Are the Mannings the greatest family dynasty in sports history?

DCFseattle

All-American
Mar 16, 2011
10,808
7,914
0
That's lazy analysis. Namath threw more interceptions than touchdowns and had a career rating of 65. He is in the hall. Jim Kelly threw a lot of interceptions compared to his touchdowns and had a career rating of 84 and no Super Bowl rings. He is in the hall. Eli will be in the hall of fame. I think he will be a first ballot but that is debatable. Eli actually getting in is not debatable.

You forgot Favre, with the all-time record for interceptions and only one super bowl.
 

ORCAT

Heisman
Jan 6, 2003
24,474
11,562
113
That's lazy analysis. Namath threw more interceptions than touchdowns and had a career rating of 65. He is in the hall. Jim Kelly threw a lot of interceptions compared to his touchdowns and had a career rating of 84 and no Super Bowl rings. He is in the hall. Eli will be in the hall of fame. I think he will be a first ballot but that is debatable. Eli actually getting in is not debatable.

Totally agree, Eli will be in the Hall, no doubt about it. Can't believe that other poster just keeps carrying on in such a negative way about Eli when there are far less successful QB's already in the Hall. All I can figure out is that he just doesn't like the Mannings and maybe Eli in particular but there is absolutely no doubt he will be voted in.
 

JohnnyGentle

Senior
Nov 6, 2007
1,559
675
0
christ didn't favre win multiple mvps? namath played 50 years ago

eli manning has never been a top 5 qb in the league. it's unclear whether he's the second or third best qb in his own draft class

he's going to get in the HOF because of his surname, playing in new york, and being on two super bowl winners, but he doesn't deserve it. and he, his brother, and his dad are all f--king weirdo creeps