Originally posted by dukehokie:
"Though there is no 'official' criteria to have a jersey retired at
Duke, a player must achieve at a national level - earn National
Player of the Year or National Defensive Player of the Year honors,
set an NCAA record, win a gold medal representing his country in the
Olympics or earn All-America recognition. What distinguishes Duke's
retired jersey players from many other schools is the main criteria.
No jersey will be retired at Duke unless the player has earned his
degree."
This is from the Duke media guide. For now Quinn only meets the standards of graduation and a gold medal. He will not have the #2 retired. Nolan actually would hold that honor over him IMO and that isn't happening either. This is why Duke has the hall of honor. Quinn will be recognized there.
This is also why I think UNC gets something right. I think Duke should have jersey honors AND retirements. What would the harm be (besides exceeding structural weight limits) in honoring players in that way? Guys like Steve Vacendak and Mike Lewis and Jim Spanarkel and Kyle Singler and Nolan Smith and Jon Scheyer and DeMarcus Nelson and now Quinn Cook and many others (Gene Banks, Bill Werber...) deserve to be recognized in the building and space in which they showed their greatness. I've said this for a while on this board and in person, but I would love to see Duke hang some jerseys in honor in blue and retired in white. Just a wish of mine.
Agreed about some for of recognition for those who miss the retirement cut. B/c of how many great players that play here, we can't retire the jersey of everyone who steps foot on campus -- and have to reserve it for the special few who make an indelible mark on the program for a sustained period (b/c otherwise we'd have to retire like 30 more jerseys). With that said, UNC's approach is right in my view. Guys like Nolan Smith, Scheyer, Singler, Mason Plumlee, Duhon, Cook,etc. deserve some recognition -- and frankly, most programs would retire their jerseys if they had similar career successes (in terms of individual honors and team accomplishments). I think that particularly makes sense in view of the current one-and-done system, which is unlikely to produce many future players who can meet all of the traditional criteria for getting their jerseys retired (particularly the graduation piece) -- i.e., are we really not going to do anything to honor kids like Okafor / Winslow who were the foundation of a national title team? While we don't have enough room to hang 50+ jerseys in cameron, I do think we could have a large banner or couple large banners that list out the guys who hit some other major criteria, such as AA, final four MOP, ACC POY, or ACC First Team.
This post was edited on 4/9 4:46 PM by aah555