Why Would Anyone Seek a Blind Plea?
There are reasons why a defendant might take a blind plea bargain. For example, if the judge has a record of going easy on people who plead guilty, or if the prosecution has a very good case but refuses to cut a deal, then a blind plea might be a risk worth taking.
A defendant may take a blind plea when there is no lesser included offense for a plea bargain or when the prosecution imposes a very unfavorable plea bargain. A lenient judge might hand down a lighter sentence if a blind plea is paired with clear signs of regret, remorse, and other actions.
Some individuals might prefer taking a chance with the judge and not trusting the prosecution. Individuals with a long criminal history and extensive experience with the prosecution might be hesitant to trust them. However, every defendant should trust their attorney, whether a criminal defense lawyer or a public defender.
If you go to a bench trial or jury trial, the evidence is presented, and the state must either meet their burden of proof or acquit you. There is no middle ground. There is a lot of risk in going before a jury because no one knows how a jury will rule. However, if you face a prosecutor you don’t feel will give you a fair recommendation, a blind plea may be the best option for you.
