The transfer portal is a friggin' mess!

Rebel II1

Redshirt
Dec 7, 2021
1,771
0
0
Approaching 3,000 names. They ought to let the schools trade and buy players and announce it.
 

jimmyNU

Redshirt
Sep 12, 2005
286
0
0
Is that true? We have 130 or so programs with 85 scholarships per school. Even if you include the three service academies, the total population of scholarship players is right around 11,000. If we are approaching 3,000 in the portal that would mean that over 25% of all scholarship players are looking to transfer.

Maybe non-scholarship players are allowed to use the portal. I'm not exactly sure how that works.
 

Rebel II1

Redshirt
Dec 7, 2021
1,771
0
0
Is that true? We have 130 or so programs with 85 scholarships per school. Even if you include the three service academies, the total population of scholarship players is right around 11,000. If we are approaching 3,000 in the portal that would mean that over 25% of all scholarship players are looking to transfer.

Maybe non-scholarship players are allowed to use the portal. I'm not exactly sure how that works.
Yes, PWOs and all non scholarship players have access as well. NU had a pwo Qb enter the portal this year. The OSU's backup Qb entered yesterday and is highly rated non scholarship player.
 
Nov 5, 2001
18,474
729
113
Yes, PWOs and all non scholarship players have access as well. NU had a pwo Qb enter the portal this year. The OSU's backup Qb entered yesterday and is highly rated non scholarship player.
He's the third OSU scholarship QB to bolt. Basically, it's become no different than changing your major (for those of them that attend class.../s).

I understand the perspective of the student athlete. They want to play. If they are an elite player like Joseph, they want to play on a good team and excel. They bust their a$$es 12 months a year and then...don't play? They've been star athletes all of their lives, and have been told by coaches that they will continue to be, and then they don't play. Why stay?

Of course, the FBS programs can't absorb 3k kids plus incoming Freshmen. A ton of them will go back where they started or go FCS.
 

CSCatFan1

Senior
Dec 4, 2002
39,976
457
0
Of course, the FBS programs can't absorb 3k kids plus incoming Freshmen. A ton of them will go back where they started or go FCS.

Only a small percentage will go back where they started. The majority are not welcomed back.
 

wolve1972

Junior
Sep 3, 2018
779
281
18
Only a small percentage will go back where they started. The majority are not welcomed back.
Exactly, especially at some of the higher end programs. Teams like Alabama, Georgia, Clemson and OSU will just say adios and recruit someone just as good or better
 

Sheffielder

Senior
Sep 1, 2004
9,630
424
83
A significant unintended consequence of the transfer portal - I bet many of these "students" never enroll anywhere else - playing career AND college career both over, whereas under the old system they would have sat on the bench for years, maybe gotten in on plays here or there, and maybe possibly gotten their degree. Obviously there are many different stories that go in every direction, but this is definitely going to be an unfortunate outcome for many.
 

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
25,928
1,409
113
A significant unintended consequence of the transfer portal - I bet many of these "students" never enroll anywhere else - playing career AND college career both over, whereas under the old system they would have sat on the bench for years, maybe gotten in on plays here or there, and maybe possibly gotten their degree. Obviously there are many different stories that go in every direction, but this is definitely going to be an unfortunate outcome for many.
That’s their problem. They made the choice to enter the portal. Better believe in yourself and more importantly other schools better perceive you as a viable scholarship player if you plan on taking the risk.
 

Medill '03

Sophomore
Nov 22, 2001
4,107
130
62
That’s their problem. They made the choice to enter the portal. Better believe in yourself and more importantly other schools better perceive you as a viable scholarship player if you plan on taking the risk.
I think a lot of the most successful programs "nudge" their bench players into the portal.
 

stpaulcat

Senior
May 29, 2001
34,959
677
113
He’s headed to South Bend.
Joseph reflects a serious failure, as did Skoronski. The positive is NU is a great preparation for playing at ND. Wow. just wow, and to think we have beaten them 2 of our last three games. Will there ever be a next time?
 

CSCatFan1

Senior
Dec 4, 2002
39,976
457
0
Joseph reflects a serious failure, as did Skoronski. The positive is NU is a great preparation for playing at ND. Wow. just wow, and to think we have beaten them 2 of our last three games. Will there ever be a next time?

“Better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak and to remove all doubt.”
 

Fanaticat98

Junior
May 29, 2001
8,621
265
83
Joseph reflects a serious failure, as did Skoronski. The positive is NU is a great preparation for playing at ND. Wow. just wow, and to think we have beaten them 2 of our last three games. Will there ever be a next time?
You mean Skowronek (whew). I had a mild panic attack and started Googling thinking something happened with Skoronski.
 

stpaulcat

Senior
May 29, 2001
34,959
677
113
You mean Skowronek (whew). I had a mild panic attack and started Googling thinking something happened with Skoronski.
That would be the second time I have misspelled his name. Skowronek, I sincerely apologize. Not acceptable especially since i take spelling very seriously. Vodka may have played a role.