24 team CFP

Fanaticat98

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
9,644
1,171
113
Lots of bowl games could die. I think the 24 team playoff may actually lead more programs to invest in football, because the bar is now basically finishing the regular season ranked, to be in the elite “we made the playoff” tier and with the parity we’ve seen between top 5-10 and fringe top 25 teams, you could make a deep run in the playoffs with the right bounces.
 

Baz = Heisman

Senior
Aug 15, 2025
728
449
63
Lots of bowl games could die. I think the 24 team playoff may actually lead more programs to invest in football, because the bar is now basically finishing the regular season ranked, to be in the elite “we made the playoff” tier and with the parity we’ve seen between top 5-10 and fringe top 25 teams, you could make a deep run in the playoffs with the right bounces.
My point is it completely waters down the regular season. It’s basically pointless now.
 

RiseNorthwestern

Redshirt
Mar 6, 2009
76
11
7
My point is it completely waters down the regular season. It’s basically pointless now.
Not so sure. If anything it would have more casual fan interested in more games to see who can make the playoffs instead of just the teams at the top. Also, hopefully it leads to top teams scheduling hard teams instead of cupcakes.

I just know as a Northwestern fan, I would be more interested in this regular season right now in a 24 team format than the current construct.
 

Baz = Heisman

Senior
Aug 15, 2025
728
449
63
Not so sure. If anything it would have more casual fan interested in more games to see who can make the playoffs instead of just the teams at the top. Also, hopefully it leads to top teams scheduling hard teams instead of cupcakes.

I just know as a Northwestern fan, I would be more interested in this regular season right now in a 24 team format than the current construct.
You want to see 8-4 teams in the playoff? Really? Screw that. It should be an accomplishment. I want us to make it legitimately. We can make it with 12 too.
 

Catmandoo78

Junior
Nov 12, 2025
511
303
63
You want to see 8-4 teams in the playoff? Really? Screw that. It should be an accomplishment. I want us to make it legitimately. We can make it with 12 too.
In the last 30 years, how many of our teams would’ve made the 12 team playoff? I’m pretty sure it’s zero.

You could maybe make the outside case that we could’ve made it in 2020, where we finished ranked 10. But that’s such a weird season where so many games got cancelled or teams were shorthanded that I don’t really have a clue what selection wouldn’t looked like.
 

Baz = Heisman

Senior
Aug 15, 2025
728
449
63
In the last 30 years, how many of our teams would’ve made the 12 team playoff? I’m pretty sure it’s zero.

You could maybe make the outside case that we could’ve made it in 2020, where we finished ranked 10. But that’s such a weird season where so many games got cancelled or teams were shorthanded that I don’t really have a clue what selection wouldn’t looked like.
We’ve been “in the hunt” for the 12 teamer numerous times since 2010. Off the top of my head, 2012, 2018, 2020, this year before last week.
 

CappyNU

Senior
Mar 2, 2004
5,400
749
113
We’ve been “in the hunt” for the 12 teamer numerous times since 2010. Off the top of my head, 2012, 2018, 2020, this year before last week.
In 2012 we were not in the hunt, we had two losses by October 20th. 2015 we would've been in the hunt for sure, though I think our two blowout losses to the best teams we played would've kept us out. 2018 we were definitely never in the hunt with 3 losses in September and never getting above #19. 2020, sure, but that was a goofy year with Covid.
 

AstroCat

Freshman
Sep 17, 2002
5,318
61
48
I think the 24-team playoff is a mistake. I much prefer the 12-team format. There is a huge drop-off in quality somewhere beyond 12 teams, and the 24th best team is simply a good team -- not a great one.

With 24-teams, that will start to eliminate the tier 2 and tier 3 bowl games, and some of those were in nice locations. I hope the Citrus Bowl, Alamo Bowl, and Sun Bowl survive.

As for post-season games in mid-December, I think most fans would rather go to a neutral, warm-weather site, than as visitors to a frigid Ann Arbor or Columbus.

I will also miss the conference championship games. The BIG had one for only 15 years, but it was game I always looked forward to watching.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Baz = Heisman
Wildcat Report

Latest

  1. 01 Wildcat Report Behind Enemy Lines: Minnesota
  2. 02 Wildcat Report Northwestern at Ohio State PFF Grades Analysis
  3. 03 Wildcat Report Northwestern working to support, improve QB Nicco Marchiol ahead of Minnesota
  4. 04 Wildcat Report Northwestern embarrassed by Columbia, 75-53
  5. 05 Wildcat Report Notebook: Braun looks to snap three-game losing streak at Minnesota