Basketball Rutgers Basketball falls to Notre Dame in wild Players Era 8 OT showdown

RAC93

All-American
Aug 11, 2023
3,837
6,361
113
No way Buchanan should be in end game over Gurdak June shouldn’t even start. Poor shot selections and poor court awareness
I have always thought, and still think, he is a Big 10 bench player. I have no issues with Buchanan in our rotation I just think we need less of him on the floor, his issue has always been decision making on the floor and playing hero ball. He’s a role player, not a hero.
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,259
182,361
113
we need at least one of smith or snydor to step up . without them we aren’t going to whiff her tourney and are too limited in the front court. buchanan is a glue guy off the bench on a tourney team
I just dont think tourney is an exoectation for this year. Its likely going to take too long to get where we want to play and roles set and the Big 10 first 5-6 games are brutal
 
  • Like
Reactions: RAC93 and Shell21

RUbyRED

Senior
Nov 14, 2025
366
979
93
we need at least one of smith or snydor to step up . without them we aren’t going to whiff her tourney and are too limited in the front court. buchanan is a glue guy off the bench on a tourney team
I think it’s gonna have to be Sydnor. Curious if / when the staff looks to ramp him up. I just don’t think Smith is a Big Ten athlete, scoring hasn’t translated against better comp
 

RutgersClassof2004

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2020
3,542
3,366
113
I think it’s gonna have to be Sydnor. Curious if / when the staff looks to ramp him up. I just don’t think Smith is a Big Ten athlete, scoring hasn’t translated against better comp
I don't know. I don't have high hopes. Didn't even play today. Is he injured? He played a bit yesterday I believe.
 

RAC93

All-American
Aug 11, 2023
3,837
6,361
113
Give TONS of credit to Notre Dame. That was a very good team

Love our effort but we arent a complete TEAM yet. We are on our way. Remember how bad we were last year at this point. Unfortunately we can be improved and finish 16-16
I am not seeing a bubble team, at least not 5 games in and the exhibitions. That could change, I see potential and we are for sure better than last year, but the defense needs to be better and we need to have this roster round into form more. Sydnor doesn’t even play, Jones gets limited minutes, there is potential for more from this group but we have to dig a little deeper on the defensive end. If we end up 0-3 in Vegas this is a disastrous trip.
 

RUbyRED

Senior
Nov 14, 2025
366
979
93
I don't know. I don't have high hopes. Didn't even play today. Is he injured? He played a bit yesterday I believe.
Oh I’m equally concerned. I just don’t think Smith is the answer. Sydnor at least has the length / athleticism to play at this level. Question is the bball IQ and whether the coaches can trust him
 

Scangg

Heisman
Mar 19, 2016
25,508
49,542
113
After a great comeback completely folded with this lineup in OT. Not sure why Knight went with this one.
He should have ran the same group back out there in OT. They earned those minutes and were on a roll

I will NEVER understand the love affair with Buchanan

He is MAYBE the 9th or 10th best player on this roster and one of the worst offensive players
Buchanan minutes should be Sydnor's?

What is going on with Sydnor? Was he just a DNP coaches decision? Is he a problem off the court? Why is he ramping down and not up? Or is it a situation where they don't want him playing on short rest back to back days??
 

SAE96

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2003
5,292
4,014
73
We need a 3 and D forward with length. Our lack of athletic size is going to hurt us as we play more talented teams.

I do appreciate the step forward the team has taken from last year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RAC93 and RUbyRED

rob kight

All-American
Oct 22, 2020
5,063
6,462
113
The team that got us to OT should have been on the floor for OT. We went up 2 and had the ball. We should have slowed the game down. They wanted the run and gun pace If we go up 4 or 5, they would have been the ones who had to intentionally fouled.
Speaking of foul shots. Missing them in the last 2 minutes of regulation was the game.
 

PhillyRU

All-Conference
Apr 17, 2021
1,089
1,794
96
It was a dreadful defensive performance, but Notre Dame is also shaping up to be a very good offensive team. Scored 1.15 points per possession against a Florida team that's routinely churned out top-10 defenses under Todd Golden and have shot >68% eFG against four of its last five opponents now.

Still, unless Notre Dame really takes off into a top-25 team this year, it's a loss against a prospective bubble rival on a neutral floor that was there for the taking. -0.7 WAB right now, so UNLV (improved)/Auburn and Seton Hall both effectively become must-win games to end non-conference play on semi-respectable footing.
 

RutgersClassof2004

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2020
3,542
3,366
113
He should have ran the same group back out there in OT. They earned those minutes and were on a roll


Buchanan minutes should be Sydnor's?

What is going on with Sydnor? Was he just a DNP coaches decision? Is he a problem off the court? Why is he ramping down and not up? Or is it a situation where they don't want him playing on short rest back to back days??
Yea it's odd. There's been some talk about Sydnor being a big piece to this team, and I know Brietman seemed very high on him, but he's playing a few minutes mostly in garbage time, or not even playing.
 

RutgersClassof2004

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2020
3,542
3,366
113
It was a dreadful defensive performance, but Notre Dame is also shaping up to be a very good offensive team. Scored 1.15 points per possession against a Florida team that's routinely churned out top-10 defenses under Todd Golden and have shot >68% eFG against four of its last five opponents now.

Still, unless Notre Dame really takes off into a top-25 team this year, it's a loss against a prospective bubble rival on a neutral floor that was there for the taking. -0.7 WAB right now, so UNLV (improved)/Auburn and Seton Hall both effectively become must-win games to end non-conference play on semi-respectable footing.
I think they'll be quite good. Very few teams have offensive firepower like that from beyond the arc. And they aren't a total one trick pony....they have the bearded fella down low and enough of their guys can get to the rim and score. I think they make expanded tournament easily.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RAC93 and BillyC80

Scangg

Heisman
Mar 19, 2016
25,508
49,542
113
Yea it's odd. There's been some talk about Sydnor being a big piece to this team, and I know Brietman seemed very high on him, but he's playing a few minutes mostly in garbage time, or not even playing.
Would have liked to see him on the big lefty and see what he could do offensively against ND weak defense

If he was a healthy scratch something is wrong off the court so I am hoping it was a pre determined we won't play him back to back days while he is rounding back into shape
 

eddynyse

Sophomore
Jul 7, 2025
71
104
18
Didn't catch this one live, but it sounds like a heck of a game and well worth the price of admission. Love the grit these guys are showing. hopefully the team and staff keep stacking good days and riding this momentum. Planning to watch a lot more games and throw a little cash behind the program to show my support (within reason... dad of two here, lol). Go Knights!
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,715
151,548
113
There is talent on this team to beat good teams obviously. Lots to clean up. A defense that switches everything is going to get exploited by smart teams, like ND. I get wanting to get out on shooters but we play this same way no matter the opponent. Any D that constantly allows your short'ish guards to wind up in the post with their center with no help around is not smart defense.
 

RUJMM78

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
26,395
12,691
113
Could not agree more, he is so ordinary and we need to mix in others more than we do. Richie always says “they like Buchanan” when asked if he’ll start, I don’t get what they like so much.
Rutgers needs better performance from the small forward and the power forward positions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RAC93
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball overwhelms Maryland Eastern Shore on Recess Day for sixth straight win
  2. 02 The Knight Report Basketball How to watch Rutgers / UNLV; Pregame Info, More: Gameday Central
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Basketball Rutgers vs. UMES: How to Watch, Starting Lineups, Rankings & More
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game