2026 NCAA Championship Session IV Thread

Corby2

All-American
Jul 14, 2025
3,418
7,338
113
He hesitated. He should have called it as soon as the hip hit the mat not when PJ had rotated back out front. Then the challenge wouldn’t have mattered as much. He called it a TD, which was correct, his timing sucked a dhe was stuck in no man’s land to make a decision and he stopped the action.
The whole sequence is reviewed when it was given doesn't matter. The booth scores the sequence
 

Cali_Nittany1

All-Conference
Dec 11, 2019
667
2,845
93
With a decision win tomorrow, Haines would finish his career tied at #26 on the all-time NCAA tourney scoring list with CStar and Steveson (not counting 5th year results).

You may ask, how would Levi be tied with 4x champ CStar with going 2-1-3-1. The answer is bonus. Levi has almost as much bonus just in this tournament (6.5) as CStar had in his first 4 tournaments combined (7).

Haines with a TF would move him up the list to #23. A half point ahead of Lee Kemp and Tom Brands.
 

The Pitchfork Rebel

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2021
566
1,328
93
Barr may stall Merrill's lazy butt out. Taylor getting all the calls these days it feels. Good for them, but the more time goes on the more I'm going to feel okay not liking him and his teams. Still love the guy but he's got some boring guys, some dbags, and some serious luck of the official these days.

Once Taylor left, he became the opponent. All the slobbering over him makes him the enemy-well that and his morphing into a triad of Ryan, Eggum and Manning.
 

The Pitchfork Rebel

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2021
566
1,328
93
I hate that the ref in PJs match will have me pulling for Antrell tomorrow night. Cant believe that f'n prick did this to me...

Nailed it. I really want to see Taylor do his usual cheerleader splits for six and a half minutes and then get a TD to seal it. I surely don't want to hear how Okie State has guaranteed four-timers until next season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: johnstownsteel

El_Jefe

Heisman
Oct 11, 2021
3,270
12,869
113
Dean Heil says hello
This always cracks me up.

 

El_Jefe

Heisman
Oct 11, 2021
3,270
12,869
113
I appreciate the comment. But if anything, I'm looking to cut back on my reffing (I do more than just wrestling). I missed a chunk of this year's wrestling season when I went to Hawaii, and didn't mind it. I have two younger grandkids, and scores of places I want to travel to. So I'm trying to map out a way to do enough reffing to still be good at it, but to also spend more time with my grandkids, and more time traveling. It's a challenge, as I'm used to reffing all the time (like almost every day), in multiple seasons, but I've done my time. Plus, I've been invited to become a college ref in other sports that I ref, but while I came close a few different times, I kind of like reffing within an hour of my house (usually less). College refs get paid a good bit more, but they also travel a great deal more than I care to do. I used to travel within a multiple state region to ref tournaments, but now I only consider tournaments that are close to my home. Besides, while I'm in great shape for my age, I'm on the downside of my reffing career. I'll leave the opportunity to move up to the college ranks to younger refs.
The 157 refs cut back on their reffing while on the mat. So it's still an opportunity for you.
 

Tom McAndrew

BWI Staff
Staff member
Oct 27, 2021
77,340
63,900
113
Team Race After Session IV

PlaceTeamScoreFinalistsAlive in Consolations
1PSU15362
2Oklahoma St.111.542
3Nebraska83.514
4Iowa8215
5Ohio St.77.522
6Stanford5913
7Iowa St.5111
8Michigan4803
9Minnesota39.511
10NC St.3911
11Virginia Tech3502
12Wyoming31.501
13Arizona St.3001
14Missouri26.501
15Illinois2501

At this point, PSU and Oklahoma St. are the only teams still in the running for the team title.

PSU's max potential is 206
OSU's max potential is 159.5

Max potential assumes that every one of your wrestlers still alive win all their remaining matches, and pin their opponent -- something that is not happening (especially for teams with multiple wrestlers still alive).
 

a_mshaffer

Senior
Dec 8, 2014
334
488
63
Exactly. PJ had the cradle locked and Robideau down on the mat. And there's no "reaction time" here. PJ had the cradle locked and had Robideau on his side for several seconds. Robideau did get PJ's leg, but he lost that momentarily (to get it back later), but PJ had the cradle locked throughout. This was just a horrible, horrible review. I'm fine with the mat ref. He gave plenty of time for reaction time and he justifiably stopped the action in sudden victory because the takedown was clear. Not sure what those refs in the review room were looking at or discussing. This is horrible. I've seen plenty of ridiculous calls in wrestling, but this was just inexcusable, cost PJ a national title (come on, he wasn't losing to Taylor after EASILY majoring him two weeks ago) and changed the team score considerably (not that it will end up mattering).
still...the ref could had held his whistle and see what happens,,, knowing PSU could challenge if necessary. sort of what the nfl does now... not blow the whistle unless positive because the play can be reviewed. now that reaction time is a big thing, the rule book, as Tom states, needs to change
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheRedandtheBlue

gimb14

All-American
May 3, 2022
3,979
7,218
113
Team Race After Session IV

PlaceTeamScoreFinalistsAlive in Consolations
1PSU15362
2Oklahoma St.111.542
3Nebraska83.514
4Iowa8215
5Ohio St.77.522
6Stanford5913
7Iowa St.5111
8Michigan4803
9Minnesota39.511
10NC St.3911
11Virginia Tech3502
12Wyoming31.501
13Arizona St.3001
14Missouri26.501
15Illinois2501

At this point, PSU and Oklahoma St. are the only teams still in the running for the team title.

PSU's max potential is 206
OSU's max potential is 159.5

Max potential assumes that every one of your wrestlers still alive win all their remaining matches, and pin their opponent -- something that is not happening (especially for teams with multiple wrestlers still alive).
Dude, stop using pswc. They haven’t been right all tournament.


Penn State 153
Oklahoma State 111.5
Nebraska 90.5
Iowa 81
Ohio State 77.5
Stanford 58
Iowa State 52
Michigan 48
Minnesota 39.5
NC State 37
 

CTStall

Senior
Oct 24, 2020
270
680
93
I addressed this earlier.

In college (and HS; that was changed @ 2 years ago to match college rules), in sudden victory, you make the call to stop the match when points are attained by one of the wrestlers. The ONLY exception is if the defensive wrestler is in near-fall criteria. If they are, so as not to disadvantage the offensive wrestler's team from picking up bonus points, you don't stop the match. If a pin is attained, then you stop it then. If the defensive wrestler goes out of near-fall criteria, you stop it then.

As Robideau was not in near-fall criteria when the ref determined that a TD had been attained by Duke, he would have been wrong to not blow the whistle, and let the match continue.
I didn't know that and did not see your post. Thank you for the correction.
Seems to me the rules committee is making the refs job harder. With reaction rule, riding time stopped on legs and taking away finishing moves that involve a potential pin. The committee should use the" KISS" coaching term. "Keep It Stupid Simple". Years ago when a coach would use the term it was " Keep It Simple,Stupid". Probably frowned upon now. I was directed once by a person not to call conditioning drill ,"Suicides"🤨
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: TheRedandtheBlue

Fatwoodchuck

Senior
Oct 19, 2023
392
570
93
My HS coach used to tell us that if you perfect just one move from neutral, top, and bottom, you’ll win most of your matches. You don’t have to be fancy. Just be really really good in fundamentals and be perfect on simple moves.
That's what the Brands teach. It still works just not as well as it used to.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LB99

creamery freak

All-Conference
Jul 26, 2014
355
1,193
93
Davino showed that Blaze needs to add to his arsenal. The snap down, misdirections, go behinds aren't cutting it. I know Blaze has lived on that and he shouldn't toss it but needs to add more. Plenty of time this offseason to fine tune some stuff and work on some new approaches for his attacks
There was a time when RBY had trouble with DeSanto, but that changed the following season. Let's hope that’s the same with Blaze and Davino.
 

Lyons212

Senior
Mar 9, 2017
113
427
63
Nobody wants to hear it, but '28 is probably going to get interesting.

I'm as bewildered as everyone else about the PJ match. Horrible officiating, but I thought Duke was going to walk through Robideau and he just didn't. The way he looked through Big-10's and the first 3 rounds, I was Messenbrink/Barr certain that he was going to be in the finals. Sucks that him and Blaze finish the season having only lost in TB; hopefully it's a lesson learned.

Nobody wants to hear it, but '28 is probably going to get interesting.

I'm as bewildered as everyone else about the PJ match. Horrible officiating, but I thought Duke was going to walk through Robideau and he just didn't. The way he looked through Big-10's and the first 3 rounds, I was Messenbrink/Barr certain that he was going to be in the finals. Sucks that him and Blaze finish the season having only lost in TB; hopefully it's a lesson learned.
Unfortunately Duke forgot the valuable lesson he learned when he lost to Taylor in the Nebraska dual, do not let the opponent dictate the pace. Duke was more than willing to play Robideu's grab the fingers game and thus could not get any offense initiated. Certainly it did not help that the refs allowed Robideau to play that game and not hit him with stalling calls. What happened in OT is criminal. Again, if Duke dictates the pace, he wins. He did not and that allowed the ref to be a factor to decide the match. Painful lesson to re-learn.
 

Potterlion

Senior
Jan 25, 2011
182
711
93
still...the ref could had held his whistle and see what happens,,, knowing PSU could challenge if necessary. sort of what the nfl does now... not blow the whistle unless positive because the play can be reviewed. now that reaction time is a big thing, the rule book, as Tom states, needs to change

I suppose he could have done whatever he wanted, but he'd be going against what is and has been protocol for sudden victory. Tom McAndrew has explained perfectly that unless the defensive wrestler is in near-fall criteria, the match is to be stopped immediately when the offensive wrestler gains control and has a takedown, which PJ absolutely DID. The mat ref didn't fail here in any way, shape or form, the review booth blew it. PJ won, that's all there is to it. Doesn't matter about the interlaced fingers or stalling all match, doesn't matter that some PSU fans claim PJ didn't look his best, PJ WON, full stop, end of story. And PJ would have won tonight too. Bastards robbed PJ of a national title and they robbed Penn State of a larger advantage in the team race. I presume that there are closed door meetings after the NCAAs where the refs look at controversial calls, critique themselves, etc. etc., but that just doesn't seem like enough here. The NCAA and these refs owe PJ Duke a public apology.
 

Fatwoodchuck

Senior
Oct 19, 2023
392
570
93
Lets keep things in perspective here ladies and gentleman. Duke and Blaze are true freshmen who have had a hell of a season going right out of the gate. 133 was the toughest weight in the field this year, and Duke beat the returning national finalist, and the number one ranked wrestler at one point this year. Their season is not over yet and its time to put that behind them and get the next best thing. If they let it linger like we are, it could cost them and the team (not the championship but the record).
Perspective is one had a good match that if Davino would have lost would have been because of a BS missed call and Duke lost because of a missed BS call. It truly, luckily worked out for Davino, Duke got screwed. Hopefully it makes him even more hungry as I think it will never be close again just l8ke he majored Taylor.
 

LittleJ

Freshman
Oct 4, 2025
51
83
18
Unfortunately Duke forgot the valuable lesson he learned when he lost to Taylor in the Nebraska dual, do not let the opponent dictate the pace. Duke was more than willing to play Robideu's grab the fingers game and thus could not get any offense initiated. Certainly it did not help that the refs allowed Robideau to play that game and not hit him with stalling calls. What happened in OT is criminal. Again, if Duke dictates the pace, he wins. He did not and that allowed the ref to be a factor to decide the match. Painful lesson to re-learn.
Was is so much PJ forgetting or something else? From Big 10’s up to this last match PJ tore his opponent apart. He did not wrestle the same in this last match which begs the question of whether he had a bad strategy or was bothered by something else. While the okie st kid is good and effective, a healthy Duke beats him in regulation 9 out of 10. We can argue that Duke was robbed in SV - which he was, but it no longer matters.

How Duke performs today may give us some clues, but only he and the staff know for sure.
 

GOLFNIT85

Redshirt
Feb 9, 2018
14
11
3
@OhioLion -- the Quote function is not always working for me (too many windows opened, which is taxing the memory).

But to answer your question:

As I wrote, in my quick review I thought it was a TD, but the ref called it really early, and Robideau grabbed a leg just as the TD was whistled.

So it goes back to whether the review panel thought control was established. Duke had a cradle while Robideau had a leg, then Robideau lost the leg for a sec or two, then he got it back. The mat ref probably wishes he hadn't called it so early, though in SV, you are supposed to call it as soon as you think points are scored.

In looking at it again on replay, I'm not all that surprised it was overturned. Control wasn't established long enough. Would Duke have gotten control? We'll never know. Cradles don't generally break locks around the offensive wrestler's leg. If the offensive wrestler can put the defensive wrestler on their back, then the defensive wrestler usually releases the leg lock to try to roll off their back. Certainly not a sure thing, either way.
 

GOLFNIT85

Redshirt
Feb 9, 2018
14
11
3
@OhioLion -- the Quote function is not always working for me (too many windows opened, which is taxing the memory).

But to answer your question:

As I wrote, in my quick review I thought it was a TD, but the ref called it really early, and Robideau grabbed a leg just as the TD was whistled.

So it goes back to whether the review panel thought control was established. Duke had a cradle while Robideau had a leg, then Robideau lost the leg for a sec or two, then he got it back. The mat ref probably wishes he hadn't called it so early, though in SV, you are supposed to call it as soon as you think points are scored.

In looking at it again on replay, I'm not all that surprised it was overturned. Control wasn't established long enough. Would Duke have gotten control? We'll never know. Cradles don't generally break locks around the offensive wrestler's leg. If the offensive wrestler can put the defensive wrestler on their back, then the defensive wrestler usually releases the leg lock to try to roll off their back. Certainly not a sure thing, either way.
Just for reference official 17 got his *** handed to him after the match by Cody after the Duke screwing, walked to the officials seating area for several minutes, head of officials walked over to him and said something. He put his jacket on and left the Arena. Didn't see him the rest of the night. It seemed very weird.
 

SamAdamsColdSnap

Redshirt
Mar 5, 2026
3
1
1
The only reason PJ left NF criteria was because the mat ref stopped the bout when he shouldn’t have.
Half of people here claim the ref blew the whistle prematurely while the other half claim PJ should've finished his move. Which is it? And while we're at it please define what's a takedown. :>) I thought it constitutes control.
That said, the headline is five freshmen in the finals, four of whom are from OK State. Forget Iowa. Forget the Ferraris. That is the headline. As Willem Defoe said in 'Platoon', "The worm has turned for you, man." PJ will bounce back. So will Blaze who, BTW, needs to get stronger.
 

HOA242n!

Senior
Aug 18, 2025
219
549
93
You should get crap. It's a crap take man. But, it's a take nonetheless and I'm not here to change your mind. Have a good evening.well..morning lol
You can dislike my opinion as much as you want, Blaze went on to lose the next two against Davino. I had my reservations from the start that Blaze's defense-centric counterattacking style would be as dominant in NCAA folkstyle as it was as a prep, and as he was as a teenage phenom in freestyle.

Blaze happens to be IMO in a weight class that has 4 guys in 2yrs (Forrest, Davino, Seidel, and him) who would be multiple-time NCAA champs any other time. He's also the least dynamic of the four. He took apart the guys he should have this year, but can he get over the hump? I hope Blaze ends up the best of the bunch, but I can't say I'd be totally shocked if he ends up a 4x high-AA without an individual title. Maybe growth spreads them out and my opinion is moot anyway?

Cael is the best and he picked his guy, I'm just another shmuck on the internet with an opinion.
 
Last edited:

Misalorales

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2025
1,118
3,451
113
You can dislike my opinion as much as you want, Blaze went on to lose the next two against Davino. I had my reservations from the start that Blaze's defense-centric counterattacking style would be as dominant in NCAA folkstyle as it was as a prep, and as he was as a teenage phenom in freestyle.

Blaze happens to be IMO in a weight class that has 4 guys in 2yrs (Forrest, Davino, Seidel, and him) who would be multiple-time NCAA champs any other time. He's also the least dynamic of the four. He took apart the guys he should have this year, but can he get over the hump? I hope Blaze ends up the best of the bunch, and growth may spread them out the next few years; I wouldn't bet on it, but I can't say I'd be shocked if he ends up a 4x high-AA without an individual title.

Cael is the best and he picked his guy, I'm just another shmuck on the internet with an opinion.
Good morning. I slept on it. Still don't like. Lol Time will tell but his issue isn't the ability to get on offense, or lack of talent or strength or size or anything. It's game plan and style. He and duke both learned a brutal lesson at the worst time. Never let your opponent take it to SV. I'll stay bullish on blaze. Especially cause he may be the only one from the group of freshman that can even hold 133 long term.