I think anyone whose viewing these hires from a rational, objective perspective (which is, very, very few of us on here) would have to be skeptical at best on whether they'll succeed when you consider the hires that Stoops has made to date. Anyone who is all in with these hires at this point just isn't being truthful with themselves and need to take a break from drinking the blue kool aid.
What have you HONESTLY seen in the first three years from Stoops and the staff that he HAND PICKED (which in large part has been an utter and complete failure by college football standards of anyone not named Kentucky) that gives you such excitement that these guys are suddenly going to be our saviors? Come on. I know we have some smart guys on here, but some of you really have to take a step back from letting your emotions and undying love for all things UK overshadow your judgment.
I see an upward trajectory. I don't think you realize just how bad of shape Joker left us in. The team got noticeably better last year as well, it's just a matter of the offense being barren thanks to Shannon Dawson's horrendous playcalling.
I like the hires. I don't think it's fair to judge new hires based on the failures of previous hires. If Stoops was competent enough to realize that he needed to fire Dawson, and then he immediately went after Gran (who declined Kentucky whenever Stoops called last year, which led to Stoops getting Dawson), I think we should recognize that Gran is the better option than Dawson as well.
What do you not like about the hire? Is it the ~15 years of experience that Gran has in the SEC? The big numbers on offense? The familiarity that he has with Stoops? His recruiting ability? Surely you can think of something that you don't like about the hire rather than "but.. the last guy!"
Same with Hinshaw. What about Hinshaw makes you have reservations? Dude put a true freshman in at QB at Tennessee, and that QB ended up being very, very good while being coached under Hinshaw. Led to Tennessee having a very solid passing offense. He's a very well spoken individual who really shows his knowledge for the game every time he speaks, and he has a familiarity with our new OC that they've shared for a while now.
They came here with a plan, and they did a solid job of explaining it, as opposed to what Dawson did last year with "no, I have't really used my tight ends in the passing game before".. "No, never ran a wildcat formation either".. "Nope, I'll never run my QB's, no matter how open the field is".