Whose idea was it for Clemson

PrestonyteParrot

Well-known member
May 28, 2024
1,533
1,499
113
to throw a pass with 16 seconds left instead of running the ball or kicking the field goal?
You have a field goal in the back pocket, but you get greedy and throw a pass into the middle of the field where bad things can happen and it did.
A pass to end zone which only your guy can catch makes sense but thankfully they chose the path they did.
 

bayrooster

Well-known member
Jan 21, 2022
2,209
1,638
113
to throw a pass with 16 seconds left instead of running the ball or kicking the field goal?
You have a field goal in the back pocket, but you get greedy and throw a pass into the middle of the field where bad things can happen and it did.
A pass to end zone which only your guy can catch makes sense but thankfully they chose the path they did.
I prefer to give Dabo the credit for that one. After all, the buck stops with Dabo. 😁
 

3USC1801

Joined Dec 10, 2020
Jan 17, 2022
912
3,141
93
I prefer to give Dabo the credit for that one. After all, the buck stops with Dabo. 😁
According to Dabo in his press conference after the game, he said it was their QB’s decision—a bad play “that he will learn from.”

So, it was not on the coaching staff but simply a player making an in-game decision in an attempt to win. Disastrous for them, sweetness for Carolina!
 
  • Like
Reactions: moouclem

USCEE82

Active member
Feb 17, 2024
648
497
63
According to Dabo in his press conference after the game, he said it was their QB’s decision—a bad play “that he will learn from.”

So, it was not on the coaching staff but simply a player making an in-game decision in an attempt to win. Disastrous for them, sweetness for Carolina!
Yes. He said klubnutts made a mistake.
 

Beanerball

Well-known member
Jul 17, 2023
728
529
93
Not so sure. Who was going to tackle Sellers? lol. Just glad we didn’t have to find out.
 

KingWard

Well-known member
Feb 15, 2022
6,997
7,292
113
to throw a pass with 16 seconds left instead of running the ball or kicking the field goal?
You have a field goal in the back pocket, but you get greedy and throw a pass into the middle of the field where bad things can happen and it did.
A pass to end zone which only your guy can catch makes sense but thankfully they chose the path they did.
I've already addressed this. There's only one right answer and it's the most obvious one. Even his idolaters with whom I go to church were in agreement with that this morning, yet Gamecock people here want to defend him, I suppose because our own coach is subject to occasional brain farts.
 

kidrobinski

Well-known member
Jan 30, 2022
550
513
93
My take is that their qb (name escapes me) saw this game as an opportunity to cement his name in clemmons lore, was bolstered by his early success at throwing the ball, figured we wouldn't be expecting it, and took his shot. Their guy could have caught it, made a move and/or broke a tackle, and you guys are sitting around today throwing shade at our defense and woe is me-ing. Football players don't think in terms of Dooley or Bryant, they play to win games; their mind is not the fan's mind. If Sellers had gotten clipped and fumbled on his game winning run you guys would be blasting and claiming he should have just thrown it away if no one was open.

Play the game to win. Glory lasts forever.
 

The Reel Ess

Joined Feb 3, 2005
Jan 31, 2022
1,628
1,937
113
If they score a TD to end the game he's a genius. They throw an incompletion, no harm. But the ball bounced funny. I don't blame them for trying to do what had served them well in the first 3 quarters. I've heard complaints that they got too conservative. Which is it?

They didn't want OT. I feel certain the play was to throw into for a TD if it was there, but coverage was good so Klubnick checked down to play it safe. It was his worst throw of the day. They wanted to win in regulation, finally beat a ranked team and do it with style points. It just backfired disastrously.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HWGcock and 92Pony

Goofy141!

Active member
May 29, 2023
806
386
63
to throw a pass with 16 seconds left instead of running the ball or kicking the field goal?
You have a field goal in the back pocket, but you get greedy and throw a pass into the middle of the field where bad things can happen and it did.
A pass to end zone which only your guy can catch makes sense but thankfully they chose the path they did.
They were going for the win - I would hope we would do the same if we were in the same situation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 92Pony

Uscg1984

Well-known member
Jan 28, 2022
1,822
2,411
113
I don't know who made the decision. But right before that play, I told my son that I hoped they would just run the ball a couple of times and play for the field goal because I wasn't sure we could keep them out of the endzone if they kept throwing the ball. It turned out I was wrong, but they were going for the win - exactly as I hoped they wouldn't. It worked out for us.
 
  • Like
Reactions: moouclem

treyno2722

Joined Dec 20, 2004
Feb 3, 2022
176
84
28
Didn't we just do the same thing two weeks ago with Mizzou? We had a game tying FG in the bag but we did the shuttle pass to Rocket Sanders.
 

Uscg1984

Well-known member
Jan 28, 2022
1,822
2,411
113
Didn't we just do the same thing two weeks ago with Mizzou? We had a game tying FG in the bag but we did the shuttle pass to Rocket Sanders.
One difference with the shovel pass is that it's almost as safe as a run. The RB is only about 8 feet in front of the QB and if he mishandles the waist-high pitch, it likely falls harmlessly to the ground. Throwing a pass out beyond the line of scrimmage does increase the risk of an interception.

Having said that, if I were a Clemson fan, I don't think I'd have a problem with that play call, only the execution.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 92Pony

92Pony

Joined Jan 18, 2011
Jan 20, 2022
2,479
6,522
113
Ditto.

Major credit to the defender (can't make his number out on the YouTube video) who fought through the OL block to force Klubnik's errant throw.

Because he was pressured, the ball was thrown behind Mafah, which led to the tip and pick.
Without going and digging up the replay, I'll say I've read that it was Stewart.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 18IsTheMan

18IsTheMan

Well-known member
Jan 19, 2022
14,462
12,404
113
Without going and digging up the replay, I'll say I've read that it was Stewart.
Yep, saw a replay from another angle and you could see it was him.

Don't think we heard his name called all game, even on that play, but he was absolutely a factor in forcing the errant throw.