Sycamore-Antioch

good_nocall

Freshman
Jun 29, 2001
119
86
27
Unfortunately, this happens more often than anyone would hope. Which is why it is covered by rule in the NFHS rule book. One official ruled incomplete pass and sounded his whistle. The crew got together and determined (correctly) that the ball was caught, which made the whistle inadvertent.

Inadvertent whistle while ball is in possession of a player results in the offense getting the choice of taking the result of the play at the time of the whistle or replaying the down. And, in the case like this where time had also expired, one untimed down follows (Rule 3-3-3c).

A touchdown cannot be result of this play as Sycamore can (also correctly) say that they stopped playing when the whistle blew.

I had no true rooting interest in the game and just giving the facts. Horrible situation all around and not the way anyone wants a game to end.
 

RB_RocketFan

Freshman
Oct 15, 2023
68
89
18
This is awful. There was pass interference in end zone on the untimed down as well. Sucks for Antioch to have their season end that way. Feel bad for the ref as well. I believe they want to get it right, but mistakes happen.
 

good_nocall

Freshman
Jun 29, 2001
119
86
27
And here is my editorial/opinionated thought ... this is exactly the reason why, when people get frustrated when the whistle seems so late or in some cases seems like there never is one, they really should not be. Officials are trained never to blow the whistle until they are absolutely certain the status of the ball, with or without player possession. This play is exhibit #1 on why that is so important.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Colin2299

RetiredReferee

All-Conference
Aug 27, 2011
1,117
1,110
113
And here is my editorial/opinionated thought ... this is exactly the reason why, when people get frustrated when the whistle seems so late or in some cases seems like there never is one, they really should not be. Officials are trained never to blow the whistle until they are absolutely certain the status of the ball, with or without player possession. This play is exhibit #1 on why that is so important.
The play ends itself. The whistle is nothing more than a courtesy.
 

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,715
4,447
113
Doesn’t the ref point to the ground to indicate incomplete pass, which deserves a whistle? Still wrong call but stuff like this happens every year. It would happen in nfl without replay.
 

OnVikings!

Senior
Nov 15, 2024
364
562
87
This is awful. There was pass interference in end zone on the untimed down as well. Sucks for Antioch to have their season end that way. Feel bad for the ref as well. I believe they want to get it right, but mistakes happen.
I’d be more inclined to feel bad for them if their assistant coach wasn’t such an outspoken crybaby. In this case, I feel that the football gods got it right.
 

Colin2299

Senior
Aug 13, 2025
830
588
93
Doesn’t the ref point to the ground to indicate incomplete pass, which deserves a whistle? Still wrong call but stuff like this happens every year. It would happen in nfl without replay.
That’s what I don’t understand. It’s either a catch or in completion.

I think the right decision by the refs would have been to call it a touchdown. Sycamore staff would’ve been very upset, but not as upset as Antioch’s plus it’s the right call.
 

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,199
4,599
113
That’s what I don’t understand. It’s either a catch or in completion.

I think the right decision by the refs would have been to call it a touchdown. Sycamore staff would’ve been very upset, but not as upset as Antioch’s plus it’s the right call.
If there was a whistle you can't call it a TD, defense could have stopped when they heard the whistle.

Crappy situation all the way around but it was handled correctly.
 

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,715
4,447
113
That’s what I don’t understand. It’s either a catch or in completion.

I think the right decision by the refs would have been to call it a touchdown. Sycamore staff would’ve been very upset, but not as upset as Antioch’s plus it’s the right call.
I’m saying in the video you see the ref pointing to the ground. Right or wrong after that and whistle play is done.
 

Colin2299

Senior
Aug 13, 2025
830
588
93
I’m saying in the video you see the ref pointing to the ground. Right or wrong after that and whistle play is done.
Correct. Which is why I don’t get why another ref comes in and over rules him.

If you are going to over rule him, then call it a TD.
 
Jul 2, 2019
349
477
63
The play ends itself. The whistle is nothing more than a courtesy.
Bingo GIF by Hawkeye
 

RB_RocketFan

Freshman
Oct 15, 2023
68
89
18
I’d be more inclined to feel bad for them if their assistant coach wasn’t such an outspoken crybaby. In this case, I feel that the football gods got it right.
I don’t know anyone affiliated with- just an observer and feel bad for the kids
 

LakeCtyNewt

All-Conference
Nov 13, 2002
8,195
4,701
63
It’s a horrible situation. Official was also poorly placed as well to signal incomplete or ball hit the ground. Secondly, the horn sounds as the official is signaling the incomplete pass. You’re the back judge and you’ve got the clock. Mechanics are you swallow the whistle and let the game horn be the end of the play.

Yea the play was messed up. But mechanics wise that was really a very poorly officiated play.
 

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,715
4,447
113
I’m actually hoping you can provide an answer, as a retired referee, to this scenario.
Once the whistle was blow there was no going back to change the call, at least in terms of awarding them a TD. I think that is the answer.
Stuff like this happens every year, it's unfortunate but with no review the human error happens.
 

HRCJRHRCJR

Redshirt
Oct 28, 2025
37
35
18
Once the whistle was blow there was no going back to change the call, at least in terms of awarding them a TD. I think that is the answer.
Stuff like this happens every year, it's unfortunate but with no review the human error happens.
Get in the wayback machine and go to Fenwick in 2016
 
  • Like
Reactions: ramblinman reborn

good_nocall

Freshman
Jun 29, 2001
119
86
27
Mechanics are you swallow the whistle and let the game horn be the end of the play.
As was previously said, a play ends itself, and the whistle signals the end of the play already occurred. The game horn is a courtesy to everyone in the stadium and nothing else (and it is not controlled by an on-field official). It is completely unnecessary because no play in football is ended by the horn or even the clock reaching zeroes ... no play can begin after the clock has reached zeroes.

The horn at a stadium has far more value for a soccer match or a lacrosse game than it does for football. In fact, the NFHS recommends that the game clock horn be TURNED OFF if possible: clock_operator.pdf
 

Colin2299

Senior
Aug 13, 2025
830
588
93
As was previously said, a play ends itself, and the whistle signals the end of the play already occurred. The game horn is a courtesy to everyone in the stadium and nothing else (and it is not controlled by an on-field official). It is completely unnecessary because no play in football is ended by the horn or even the clock reaching zeroes ... no play can begin after the clock has reached zeroes.

The horn at a stadium has far more value for a soccer match or a lacrosse game than it does for football. In fact, the NFHS recommends that the game clock horn be TURNED OFF if possible: clock_operator.pdf
That’s my question here…”the ply ends itself”.

What does that mean?

The play in question here ended when the completed pass was carried through the EZ by the WR or when the ball was incompleted.

or…as it was called on the field, the play ended when the whistle was inadvertently blown.
 

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,715
4,447
113
That’s my question here…”the ply ends itself”.

What does that mean?

The play in question here ended when the completed pass was carried through the EZ by the WR or when the ball was incompleted.

or…as it was called on the field, the play ended when the whistle was inadvertently blown.
I think what he is saying is "in theory the play ends when the play ends and the ref blows the whistle to signal the play is over and for some safety reasons. In most cases, the ref isn't ending the play, he is signaling the play is over". In this case he signaled the play was over before the play was over but you stop on the whistle, so you can't change the outcome of the play.

Even with replay in the NFL a play like that would not have resulted in TD because the whistle blew before he scored.

In this instance the whistle blowing is what matters, it incorrectly signaled the play was over.
 
Last edited:

good_nocall

Freshman
Jun 29, 2001
119
86
27
That’s my question here…”the ply ends itself”.

What does that mean?

The play in question here ended when the completed pass was carried through the EZ by the WR or when the ball was incompleted.

or…as it was called on the field, the play ended when the whistle was inadvertently blown.
Going back to my message on this from yesterday, I said very purposefuly "One official ruled incomplete pass and sounded his whistle."

The order of those events is important:
1. Official ruled incomplete pass
2. Sounded his whistle

At the time the official ruled the incomplete pass, the play ended. The subsequent whistle tells everyone else in the stadium that it ended and the ball is dead, but the whistle did not cause the end of the play.

Once it was determined that the ruling official had erred in ruling the pass incomplete and sounded the whistle, the crew would have discussed the current status of the ball at the time of the ruling. In this case, they ruled the ball was in Antioch's possession somewhere between the 10 and 15 yard line. Antioch then got the choice to replay the down from the previous spot or take the result of the play, and naturally they chose the latter option.

It is really an inadvertent "ruling of what caused the ball to become dead because ..." and a thousand different things could follow. Calling it an inadvertent whistle might be a misnomer but it more centrally clarifies it for everyone who reads a rule book and has to explain it.
 
Edgy Tim

Latest

  1. 01 Edgy Tim Football 8A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  2. 02 Edgy Tim Football 7A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  3. 03 Edgy Tim Football 6A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  4. 04 Edgy Tim 5A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  5. 05 Edgy Tim Football 4A: Semifinalist Player of the Year