No BMac on the floor....what did people think?

Medill90

Junior
Jan 30, 2011
6,910
321
0
What was your take on the ball handling?

What did you think of the half court offense without a ball dominant guard?
 

NJCat

All-Conference
Mar 7, 2016
21,326
1,500
113
What was your take on the ball handling?

What did you think of the half court offense without a ball dominant guard?
I think I'll wait until NU isn't playing against air. UNO on Thursday will be an interesting case study.
 

Deeringfish

All-Conference
Jun 23, 2008
21,019
1,289
63
Is there any advantage that as the season goes on, teams will have to prepare for different guys bringing the ball up?
 

harkesnu

Redshirt
Jan 27, 2004
354
9
13
If you look at turnover %, or turnovers/40 min adjusted for usage rate, Ash was slightly worse than BMac last year. Your argument is worn out and wrong Wrassler. And worn out. And wrong...
 

catcrazy

Sophomore
Aug 5, 2001
3,777
124
62
Let’s give Mac some respect. He was a pass first point guard who could drive. Our offense was stale at times but he also helped us get to our first NCAA tournament and that no one else has done. Let’s cut the derogatory crap
 

Pukecat

Redshirt
Sep 30, 2018
615
0
0
I don’t miss him!

Let’s give Mac some respect. He was a pass first point guard who could drive. Our offense was stale at times but he also helped us get to our first NCAA tournament and that no one else has done. Let’s cut the derogatory crap

He was not a good perimeter shooter and not a good defender. I liked his personality more than his ability. Sometimes we confuse the two.

I wonder if the offense was stale due to him or due to coaching. I guess we will find out. It doesn’t really seem like anybody knows what our offensive philosophy is.
 
Aug 31, 2001
23,343
332
0
I liked his personality more than his ability.

All-time school leader in assists. First PG to lead us to the NCAAs. A team that absolutely could not function when he wasn’t on the floor. Yeah...no ability there. :( unreal...We truly have have some seriously sh*tty fans.
 

Sec_112

Sophomore
Jun 17, 2001
6,598
195
63
I know it's a weak list, but is there any possibility BMac isn't a top three PG in the modern history of NU? McKinney, Thompson and BMac in no particular order.

I HAVE to be forgetting someone, but I'm not sure there's even a close fourth.

Geno? Better talent than than BMac and Thompson, but two years doesn't cut it.

Baldwin? The anti-BMac defender, but could never come close to taking over a game even for a few minutes.

Who am I forgetting that deserves a mention? I need help on the early 80s and 70s guys.
 

Medill90

Junior
Jan 30, 2011
6,910
321
0
I know it's a weak list, but is there any possibility BMac isn't a top three PG in the modern history of NU? McKinney, Thompson and BMac in no particular order.

I HAVE to be forgetting someone, but I'm not sure there's even a close fourth.

Geno? Better talent than than BMac and Thompson, but two years doesn't cut it.

Baldwin? The anti-BMac defender, but could never come close to taking over a game even for a few minutes.

Who am I forgetting that deserves a mention? I need help on the early 80s and 70s guys.

Jenkins was great...late 70's/early 80's
 

Pukecat

Redshirt
Sep 30, 2018
615
0
0
All-time school leader in assists. First PG to lead us to the NCAAs. A team that absolutely could not function when he wasn’t on the floor. Yeah...no ability there. :( unreal...We truly have have some seriously sh*tty fans.

In what world does saying ‘I liked his personality more than his ability’ mean ‘no ability?’

He was our best player at times but it was his personality that really impressed me. He was a hard worker, a positive thinker, a playmaker on a team without playmakers. That he fell short in some areas—and saying that he did—is not saying he had ‘no ability.’ Your post is completely wrongheaded and inappropriately profane.

As the team continues to improve, we can’t forget the contributions of Mac, Scottie, and Sanjay. But they were not perfect players and it does them no credit to be anything but objective about why we loved them or why we wished they could have been even better.
 
Aug 31, 2001
23,343
332
0
He was our best player at times but it was his personality that really impressed me. He was a hard worker, a positive thinker, a playmaker on a team without playmakers. That he fell short in some areas—and saying that he did—is not saying he had ‘no ability.’ Your post is completely wrongheaded and inappropriately profane.

As the team continues to improve, we can’t forget the contributions of Mac, Scottie, and Sanjay. But they were not perfect players and it does them no credit to be anything but objective about why we loved them or why we wished they could have been even better.

That was a heck of a spin job after crapping on him....
 

willycat

Junior
Jan 11, 2005
21,448
318
0
I know it's a weak list, but is there any possibility BMac isn't a top three PG in the modern history of NU? McKinney, Thompson and BMac in no particular order.

I HAVE to be forgetting someone, but I'm not sure there's even a close fourth.

Geno? Better talent than than BMac and Thompson, but two years doesn't cut it.

Baldwin? The anti-BMac defender, but could never come close to taking over a game even for a few minutes.

Who am I forgetting that deserves a mention? I need help on the early 80s and 70s guys.
Parker?
 

NUCat320

Senior
Dec 4, 2005
19,469
495
0
He was not a good perimeter shooter and not a good defender. I liked his personality more than his ability. Sometimes we confuse the two.

I wonder if the offense was stale due to him or due to coaching. I guess we will find out. It doesn’t really seem like anybody knows what our offensive philosophy is.
I will love Mc forever.

He was 20 when he came in, and I don’t think he got much better while he was at NU. But he was plenty good, and, along with Law, one of the ten most important players in program history.
 

Katatonic

Sophomore
Oct 23, 2004
86,854
134
0
Think there will be some struggles as the players get used to their new roles (and playing w/ each other in those roles).

But then we may see a more dynamic O when the shot clock is winding down.

Never understood why the staff didn't correct BMac when he would wait too long to start his drives (which often resulted in a bad, hurried shot either by BMac or whomever he had dished it off too, as there wasn't time for a secondary pass and possibly a better shot).

But BMac wasn't the only one who did this repeatedly, Demps would also be frustrating in this dept. (of course, it made for a great highlight when the shot went in).