I don’t envy Selmon one bit!

pacificnwdawg

Freshman
Oct 31, 2013
32
50
18
I will concede that ZS is in a tough spot. I suspect we all agree that if KT1 were not in play that ZS would have likely fired Layup Lebby already. I think we can all also agree that any decision to fire Lebby must at least consider the ramifications on KT1.

4 weeks ago, despite what my eyes have told me about Lebby’s ineptitude in year 1 &2, I would have said that keeping Lebby to keep KT1 was the right decision. I would have even told you that the first 4 games of this year prove that a healthy KT1 can thrive in spite of Lebby’s poor coaching. If we had been even mildly competitive(or better coached) over the last 4 weeks, I think the fans would have still been content with the “keep lebby to keep KT1 “ plan. That should all be out then window now. For two weeks in a row, knowing what we needed to do to salvage our season, we have turned in our worst performances on both the field and the sideline. That’s on coaching and leadership. . We have been embarrassed at home in front of a bigger crowd than this team deserves, by teams that have been getting embarrassed by pretty much everyone else in the league. And not because of how well the other teams performed but because of how poorly we played and were coached. All while Mr. Coach Speak insults us with his diatribes about layups, playing clean, creating chunks, and making the easy thing easy. The fact that he can’t ever muster up a heartfelt Elko style explanation/ apology is infuriating . Bottomline, He is our CEO and he has failed in EVERY aspect of what he has been hired to do: recruiting - NO, roster management -17 NO, game management- holy 17 NO, build engagement with the fans - NOPE, build a staff to improve players - NADA, Wins on the fields- LOL.

I fear that the administration will stick to the “keep lebby to keep KT1 plan” because they think KT1 will be our “build it and they will come” moment. That recruits will flock from around the country to play with KT1. Theoretically, that could work, especially now that we have demonstrated we are are “all in” financially in 27’. God, I want this to work so badly; however, what I think we will actually find is that recruits will want to play for Lebby LESS than they WANT to play with KT1. A rising KT1 tide should theoretically lift all boats, but not if Captain AHAB is manning the helm.

ZS knows what should be done. Let’s see if he has the stones and/or the mandate from the Administration / money men.


TLDR = ZS is in a tough spot, but our program is too far gone to think KT1 and money will overcome Lebby. It’s disappointing, but is obvious what ZS has to do. HAILSTATE !
 

Dawg1976

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
8,518
3,095
113
It’s not in Selmon’s hands. It’s in the cigar boy’s hand. If they want Lebby gone he will be gone. But I’m afraid nothing will be done this year for fear of losing KT. You can bet there is an out of the contract if Lebby is not the coach. Doesn’t necessarily mean he will leave but I’m sure there is that option.
 

1msucub

Senior
Oct 3, 2004
2,209
794
113
It’s not in Selmon’s hands. It’s in the cigar boy’s hand. If they want Lebby gone he will be gone. But I’m afraid nothing will be done this year for fear of losing KT. You can bet there is an out of the contract if Lebby is not the coach. Doesn’t necessarily mean he will leave but I’m sure there is that option.
If we put that in the contract then EVERYBODY needs to be fired. I'm as excited (I think) about KT as everybody else, but we can't mortgage the program because of one player, no matter how good he is. Especially since we've wasted at least half of his eligibility here. Every day we keep Lebby is another month in the ditch. We are historically and generationally awful.
 

triton28

Junior
Dec 18, 2009
1,476
264
78
Mullen would quickly identify that K Taylor isn’t tough enough or smart enough to be an SEC quarterback and would quickly move him to WR, imo.
Quite possibly the dumbest thing I’ve seen written on this board in my entire life.

edited: change “this message board” to “any message board”
 
Last edited:

Indndawg

Senior
Nov 16, 2005
7,277
791
113
Mullen would quickly identify that K Taylor isn’t tough enough or smart enough to be an SEC quarterback and would almost immediately move him to WR, imo. Every position should be up for grabs with new staff, nonetheless.
Mullen and staff would hopefully work with him and make him more shatter proof. Leb's guys are soft
 
  • Like
Reactions: Corby.sixpack

Baddog11

All-Conference
Aug 28, 2013
4,470
3,490
113
Quite possibly the dumbest thing I’ve seen written on this board in my entire life.
Same things were said to me when I called for Dak to replace Tyler Russell .
Same things were said to me when I called for KT to replace Blake Shapen.
Now I’m here calling for Derek Garcia to replace KT.
we’ll revisit this post in a few years and see who was right.
 

The Cooterpoot

Heisman
Sep 29, 2022
7,717
13,505
113
Too much money in play in college football now and those people throwing it around at State need to require some ROI in a hurry or ***** about to go off the rails, through the ditch, and into a refinery with the fans, It's about to explode
 

stateu1

All-Conference
Mar 21, 2016
3,206
1,240
113
Nope. Can’t say i can blame them, though. Have you heard him speak?

hey, you come msu . We do good. Me promise me not hurt next year. Me maybe winner Heisman, you come miss state. When
Gotta give you credit for staying with your schtick
 

downwarddawg

Sophomore
Mar 3, 2008
527
109
43
Quite possibly the dumbest thing I’ve seen written on this board in my entire life
Mullen would quickly identify that K Taylor isn’t tough enough or smart enough to be an SEC quarterback and would almost immediately move him to WR, imo. Every position should be up for grabs with new staff, nonetheless.
No Man. Thats the opposite of what Mullen would do. Dak never ran the ball in 2015. Mullen had developed him into a true NFL QB from a run first QB. Dan would make Kamario look even better than what we've seen from him this season.
 

Seinfeld

All-American
Nov 30, 2006
11,769
8,215
113
ZS put himself where he is. Never hire buddies and maybe don't let a 19 year old run your football program.
As a person, I like Selmon. As an AD, I’m still just not sure

When your crowning achievement for the year is that you raised enough money to pay a **** ton of money to a player that we already had, forgive me if I don’t gush over the alleged incredible job that he’s done here.

From a results perspective, Selmon’s tenure here has been one of the more forgettable eras in MSU history
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bullldawg78

BossDawg78

All-Conference
Jan 25, 2015
4,075
1,397
113
Mullen would quickly identify that K Taylor isn’t tough enough or smart enough to be an SEC quarterback and would almost immediately move him to WR, imo. Every position should be up for grabs with new staff, nonetheless.

Nah. I kinda get where you're coming from as far as KT and his "fragility," but he's definitely got the smarts to be a remarkable, well-above average SEC QB. Mullen would have KT running on all cylinders and use him in a way to help minimize injury, and he would probably have significantly better offensive linemen also. It couldn't get much worse anyway. I'd love to see what Mullen could do with KT.
 

msstatelp1

All-Conference
Aug 21, 2012
2,141
1,374
113
As a person, I like Selmon. As an AD, I’m still just not sure

When your crowning achievement for the year is that you raised enough money to pay a **** ton of money to a player that we already had, forgive me if I don’t gush over the alleged incredible job that he’s done here.

From a results perspective, Selmon’s tenure here has been one of the more forgettable eras in MSU history
Other than Byrne have we had any that were memorable for anything good?
 

msstatelp1

All-Conference
Aug 21, 2012
2,141
1,374
113
Sure, because I’m not only talking about football. Final 4 and SEC championship game under Templeton. #1 in the nation in football under Byrne. CWS title under Cohen, and plenty of athletic success under Stricklin.

And then there’s Selmon…
Gotcha, I was thinking in terms of football only
 
  • Like
Reactions: Seinfeld

BossDawg78

All-Conference
Jan 25, 2015
4,075
1,397
113
I wouldn't want Selmon's job either, but if I was AD I'd be so damn pissed at the way Lebby is handling/has handled things I'd have no choice but tell him to start packing, friend or not. The AD has a job to do and he shouldn't be buddy-buddy with the coaches anyway, and he is paying Lebby way too much damn money to have him poke around and make excuses about layups and not winning because your starting QB is hurt.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Points of Focus from Jeff Lebby in Week 12 media availability
  2. 02 Maroon and White Football What Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby said about Sunday staff changes
  3. 03 On3 Football Over 35% of Power Four starting quarterbacks missed games with injuries in 2026
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Sunday Notebook: Auburn 41-9 Mississippi State
  5. 05 Rivals Football Recruiting Biggest rankings risers in the updated 2027 Rivals300 rankings