That season was "great" in context to what it should have been. All the top recruits already signed elsewhere (1 in the top 50 unsigned at the time of his hire), The portal already picked clean, Empty roster sans Travis Perry, no coaching staff. Year one was build the plane while flying it. I think almost every level headed fan expected it to be a building year, some short comings, nothing spectacular, but foundational for the future.
It was not a "great" year compared against other UK historical years. Some super elite wins, some baffling losses, and inconsistent play.
I mean there was a point where Amari Williams was our best option at point guard and we were still winning games (Butler out, Krissa out, Robinson out, and Travis Perry nearly unplayable). That would be like us asking Zyon Hawthorne to start at point for us without Zoom, Wilkins, or Williams out there. But with or without injuries, the fanbase needed that Sweet 16 to get over the heartbreak from the end of the Cal years and poor tournament outcomes. It was... hope... The hype going into year two was gaining momentum, people were starting to see the vision.
Then it turned out to be fools gold. I think Pope expected the brand to be more helpful in recruiting elite players and it was only good enough, with him at the helm, to be a bargaining chip and hat on the table. It gets us 90 percent of the way there, and he can't finish the last 10.
I don't think Penny Hardaway is a good coach. I don't think he's a stellar recruiter. But listening to his interview after they beat down Louisville was pretty revealing. They said Memphis only gave him $7 million for NIL. He had to put in $2.5 million himself out of his pocket to field the team HE WANTED. He stopped recruiting or talking to guys concerned about money or playing time. He went after what he called winners. Guys that were undersized, overlooked, had a chip on their shoulder, super physical, dawgs. They've beaten Iowa St, VCU, and UofL so far (lost to Vandy) with a 5'10" point guard averaging 24 pts a game who is as tough as they come on both sides of the ball. Small budget teams have to do this. I think Pope can't see the forest for the trees. They spend so much effort going after the top 20 players (high school) and don't even look for the dawgs. We got Mason Williams because we wanted his Dad on staff. An overlooked 3-4 star depending on which service you looked at, outside the top 100. He's raw, but he's got the most energy and hustle on the entire team. We certainly need the elite studs (2 probably each year), but give me those all heart with just enough athleticism to be dangerous guys who will almost kill themselves to win a game. We loved Pitino for findings guys like that, especially his early teams. Even Cal's better teams had glue guys that were more heart than talent. I honestly think our NIL budget makes us turn our nose up to the guys who are bargains for what they bring to the table. Then they blow up and we have to overpay to try and get them out of the portal later.
I think there is a reason the Athletic Department keeps making hires in the "player development and player evaluation" areas, with random different names for the men's basketball team. The previous staff (some of which are gone now and rightfully replaced with Mo and Aboyo) can't evaluate talent on it's own and just throw offers at the ON3 rankings top 25. Then throw money at them. Recruiting here is comical.