Decide.
Only reasonable post in this threadNot just crunchy. Extra crunchy.
Crunchy if choosing, good with both really. Peanut butter is pretty much as can't miss as anything there is.
Pallet likes crunchy, colon likes creamy.
I guarantee this is going to turn into a circle jerk of imported cashew butters versus almond and cacao nut spreads.
I like crunchy with honey.
Had a teacher tell us how much rodent hair and feces is allowed, never looked at it the same way since.
But prefer crunchy since you can't notice the difference.
Reminds me of an old Brian Regan bit:The only time i eat peanut butter it has to be mixed with jelly. You guys are a bunch of goobers, no pun intended.
![]()
What are you talking about? That stuff is in my JIF Extra Crunchy?
To me, it's mostly about value. I feel like I'm getting more bang for my buck with the crunchy. There are so many peanuts in there. But if I find out half of them are actually mouse turds, then I'll be disappointed.
Ultimately, creamy peanut butter is for ***** *** babies with no teeth and no personal preference because they are damn babies; they don't know.