Doug McDermott, AJ Green, Sam Hoiberg

Hawktech

Senior
Dec 18, 2022
557
722
93
Reporters were on Ben about PM poor play after V Tech, and Ben was in denial. He must not c the obvious
Ben told Dolph and Bobby after the game that Peyton was an "Elite Defender"... :oops:

PM got burnt 3 times toward the end of the VaTech Game. Twice on consecutive plays...
Elite defender against scrimmage teams, maybe. But against P5 competition - NFW.

I am hoping Ben sees the light. Peyton is not the answer, and may never be....in the meantime with have 3 4-star players who are better players and more athletic sitting on the bench.
SMH
 

BringBackBradBanks

All-Conference
Jul 19, 2022
979
2,188
93
Ben told Dolph and Bobby after the game that Peyton was an "Elite Defender"... :oops:

PM got burnt 3 times toward the end of the VaTech Game. Twice on consecutive plays...
Elite defender against scrimmage teams, maybe. But against P5 competition - NFW.

I am hoping Ben sees the light. Peyton is not the answer, and may never be....in the meantime with have 3 4-star players who are better players and more athletic sitting on the bench.
SMH
We are so cooked. Iowa sports can’t catch a break with this father son stuff.
 

ComradeKirk

All-Conference
Jan 12, 2026
542
1,505
93
Ben told Dolph and Bobby after the game that Peyton was an "Elite Defender"... :oops:

PM got burnt 3 times toward the end of the VaTech Game. Twice on consecutive plays...
Elite defender against scrimmage teams, maybe. But against P5 competition - NFW.

I am hoping Ben sees the light. Peyton is not the answer, and may never be....in the meantime with have 3 4-star players who are better players and more athletic sitting on the bench.
SMH
Agree. If BMC doesn't see the light, after the season he needs an ultimatum. Ditch the nepo baby or he can kick rocks. Playing his son will only be an anchor on the program long term.
 

AndreTheHawk

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2025
1,265
2,626
113
Ben told Dolph and Bobby after the game that Peyton was an "Elite Defender"... :oops:

PM got burnt 3 times toward the end of the VaTech Game. Twice on consecutive plays...
Elite defender against scrimmage teams, maybe. But against P5 competition - NFW.

I am hoping Ben sees the light. Peyton is not the answer, and may never be....in the meantime with have 3 4-star players who are better players and more athletic sitting on the bench.
SMH
"Elite Defender" is code word for "I want my Son to live out his dream while I'm the Coach". Fans don't understand DI Basketball Defense, so there's the "out".

I specifically watched Peyton McCollum on several plays just to see what an "elite defender" does away from the ball. What he did was put himself halfway between the ball and his guy, apparently intent on stopping any bounce pass attempts. Problem is he was 10 ft away from his guy at the 3 point line, and now he's susceptible to an easy pass over the top of his head for a 3 attempt or a back door cut. He's not tall enough or fast enough to handle a "real" basketball player on either front.

I'm sure Peyton McCollum is a great kid, and he's currently a Morningside level player IMO. He's not terrible, but he should not in any way, shape or form be on the court in an Iowa game against legitimate DI competition that Iowa isn't leading by 20 with a few minutes left.

He's played basketball all his life, his shooting form is solid, and he'll make a shot or 2 on occasion if he gets enough attempts at it and somehow finds himself open. I'm sure the "effort" is there. That's not enough to play major minutes over multiple 4 star recruits sitting on your bench regardless of what position they play. How about YOU force the opponent to play to YOUR strengths instead of the other way around?

I can't help but think Ben McCollum is trying to turn his Son into the next Bennett Stirtz. Sorry Dad, they're not the same player.
 

Roncuba65

All-Conference
Aug 15, 2022
1,304
2,189
113
Lol Greg McDermott was smart enough to encourage his son to play @ UNI because he didn't think his son was good enough to play in the Big 12. Obviously that changed when he went to Creighton and Doug was by far good enough and a baller. That is called being a smart dad and being realistic while having common sense... Beth better get in Ben's ear because after what we have been through as fans in the past... this will get ugly if he plays his son starter minutes and we are a sub .500 team! I am really surprised about this and thought Ben would be smarter... He will lose a lot of goodwill he gained! The one constant theme I heard many Iowa fans complaining about yesterday as we filed out of the Caseys center was that his son played so many minutes and shot the final shot.
 

ComradeKirk

All-Conference
Jan 12, 2026
542
1,505
93
Bmc can kick rocks right now
Cut It Laugh GIF
 

DukeSlater

All-American
Jul 2, 2023
2,498
5,498
113
And alas…. Iowa gets… I just can’t anymore.
Sam Hoiberg was dissed early in his career too, much like some folks are doing to Peyton McCollom now, but Fred and Sam stayed the course, and Sam became an outstanding player for his dad at Nebraska. I could easily see a similar path for the McColloms at Iowa.

BTW: If Iowa had hit a FT in one game and any kind of basket in the other, Iowa is 4-0. I wonder what some folks would be saying then since it would be the exact same team, exact same roster, and exact same minutes distribution.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hawksfor3

BringBackBradBanks

All-Conference
Jul 19, 2022
979
2,188
93
Sam Hoiberg was dissed early in his career too, much like some folks are doing to Peyton McCollom now, but Fred and Sam stayed the course, and Sam became an outstanding player for his dad at Nebraska. I could easily see a similar path for the McColloms at Iowa.

BTW: If Iowa had hit a FT in one game and any kind of basket in the other, Iowa is 4-0. I wonder what some folks would be saying then since it would be the exact same team, exact same roster, and exact same minutes distribution.
I wonder what some people would be saying if Alvaro had missed that shot against Florida. Exact same team, exact same roster, exact same minutes distribution. It’s a two way street. 🤷‍♂️
 

MacMiney

Senior
Jul 3, 2025
379
703
93
I got too triggered about all this, kinda embarrassing tbh - sorry bout the name calling earlier.. But seriously, I can't see BM long-term mishandling this type of thing like Fran did. He's too addicted to winning, and sounds like he's at least trying to maintain a sense of reality given the comment about communication with assistants about the son playing time topic.
 

Hawktech

Senior
Dec 18, 2022
557
722
93
Agree. If BMC doesn't see the light, after the season he needs an ultimatum. Ditch the nepo baby or he can kick rocks. Playing his son will only be an anchor on the program long term.
If it continues like the last two games, correct. We are not going to be sub .500 in the B1G.
 

Hawksfor3

Heisman
Dec 5, 2016
9,861
10,787
113
Sam Hoiberg was dissed early in his career too, much like some folks are doing to Peyton McCollom now, but Fred and Sam stayed the course, and Sam became an outstanding player for his dad at Nebraska. I could easily see a similar path for the McColloms at Iowa.
Good point. He became a menace later in games.
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Football Hawkeye Report Podcast
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Football Hawkeye Report Podcast with Trevor Lauck
  3. 03 Rivals Football Recruiting Four-star Iowa QB commit Chase Grove talks latest experience inside Kinnick Stadium
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Football Kelvin Bell talks Iowa defensive line development
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Basketball WATCH: Jan Jensen, Hawkeyes recap Vandy, preview Montana State