ACC officials

rockycard

Heisman
Jan 8, 2007
129,782
10,816
0
How did they miss the targeting call when Quick got knocked out? The uk dude lunged from 5 yards away right at his head, that is the type of hit that the rule is trying to prevent.
 

CardX

Heisman
May 29, 2001
254,750
19,564
0
I'll give ACC refs credit. They are consistent. Consistently awful.
 

shamcard

Freshman
Apr 20, 2013
474
50
0
How did they miss the targeting call when Quick got knocked out? The uk dude lunged from 5 yards away right at his head, that is the type of hit that the rule is trying to prevent.
The targeting rule is theory and is difficult to apply to a fluid game. How often have you watched a replay of a targeting call and noticed that the defender had left his feet when the receiver went up for the ball, and would have struck receiver in the numbers or lower, but for the receiver falling down with the momentum of the catch.
In the Quick situation he had leaped high (like he had on his previous TD) to catch the ball. The UK defender appeared to react instinctively to that action but hit Quick when he neared the ground. Considering the UK player got wiped out as well Quick, I doubt that the hit that occurred was planned.
 

teamcanada

Senior
Aug 27, 2007
925
753
0
The targeting rule is theory and is difficult to apply to a fluid game. How often have you watched a replay of a targeting call and noticed that the defender had left his feet when the receiver went up for the ball, and would have struck receiver in the numbers or lower, but for the receiver falling down with the momentum of the catch.
In the Quick situation he had leaped high (like he had on his previous TD) to catch the ball. The UK defender appeared to react instinctively to that action but hit Quick when he neared the ground. Considering the UK player got wiped out as well Quick, I doubt that the hit that occurred was planned.
Neared the ground? He had taken two steps. Intent has nothing to do with it being targeting or not.
 

birdie king

All-Conference
Aug 10, 2002
14,806
2,652
0
I haven't heard a word on any discipline for the ACC officials who botched the Miami-Duke and Clemson-UNC games. Has anyone heard anything yet ?