Are We Really An Embarrassment?

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
6,913
5,700
113
Spurrier was 4 games over .500 in conference play and quit mid season, Holtz had an overall losing record and was 10 games UNDER .500 in SEC play. Neither one ever made it to a major bowl game.

No doubt they were the best at SC, and that is sort of sad.


Each started low and built us up though. Taking the overall average doesnt highlight that Holtz took over a 1 win team, went winless his first year, then built us to what, 8 wins his third year?
 

DannyTree1

Sophomore
Jun 4, 2026
373
173
43
We are spending more than UGA. We are spending more than Clemson. There is no reason we shouldn't be able to win with the right coaching staff building the right culture. I just hasn't been done with any regularity.
I think it's tied up in just a small number of players.

Those teams might spread it around more allowing to get more talent overall.
 

The Reel Ess

Joined Feb 3, 2005
Feb 3, 2005
1,746
2,027
113
The word dysfunctional comes to mind. When players stop believing, they will shut it down and try not to get hurt. It's been that way here many times in the past. Money in the sport has made it worse. The NFL will take players with bad attitudes and little self-control so there's really no reason for them to act professionally. Beamer's finished even if he manages to hang on for another season. Apathy has set in.
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
25,729
3,309
113
We are spending more than UGA. We are spending more than Clemson. There is no reason we shouldn't be able to win with the right coaching staff building the right culture. I just hasn't been done with any regularity.
2 years ago, Beamer was the right coach with the right staff building the right culture. We were playoff bound in 2025, Sellers was a Heisman favorite and a number one draft pick, Harbor was going to be a superstar WR and Stewart was high first round.

Did Beamer forget how to coach?
 

Cockofdawn

Senior
Aug 16, 2009
763
509
63
2 years ago, Beamer was the right coach with the right staff building the right culture. We were playoff bound in 2025, Sellers was a Heisman favorite and a number one draft pick, Harbor was going to be a superstar WR and Stewart was high first round.

Did Beamer forget how to coach?
I am guessing these STARS came out of HIGH School better coached and prepared than they are now, No other reason IMO..
 

SCExile

Redshirt
Oct 2, 2019
1
0
0
Let's be realistic.

Neither Holtz nor Spurrier were able to sustain their OWN success.

Holtz peaked in his 3rd year and declined back to middling his final 3 years. Peaked at an end of season AP #13 in the 3rd year.
Spurrier peaked in years 5-7 at 11-2 and a post season AP #4 in year 7, and declined to p--- poor his final season.

Holtz delined to 5-7, 5-7 and 6-5
Spurrier declined to 7-6 and 3-9 (but his record that last year was 2-4 because he quit after 6 games.)
 

Cockofdawn

Senior
Aug 16, 2009
763
509
63
Let's be realistic.

Neither Holtz nor Spurrier were able to sustain their OWN success.

Holtz peaked in his 3rd year and declined back to middling his final 3 years. Peaked at an end of season AP #13 in the 3rd year.
Spurrier peaked in years 5-7 at 11-2 and a post season AP #4 in year 7, and declined to p--- poor his final season.

Holtz delined to 5-7, 5-7 and 6-5
Spurrier declined to 7-6 and 3-9 (but his record that last year was 2-4 because he quit after 6 games.)
Oh my what this squad would give to be 5-7?? I see 4 wins (right now) at best, and that includes getting one this Sat.
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
25,729
3,309
113
Let's be realistic.

Neither Holtz nor Spurrier were able to sustain their OWN success.

Holtz peaked in his 3rd year and declined back to middling his final 3 years. Peaked at an end of season AP #13 in the 3rd year.
Spurrier peaked in years 5-7 at 11-2 and a post season AP #4 in year 7, and declined to p--- poor his final season.

Holtz delined to 5-7, 5-7 and 6-5
Spurrier declined to 7-6 and 3-9 (but his record that last year was 2-4 because he quit after 6 games.)
There are lots of garnet colored glasses looking in garnet tinted rear view mirrors among gamecock fans. Unfortunately, unlike the stock market, past results do, indeed, seem to guarantee future performance in gamecock football.
 

FootballLVR

Junior
Sep 25, 2023
508
317
63
2 years ago, Beamer was the right coach with the right staff building the right culture. We were playoff bound in 2025, Sellers was a Heisman favorite and a number one draft pick, Harbor was going to be a superstar WR and Stewart was high first round.

Did Beamer forget how to coach?
He forgot how to maintain control over his team. Did he forget how to coach or did he never really know how to coach? Either way, he needs to go.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cockofdawn

Cockofdawn

Senior
Aug 16, 2009
763
509
63
He forgot how to maintain control over his team. Did he forget how to coach or did he never really know how to coach? Either way, he needs to go.
I think the stars he had came out of high school ready to play college ball, just don’t think he was able to develop them past that level!!
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
292
163
43
Holtz and Spurrier proved you can win out South Carolina. We have to quit hiring lousy coaches.
You're mentality residing in a prevoius era. You cannot pull in big recruits with big name coaches anymore.
 

SuperCock99

Junior
Jun 21, 2021
315
236
43
The biggest mistake that Carolina athletics program ever made was promoting Ray Tanner to A/D. His two H/C football hires were the two dumbest, most baffling decisions in the history of all sports. Why? Everyone pussyfoots around and wouldn’t press for an explanation. Why did you hire the guy Florida just fired for losing! Then Beamer. Because he is a nice guy, former coach, father was Virginia Tech legend and former players liked him?

I know Carolina isn’t historically a power house football program. Spurrier got it up to pare. 11 win seasons, consistently ranked. Going toe to toe with anyone. Then sure Spurrier mentally checked out and that’s not how he left it. But……… Tanner was a doofus and shouldn’t have been allowed to touch another football hire after the Muschamp situation.
 
Last edited:

Deathstar

Sophomore
Sep 6, 2026
196
159
43
We are spending more than UGA. We are spending more than Clemson. There is no reason we shouldn't be able to win with the right coaching staff building the right culture. I just hasn't been done with any regularity.
Money does not buy happiness, this rings true for us.

Are we spending wisely? $6 million for QB Sellers, was this smart? Whatever we spent on DB’s, were they a good investment? How much did we spend on the edge rusher who is suspended?

Other teams showing Beamer that smart money always beats new money.
 

Dabo's Weenie

Senior
Nov 30, 2024
896
957
93
Each started low and built us up though. Taking the overall average doesnt highlight that Holtz took over a 1 win team, went winless his first year, then built us to what, 8 wins his third year?

Eight wins in his second year.

And Stevie Wonder could see the improvement in the team during his first year. They were competitive, just not victorious.
 
GamecockCentral

Latest

  1. 01 GamecockCentral Football Recruiting Keeping up with South Carolina commitments: week 6
  2. 02 GamecockCentral Baseball Notes and takeaways from Kevin Schnall previewing fall baseball practice
  3. 03 On3 Football SEC, South Carolina announce joint one-game suspension of Dylan Stewart
  4. 04 GamecockCentral Football Grading the Gamecocks' performance in blowout loss at Alabama
  5. 05 GamecockCentral Football South Carolina falls again in FPI standings after lopsided loss to Alabama