2026 Predictions? What is best case/worst case scenario?

GrumpyDoc

Redshirt
Sep 22, 2025
7
5
3
I know we have Martinelli back which is huge. I know we have some interesting transfers. But the Conference slate is always super tough...

What is the most likely scenario this year? What does the best/worst case scenario look like?
 

macarthur31

Redshirt
Nov 9, 2006
1,536
39
48
Best case: these guys (Collins and the players) figure out their roles and chemistry quickly, and establish themselves as a tough, defensive team, that will generate pace/buckets off turnovers and will protect their glass. (I found it telling that Collins kept referring to Michigan State as a comparison in his presser; on first blush it was more about the 9/10 man rotations that Izzo has run, but I also intuit that Collins wants that toughness to be part of the 'Cats identity.). This leads to them being a surprise team in the B1G and finish 7th/8th.

Worst case: Collins own inexperience with running 9/10 man rotations effectively, and/or longterm injuries to Martinelli or Page take away their #1 catalysts on offense and defense respectively. Despite strong efforts, team loses more 1-2 possession games and they are at near bottom of table.

Likely: Team will be a tough out, but will be on bubble all season.
 

Hungry Jack

All-Conference
Nov 17, 2008
36,302
1,857
67
Worst: Martinelli gets hurt: 4-5 conference wins

Best: KJ plays like he did near the end of last season. Gelo and Mullins become reliable outside shooters. Page benefits from offensive options beyond Nick and gives us 8 - 10 ppg. Team defense comes together quickly. 20 wins and bubble team.
 

hdhntr1

Senior
Sep 5, 2006
36,113
625
113
Worst: Martinelli gets hurt: 4-5 conference wins

Best: KJ plays like he did near the end of last season. Gelo and Mullins become reliable outside shooters. Page benefits from offensive options beyond Nick and gives us 8 - 10 ppg. Team defense comes together quickly. 20 wins and bubble team.
Honestly as good as Martinelli has been, I don't think a loss of him this year would be any where near as bad as the loss of Barney last year. Have a ton more quality and experienced depth this year. Losing other guys might even have a bigger impact as D is so important to this team and that is the weakest part of his game and it looks like we have a few others ready to make a jump on O
 

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
25,825
1,297
113
Honestly as good as Martinelli has been, I don't think a loss of him this year would be any where near as bad as the loss of Barney last year. Have a ton more quality and experienced depth this year. Losing other guys might even have a bigger impact as D is so important to this team and that is the weakest part of his game and it looks like we have a few others ready to make a jump on O
Nick is clearly the Alpha. Option 1, 1A, 1B with the game on the line. Losing Nick would kill this team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AdamOnFirst

TheC

Senior
May 29, 2001
18,589
741
62
I am excited about this roster and the athleticism that seems off the charts compared to our history. That said, we only have one returning guy who has consistently performed at a high level against BIG competition. I think we may struggle some this year.
 
Dec 24, 2010
3,045
61
48
At the open practice, almost everyone showed a nice three point stroke. Most of them were able to handle the ball driving the lane.

Best case - the new kids figure out the defense, Nick and Page prove a dangerous inside force, creating tons of open looks from three, and our guys knock them down. 12 - 8 and a nice seed in March.

Worst case - someone gets hurt, the kids can't run the defense, and the team shoots 20% from three. 5-15 and we don't make the B1G tournament.

Middlin - we do a bit of both, but can't execute well enough against the top tier. 8-12, win a game in the B1G, miss out on the dance.
 

AdamOnFirst

Junior
Nov 29, 2021
8,468
331
83
WORST case? Martinelli turns into a sort of pumpkin (or gets hurt) and nobody else takes any steps forward or fills in gaps at the Big Ten level. The team finishes below .500 and only wins like 3 Big Ten games.

BEST case: Martinelli leads the Big Ten in scoring again and somehow adds yet another major complimentary piece to his game, be it in rebounding or defense. He challenges for Big Ten PoY as a 2nd or 3rd place finisher there. Guys like Arrington suddenly realizes his full potential and is a serious starting Big Ten big for 25-30 mpg. Reid and Green light it up as Big Ten wings and the outside offense absolutely clicks behind Martinelli. Singleton plays only 15-20 a game on a really good veteran team, but he looks like a future absolute star in those minutes and contends for conference 6th man of the year. Our other young-ish wings all take strong development steps as well, explaining why Singleton can't get more, and we have a deep team of guys who come at you from all over the place. We win like 12+ Big Ten games, easily make the tournament, score a second round upset into the sweet 16, and enter the offseason looking to just add the right complimentary pieces in the portal to fit our developing young and returning stars who are projected to be solidly in the top half of the league next year even by a media who underrates us.
 

TheC

Senior
May 29, 2001
18,589
741
62
WORST case? Martinelli turns into a sort of pumpkin (or gets hurt) and nobody else takes any steps forward or fills in gaps at the Big Ten level. The team finishes below .500 and only wins like 3 Big Ten games.

BEST case: Martinelli leads the Big Ten in scoring again and somehow adds yet another major complimentary piece to his game, be it in rebounding or defense. He challenges for Big Ten PoY as a 2nd or 3rd place finisher there. Guys like Arrington suddenly realizes his full potential and is a serious starting Big Ten big for 25-30 mpg. Reid and Green light it up as Big Ten wings and the outside offense absolutely clicks behind Martinelli. Singleton plays only 15-20 a game on a really good veteran team, but he looks like a future absolute star in those minutes and contends for conference 6th man of the year. Our other young-ish wings all take strong development steps as well, explaining why Singleton can't get more, and we have a deep team of guys who come at you from all over the place. We win like 12+ Big Ten games, easily make the tournament, score a second round upset into the sweet 16, and enter the offseason looking to just add the right complimentary pieces in the portal to fit our developing young and returning stars who are projected to be solidly in the top half of the league next year even by a media who underrates us.
I will sign up for your blog right now! Love it!!
 

prez77

Freshman
Dec 27, 2024
358
99
22
I think the best case is bubble tourney team if we get great interior defense and Windham is a 15 point scorer without taking too many shots. The floor could be really low if the transfers aren't great, the first years play like first years and KJ doesn't shoot great.
 

SDakaGordie

Redshirt
Dec 29, 2016
2,098
29
38
I think the best case is bubble tourney team if we get great interior defense and Windham is a 15 point scorer without taking too many shots. The floor could be really low if the transfers aren't great, the first years play like first years and KJ doesn't shoot great.
I feel stronger positive vibes. While interior foul trouble and defense is a concern, I think others are not. Our transfers are / will be the best group we’ve ever had. Same as our first years. And KJ will be just fine, especially without the primary ball handling burden.