Had me till you said Edward's was starting to look like the number 1 recruit. In what world? He hit a few shots yes but anyone could tell he was in no way the number 1 recruit.
I guess it was really just the Alabama Game.. but he had 28 points on nearly perfect efficiency.. only missed one free throw. That game was when a lot of us said "Ok, there he is!". But we also knew it was baby steps, that he didn't just become Kobe overnight. But if you check his splits, his shooting percentages really started to stabilize in the 2nd semester. For example, in November/December he shot 9/35 (25%) from the 3. From January on he was 22/50 (44%).
I think the other difference is that Edwards' game, like any forward, is greatly impacted by the guys getting them the ball. And that was DJ lol. We saw SO many times that those two weren't on the same page, which was probably both of their faults. But I think forwards, especially offensive ones like Edwards, need a bit more time to get the chemistry down with the ball handler.
I guess another way of saying it is.. No one made DJ better. He proved that he really couldn't work well with anyone. He just kind of sucked. But at least with Edwards, there was a chance he just had the wrong PG feeding him. Take a look at that Alabama game's box score. Reed and Dilly each played MORE minutes than DJ.. And they combined for 10 assists while DJ had 4. They also combined for 60% 3pt shooting and made 24 pts combined... DJ? scored 4 points and was 0 for 4 from the 3. That game SHOULD have been all the proof that we needed, that a combination of Reeves/Dilly/Reed was probably all that was needed to bring Edwards' game out. And with those 4 getting the most minutes, they wound up shelling a Final4 team that was only stopped by Uconn..
I believe DJ (and the family relationship that forced Cal to play him) is the main reason that sunk this team.