Something new. Okay player ABC agreed to play at school XYZ and got NIL money, what if he says, no, not playing, draft is at risk?

Gocatsgo2003

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2006
45,424
1,438
78

NUCat320

Senior
Dec 4, 2005
19,469
495
0
Back in the ‘old’/pre-NIL days, there were pushes for Jadaveon Clowney to sit out his entire junior season. Business decision.

I know some teams like players who ‘really love football’, but Williams definitely has done enough.

It would be a great things if NIL payouts had participation requirements of some sort. A shame about the NCAA…
 

Sheffielder

Junior
Sep 1, 2004
9,585
344
83
Serious question: what is the NCAA's stance now on players having agents?

I'm asking because it seems very, very logical that NIL will soon (if it hasn't already) reach a point where contracts will need to be signed between players and benefactors - whether we're talking about % of games played, incentives, bowl games, fundamental eligibility...a million different things. There can be no "good faith" here - has to be in writing and seems unfair for a child to navigate this with one or two idiot parents or crazy Uncle Remus "helping."
 

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
25,635
1,111
113
The NFL does care about having good tape. The last few games have been pretty “meh” against the first couple legitimate defenses he’s faced. Sitting out the rest of the season seems like a bad idea, bowl game seems obvious if not the Natty.
I don’t believe Williams has ever mentioned he is considering skipping the rest of the year.
 
Aug 31, 2003
14,652
192
63
It's in the name. The players are being compensated for their "name, image, and likeness," not for playing.

Now, the schools are compensating them with scholarship/room/board for playing. Could the schools revoke those?
 
Nov 5, 2001
18,319
554
113
My guess. A well written contract would require you to be available to play or injured to get paid. Second, there are many cases of people skipping out. I don't think it affects his NFL stock. So, is the remaining NIL money worth staying?
 

Gocatsgo2003

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2006
45,424
1,438
78
My guess. A well written contract would require you to be available to play or injured to get paid. Second, there are many cases of people skipping out. I don't think it affects his NFL stock. So, is the remaining NIL money worth staying?

That’s the trick… NIL (at least in theory/technicality) isn’t supposed to be tied to attending a specific school to say nothing of actual playing time.
 

xxxbobxxx

Sophomore
Mar 12, 2005
10,782
131
43
That’s where NIL is gonna get REALLY interesting. And why I’m assuming there are some people pushing for more standardized contracts and reporting.
Normally, a lawyer would look at college kid defendant and say that even with a win, no way to collect. Not the case here. And a smart advisor to student would probably advise to repay as judgement plus attorney fees to fight May eat up whatever portion of the first contract he receives after agent and tax deductions.
 

xxxbobxxx

Sophomore
Mar 12, 2005
10,782
131
43
That’s where NIL is gonna get REALLY interesting. And why I’m assuming there are some people pushing for more standardized contracts and reporting.
Further - I would set a contract to pay in installments and scale with relation to Q rating. It is NIL which implies measurable Q. I would include required participation in public contests monthly, maybe with exception for documented injury.
 

xxxbobxxx

Sophomore
Mar 12, 2005
10,782
131
43
Serious question: what is the NCAA's stance now on players having agents?

I'm asking because it seems very, very logical that NIL will soon (if it hasn't already) reach a point where contracts will need to be signed between players and benefactors - whether we're talking about % of games played, incentives, bowl games, fundamental eligibility...a million different things. There can be no "good faith" here - has to be in writing and seems unfair for a child to navigate this with one or two idiot parents or crazy Uncle Remus "helping."
Anyone can hire a lawyer. If NCAA or any other group tried to impinge on that negatively, the lawyers would have a field day.

Smart first year MBB and FB players hire lawyers with hourly rates since contracts are boiler plate and there is no reason to give an agent a percentage.