Skip to main content

Top 5 Underrated Option Era Players - Tyler Carmona

by: Mike James07/22/25navybirddog
NCAA Football: Tulane at Navy
Sep 9, 2017; Annapolis, MD, USA; Navy Midshipmen wide receiver Tyler Carmona (88) runs down the sideline for a touchdown after a second quarter reception against the Tulane Green Wave at Navy-Marine Corps Memorial Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Tommy Gilligan-USA TODAY Sports

#5 – Lamar Owens

#4 – Tyler Carmona

Option football isn’t kind to wide receivers when it comes to box score glory; they call themselves “wide blockers” for a reason. Still, there have been a few that put up strong numbers. Jamir Tillman had 1,626 career receiving yards, the closest anyone’s ever gotten to Rob Taylor’s Navy career record. Greg Jones’ 662 yards in 2010 is the fifth-most in Navy history. Tyree Barnes got an NFL look. Several others delivered memorable moments. But when it comes to making the most of his opportunities, I don’t know if there’s anyone in Navy history quite like Tyler Carmona.

At 6-4, 227, Carmona was the most punishing blocking receiver of the option era; Navy fans might remember the blocks he and Dishan Romine threw in the 2016 Notre Dame game. He was also the most big-play receiver Navy has ever had. His first two receptions in 2017 went for 56 and 79 yards. Nearly one out of every three of his 23 career receptions was a touchdown, including his magnum opus to clinch the 2017 Air Force game.

Oct 7, 2017; Annapolis, MD, USA; Navy Midshipmen wide receiver Tyler Carmona (88) catches the go ahead touchdown n front of Air Force Falcons defensive back Marquis Griffin (2) during the fourth quarter in at Navy-Marine Corps Memorial Stadium. Navy Midshipmen defeated Air Force Falcons 48-45. Mandatory Credit: Tommy Gilligan-USA TODAY Sports

Carmona averaged 27.2 yards per reception that year, which would be a school record if not for falling one reception short of the 15 needed to qualify. His career average of 24.9 yards per catch would also be a school record if it wasn’t just two catches short.

With or without the ball, Tyler Carmona was one of the option era’s most explosive players.

You may also like