current free for all system can’t be better regulated.