So, reading Nick Saban's comments on 24 team CFP

skip dog

All-Conference
Nov 15, 2005
1,595
1,460
93
and he says there are not 24 teams that can compete for the CFP Natty made me think of a few things:
-oversaturation of games, and lower in person attendance of games
-what, once every 15 years there MIGHT be a "Cinderella Story"
-is there a team physically capable of enduring that season and playoff gauntlet
-at what point are you actually devaluing your product ?

I love college football, and look forward to it every year, but at the same time, every season needs an ending point.......
 

BoDawg.sixpack

All-Conference
Feb 5, 2010
5,982
3,773
113
Saban has been against it since the idea was first conceived. But with the amount of money some of these men are now making, it doesn't surprise me this season is about to get longer. Simple econ 101 says if you get more you should produce more.

Also, college football rosters are larger than NFL rosters so there's really no excuse not to have the depth to go 16 games.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hatfieldms

mcdawg22

Heisman
Sep 18, 2004
13,785
12,443
113
Saban is the only ESPN employee that they can’t get to and force the talking points on. I get it, it makes it more likely for us to be part of the playoff, but we will not be a serious contender for a title as a 20 seed. Essentially what you have done is take a team going to the Outback bowl, put them in Columbus Ohio in a game where tickets are going to be expensive and hard for visitors to get, in a cold weather city, against a team they are likely to lose against. Yes, I realize there are stakes but it’s just bowl games until you win the last one. This year I can be happy that Ole Miss and LSU werr eliminated last weekend, next season that is not the case.
 
  • Like
Reactions: skip dog and patdog

Maroon13

All-Conference
Sep 29, 2022
4,428
4,638
113
Well Miami was a 10 seed last year. But the move to 24 teams is a good one because it keeps teams, players and fans engaged.

The bowls are dead. Nobody is interested in bowls. This keeps hope alive for 24 teams even if it's futile for most.
 
Last edited:

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,425
33,256
113
Saban has been against it since the idea was first conceived. But with the amount of money some of these men are now making, it doesn't surprise me this season is about to get longer. Simple econ 101 says if you get more you should produce more.

Also, college football rosters are larger than NFL rosters so there's really no excuse not to have the depth to go 16 games.
Colleges don’t have any more players who are ready to & can play than nfl teams do. And nfl teams can pick up players mid season from practice squads, trades, waivers, etc.
 

Dawgzilla2

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2022
2,862
3,322
113
Tebow said it best. The one thing that made college football different from every other sport was the importance of each game in the regular season. It wasn't just the big rivalries that mattered. It was how the teams performed week in and out, and even how the lesser teams in a conference performed. And upsets weren't just fun for the victors, they could wreck the other team's season.

The 12 team playoff already took some of that away, but the 24 team playoff kills it. College football is just like every other sport now.
 

Tractorman

All-Conference
Mar 15, 2009
1,344
1,304
113
24 team playoff is great. Everyone here will be watching it. I do believe the teams toward the bottom have a chance to win it. If announced today, here is the bracket:

I could see teams 17-22 all making a legit run.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maroon13

MississippiTexan

Sophomore
Jun 11, 2014
149
135
43
Tebow said it best. The one thing that made college football different from every other sport was the importance of each game in the regular season. It wasn't just the big rivalries that mattered. It was how the teams performed week in and out, and even how the lesser teams in a conference performed. And upsets weren't just fun for the victors, they could wreck the other team's season.

The 12 team playoff already took some of that away, but the 24 team playoff kills it. College football is just like every other sport now.
Tebow can say that because he played on one of the few teams that every game of a season did matter because they actually had a shot at winning every game. But overall, Tebow is wrong. Any given year there are only about 10 teams at the start of the year who can realistically think that, but for all others pre-playoff era, their season was over by game 6 and the rest of the season was meaningless other than do we make a crappy bowl or which crappy bowl do we get. The playoff makes way more teams seasons meaningful for way longer, which is better.
 
  • Like
Reactions: thedoubledeuce

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,659
13,477
113
Tebow said it best. The one thing that made college football different from every other sport was the importance of each game in the regular season. It wasn't just the big rivalries that mattered. It was how the teams performed week in and out, and even how the lesser teams in a conference performed. And upsets weren't just fun for the victors, they could wreck the other team's season.

The 12 team playoff already took some of that away, but the 24 team playoff kills it. College football is just like every other sport now.
Tebow can say that because he played on one of the few teams that every game of a season did matter because they actually had a shot at winning every game. But overall, Tebow is wrong. Any given year there are only about 10 teams at the start of the year who can realistically think that, but for all others pre-playoff era, their season was over by game 6 and the rest of the season was meaningless other than do we make a crappy bowl or which crappy bowl do we get. The playoff makes way more teams seasons meaningful for way longer, which is better.
Tebow is right and wrong. The old way worked because the bowls mattered. You always had a reason to keep playing, even if you were say, 3-5 or whatever. That is the only reasonable argument for clinging to the old system.

I'm really not sure when or where they quit mattering, but they certainly did. Seems like it was around when Jadaveon Clowney kinda quit his junior year. And then obviously the 4-team playoff accelerated the demise.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dawgzilla2

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,659
13,477
113
24 team playoff is great. Everyone here will be watching it. I do believe the teams toward the bottom have a chance to win it. If announced today, here is the bracket:

I could see teams 17-22 all making a legit run.
Especially now with the parity that has been introduced.
 

Drebin

Heisman
Aug 22, 2012
23,126
29,154
113
and he says there are not 24 teams that can compete for the CFP Natty made me think of a few things:
-oversaturation of games, and lower in person attendance of games
-what, once every 15 years there MIGHT be a "Cinderella Story"
-is there a team physically capable of enduring that season and playoff gauntlet
-at what point are you actually devaluing your product ?

I love college football, and look forward to it every year, but at the same time, every season needs an ending point.......
There's always going to be a cinderella I think. This is where the SEC is at a disadvantage because some of those teams will be more beat up by playoff time where an ACC or B1G school will be healthier and have an advantage. But with the parity in college football and the discrepancy across conferences in quality/strength, there are going to be big upsets.

I mean, it happened last year - Indiana was a good team but they also played a super light schedule. And some of the better teams they might have faced in the playoff got knocked out early (thinking about Georgia, for example).
 
  • Like
Reactions: skip dog

MississippiTexan

Sophomore
Jun 11, 2014
149
135
43
Tebow is right and wrong. The old way worked because the bowls mattered. You always had a reason to keep playing, even if you were say, 3-5 or whatever. That is the only reasonable argument for clinging to the old system.

I'm really not sure when or where they quit mattering, but they certainly did. Seems like it was around when Jadaveon Clowney kinda quit his junior year. And then obviously the 4-team playoff accelerated the demise.
It happened when the players stopped caring about playing in them and started opting out. And they started that before all the transferring happened. I just got worse when they started transferring. Fans would watch their team play the entire season, watch them earn a bowl invite and then have to watch the second or third stringers play in the bowl against the other teams second and third string.
 

00Dawg

Senior
Nov 10, 2009
3,355
621
93
Tebow is right and wrong. The old way worked because the bowls mattered. You always had a reason to keep playing, even if you were say, 3-5 or whatever. That is the only reasonable argument for clinging to the old system.

I'm really not sure when or where they quit mattering, but they certainly did. Seems like it was around when Jadaveon Clowney kinda quit his junior year. And then obviously the 4-team playoff accelerated the demise.
Yeah, once players began skipping bowls for the draft, the cracks were showing as changes in culture didn't mesh with giving your all for your alma mater anymore. I'm going to forever pretend that wouldn't have worsened and that the playoff is what killed the golden goose. I'll always look at the BCS era as the peak of college football, while acknowledging we should've stopped the bowl growth somewhere short of the 35 we had in 2010.
 

Dawgzilla2

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2022
2,862
3,322
113
Tebow can say that because he played on one of the few teams that every game of a season did matter because they actually had a shot at winning every game. But overall, Tebow is wrong. Any given year there are only about 10 teams at the start of the year who can realistically think that, but for all others pre-playoff era, their season was over by game 6 and the rest of the season was meaningless other than do we make a crappy bowl or which crappy bowl do we get. The playoff makes way more teams seasons meaningful for way longer, which is better.
You must not have been there. Individual games mattered, even if your team sucked. The National Championship was only for a handful of programs to worry about, but most of the other fans still had a reason to go to games. And for smaller programs getting to that "crappy bowl" was worth working for. It all meant something.
 

MississippiTexan

Sophomore
Jun 11, 2014
149
135
43
You must not have been there. Individual games mattered, even if your team sucked. The National Championship was only for a handful of programs to worry about, but most of the other fans still had a reason to go to games. And for smaller programs getting to that "crappy bowl" was worth working for. It all meant something.
I was most definitely there. Graduated in 2003. But you are wrong, for most of the teams most of the games did not "matter" or at least in the sense that Tebow was meaning they mattered. The only bowls that truly mattered were the New Years bowls and the national championship and you new pretty early in the season whether you had a chance to go to one or not. All the other bowls meant so much that players started opting out of them and that was before all the transfers and the playoffs. The bowls stopped meaning anything quite some time ago. Once the players stopped caring, so did everyone else, meaning if you weren't going to the national champion ship or one of the big bowls no one care about the rest of the games in the season. Now, the bowls mean absolutely nothing and the only thing that brings any semblance of relevance to the games is the playoffs. So an expanded playoff is a good thing and brings relevance to more teams games.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State at UCF: How, Where, and When to Watch Men's Basketball on the road
  2. 02 Maroon and White Football Sanfrisco Magee's "detail" and consistency carrying Mississippi State offense through tough times
  3. 03 Maroon and White Points of Focus from Jeff Lebby in Week 12 media availability
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football What Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby said about Sunday staff changes
  5. 05 On3 Football Over 35% of Power Four starting quarterbacks missed games with injuries in 2026