Objectively, tonight was one of the Top 3 worst losses in modern MSU football history

Perd Hapley

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
6,820
8,250
113
Examing the full context, it might have been THE worst. 2026 Vandy, 2024 Toledo, and 2004 Maine is the list. No others come anywhere close.

Lets look at the full story here:

- Winless in conference play Vandy team at home; who should be winless overall against the P4….if not for the most boneheaded play in college football history gifting them a win over NC State.
- Program we haven’t lost to at home since 1971
- Team that lost to ARKANSAS at home.
- Last place team in the SEC….in November.
- Year 3 of our current coaching regime.
- We were literally shut out in the first half.
- 16 offensive points scored overall. Pathetic.
- 12 first downs, less than 300 yards of offense, 43 rushing yards, 2 turnovers. Awful. Worse than Croom.

Look at that Top 3 list again, folks. One guy has two of them, and it took him less than 3 seasons to do it.

It’s no secret at all what’s about to happen in the next 24 hours. There’s really no way that any another alternative could be on the table at this point. The nightmare is over.
 

CoastTrash

Senior
Aug 22, 2012
521
491
63
First year buying season tickets in maybe a decade. Took us 3 games to regret it. We are busy and nothing about a state football game is “fun”. It’s depressing and a waste of money and time. See you all next week for more punches in the gut.
 

Perd Hapley

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
6,820
8,250
113
UAB in 2004 was not a bad team.

They went 7-5, and had Roddy White at the time (who went for 123 yards and 2 TD’s against us that day). He also led the country in receiving yards that season.

The 2004 MSU team was absolutely atrocious, and it was Year 1 of Croom after the whole NCAA debacle. Still pathetic that we lost to Maine, but that UAB loss was just par for the course for the most part. I’m not even sure we were favored in that game.
 
Last edited:
Nov 16, 2005
29,771
25,475
113
UAB in 2004 was not a bad team.

They went 7-5, and had Roddy White at the time (who went for 123 yards and 2 TD’s against us that day). He also led the country in receiving yards that season.

The 2004 MSU team was absolutely atrocious, and it was Year 1 of Croom after the whole NCAA debacle. Still pathetic that we lost to Maine, but that UAB loss was just par for the course for the most part.
I was there for that game. It was an absolute trainwreck. Players out of position, bad passes, dropped balls. It was awful. Looked totally clueless.

Maine was embarrassing and State would have won but they fumbled I think twice into the endzone.

Both are terrible, awful games. I’m not arguing, I was just pointing out UAB was embarrassingly bad too.
 

Perd Hapley

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
6,820
8,250
113
I was there for that game. It was an absolute trainwreck. Players out of position, bad passes, dropped balls. It was awful. Looked totally clueless.

Maine was embarrassing and State would have won but they fumbled I think twice into the endzone.

Both are terrible, awful games. I’m not arguing, I was just pointing out UAB was embarrassingly bad too.
I got curious and went back and checked box score.

Another thing we had going against us was York starting due to Conner being hurt. Norwood went over 200 yards - at 8.4 YPC - but we still couldn’t punch it in when we got close.

IMG_2886.jpeg
 

BulldawgFan

Senior
Oct 7, 2013
368
762
93
Nobody watched. I assure you I still feel so bad for the guys that have to call our games
I know that Dave Neal has a kid pitching against LSU in fall baseball tomorrow. And Clark Lea had his 4th kid. Tells you all you need to know how crappy this game was to call.
 

MSUDC11-2.0

Heisman
Sep 29, 2022
11,259
18,403
113
We play in a serious football conference and are a totally unserious football program.

In a world where previously similarly stationed programs to us have made huge strides, we are content to make excuses for a coach that’s 3-20 and probably plan on running it back with this total loser for Year 4.

So I’m just going to assume the people in charge don’t believe we are capable of being competitive and if they don’t believe we can do better than what we’ve done, why should I? And what incentive is there for any of to support this unserious operation financially, either? There is zero return on investment with this regime.
 

horshack.sixpack

All-American
Oct 30, 2012
12,440
9,962
113
I was there for that game. It was an absolute trainwreck. Players out of position, bad passes, dropped balls. It was awful. Looked totally clueless.

Maine was embarrassing and State would have won but they fumbled I think twice into the endzone.

Both are terrible, awful games. I’m not arguing, I was just pointing out UAB was embarrassingly bad too.
To be fair, I did not see any of our players on offense block other players of ours on offense, so there’s that.
 

Perd Hapley

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
6,820
8,250
113
Those games were worse.
Agree to disagree. I was at every single one of those other games.

3-2: was just a horrible football game to watch, because both teams played poorly. Auburn wasn’t good that year, but they were still better than we were, and they at least had another conference win over Tennessee that season and some other competitive games. They were favored to win, by more than they did. Hard to say its a historically horrible loss in general when we lost to a better team and coach.

Troy Tornado game: we came into the game with the season already shot to hell in a handbasket. We were predicted as a favorite for Atlanta, and had alreadt 17ed it all up and started 1-3 and flushed it all down the toilet in a month. Jackie had what felt like a dozen games like this where we just laid an egg against an inferior opponent, and the tornado delay made everything worse by sucking any crowd energy that was left (those who stayed were treated to the joy of watching Eli and Ole Miss upset Bama on the jumbotron during the delay). This game was no better or worse than all of Jackie’s other similar debacles - 1995 NE Louisiana, 1996 La Tech, 1996 Arkansas, 1993 tie against Arkansas State, 1998 loss to a 3-8 LSU team by a score of 41-6, 2002 loss to Houston, and on and on.

2005 Tulane was just one really bad football team losing to another one. Not much else you can say. Croom sucked.

What made today worse was that the stakes were so much higher, both for the season in general and Lebby’s future. And this is a team that was supposedly better than all those other ones mentioned above. How the hell do you start 4-0 and get a win over a Top 15 team, then end up losing at home to a winless Vandy team 6 weeks later? It’s really difficult to fathom.
 

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,659
13,477
113
Agree to disagree. I was at every single one of those other games.

3-2: was just a horrible football game to watch, because both teams played poorly. Auburn wasn’t good that year, but they were still better than we were, and they at least had another conference win over Tennessee that season and some other competitive games. They were favored to win, by more than they did. Hard to say its a historically horrible loss in general when we lost to a better team and coach.

Troy Tornado game: we came into the game with the season already shot to hell in a handbasket. We were predicted as a favorite for Atlanta, and had alreadt 17ed it all up and started 1-3 and flushed it all down the toilet in a month. Jackie had what felt like a dozen games like this where we just laid an egg against an inferior opponent, and the tornado delay made everything worse by sucking any crowd energy that was left (those who stayed were treated to the joy of watching Eli and Ole Miss upset Bama on the jumbotron during the delay). This game was no better or worse than all of Jackie’s other similar debacles - 1995 NE Louisiana, 1996 La Tech, 1996 Arkansas, 1993 tie against Arkansas State, 1998 loss to a 3-8 LSU team by a score of 41-6, 2002 loss to Houston, and on and on.

2005 Tulane was just one really bad football team losing to another one. Not much else you can say. Croom sucked.

What made today worse was that the stakes were so much higher, both for the season in general and Lebby’s future. And this is a team that was supposedly better than all those other ones mentioned above. How the hell do you start 4-0 and get a win over a Top 15 team, then end up losing at home to a winless Vandy team 6 weeks later? It’s really difficult to fathom.
Just stop
 
  • Like
Reactions: sandwolf.sixpack

bolddogge

All-Conference
Aug 23, 2012
1,244
1,479
113
First year buying season tickets in maybe a decade. Took us 3 games to regret it. We are busy and nothing about a state football game is “fun”. It’s depressing and a waste of money and time. See you all next week for more punches in the gut.
I'll be there getting the same.
 

AT4 Dawg

Senior
Sep 18, 2012
503
652
93
Examing the full context, it might have been THE worst. 2026 Vandy, 2024 Toledo, and 2004 Maine is the list. No others come anywhere close.

Lets look at the full story here:

- Winless in conference play Vandy team at home; who should be winless overall against the P4….if not for the most boneheaded play in college football history gifting them a win over NC State.
- Program we haven’t lost to at home since 1971
- Team that lost to ARKANSAS at home.
- Last place team in the SEC….in November.
- Year 3 of our current coaching regime.
- We were literally shut out in the first half.
- 16 offensive points scored overall. Pathetic.
- 12 first downs, less than 300 yards of offense, 43 rushing yards, 2 turnovers. Awful. Worse than Croom.

Look at that Top 3 list again, folks. One guy has two of them, and it took him less than 3 seasons to do it.

It’s no secret at all what’s about to happen in the next 24 hours. There’s really no way that any another alternative could be on the table at this point. The nightmare is over.
Maine
Toledo
2008 Egg Bowl.

Short memory. It was bad but good grief tonight wasn’t nowhere near “top whatever” kind of loss.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DesotoCountyDawg

L4Dawg

All-American
Oct 27, 2016
12,203
8,659
113
Examing the full context, it might have been THE worst. 2026 Vandy, 2024 Toledo, and 2004 Maine is the list. No others come anywhere close.

Lets look at the full story here:

- Winless in conference play Vandy team at home; who should be winless overall against the P4….if not for the most boneheaded play in college football history gifting them a win over NC State.
- Program we haven’t lost to at home since 1971
- Team that lost to ARKANSAS at home.
- Last place team in the SEC….in November.
- Year 3 of our current coaching regime.
- We were literally shut out in the first half.
- 16 offensive points scored overall. Pathetic.
- 12 first downs, less than 300 yards of offense, 43 rushing yards, 2 turnovers. Awful. Worse than Croom.

Look at that Top 3 list again, folks. One guy has two of them, and it took him less than 3 seasons to do it.

It’s no secret at all what’s about to happen in the next 24 hours. There’s really no way that any another alternative could be on the table at this point. The nightmare is over.
Not even freaking close. How old are you?
 

Drebin

Heisman
Aug 22, 2012
23,126
29,154
113
I got curious and went back and checked box score.

Another thing we had going against us was York starting due to Conner being hurt. Norwood went over 200 yards - at 8.4 YPC - but we still couldn’t punch it in when we got close.

View attachment 1522333
LOL when Will Prosser was your leading WR, what could go wrong? That's a stat only possible in the croom error.
 

uptowndawg

All-Conference
Jul 15, 2010
2,266
1,106
113
Examing the full context, it might have been THE worst. 2026 Vandy, 2024 Toledo, and 2004 Maine is the list. No others come anywhere close.

Lets look at the full story here:

- Winless in conference play Vandy team at home; who should be winless overall against the P4….if not for the most boneheaded play in college football history gifting them a win over NC State.
- Program we haven’t lost to at home since 1971
- Team that lost to ARKANSAS at home.
- Last place team in the SEC….in November.
- Year 3 of our current coaching regime.
- We were literally shut out in the first half.
- 16 offensive points scored overall. Pathetic.
- 12 first downs, less than 300 yards of offense, 43 rushing yards, 2 turnovers. Awful. Worse than Croom.

Look at that Top 3 list again, folks. One guy has two of them, and it took him less than 3 seasons to do it.

It’s no secret at all what’s about to happen in the next 24 hours. There’s really no way that any another alternative could be on the table at this point. The nightmare is over.
I would argue that today doesn’t make the list because half of our fan base wouldn’t have been able to tell you who we played or what time we kicked off if you polled them yesterday.

but maybe that’s another point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Darryl Steight

uptowndawg

All-Conference
Jul 15, 2010
2,266
1,106
113
Goat mentioned it above but that 2008 La tech sucked more than today.

you could argue that today was top ten but top 3? Kiss my ***.
 

Pak Drescott

All-Conference
Dec 10, 2018
559
1,257
93
We've had a lot of bad losses in our history. Is it defined by how bad the opponent was that beat us? If so then probably Maine

Is it defined by how high our expectations were going into the game vs how bad we got our butts whipped? Might need to throw the Bama #webelieve 8-0 game in there
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blitz83

She Mate Me

Heisman
Dec 7, 2008
15,461
15,154
113
If Lebby is very soon not our coach, I will consider this possibly the most
fortuitous loss in Mississippi State history.


I was a stealth Vandy fan in that 2nd half (yes I feel dirty)
 

Blitz83

Sophomore
Feb 6, 2019
150
115
43
If Lebby is very soon not our coach, I will consider this possibly the most
fortuitous loss in Mississippi State history.


I was a stealth Vandy fan in that 2nd half (yes I feel dirty)
Felt like Croom's last game - let OM finish this.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Sanfrisco Magee's "detail" and consistency carrying Mississippi State offense through tough times
  2. 02 Maroon and White Points of Focus from Jeff Lebby in Week 12 media availability
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football What Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby said about Sunday staff changes
  4. 04 On3 Football Over 35% of Power Four starting quarterbacks missed games with injuries in 2026
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Sunday Notebook: Auburn 41-9 Mississippi State